novareads.musicMusical

West Side Story

1957

A single uneasy interval hidden in one whistled phrase begins as a signal for a fight, becomes the name of a beloved, and remains, to the very end, never quite resolved.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. Origins1957 US premiereRomeo and JulietRobbins's idea2. IntervalTritoneResolving up a half stepMotif of hope3. DancePrologueMambo at the gymCool fugue4. SongMariaTonight quintetSomewhere5. Film1961 film10 Academy AwardsReordered numbers6. LegacySymphonic DancesSpielberg remakeStory1957Romeo and Juliet carried into the back alleys …

The creators ⏳🌊

  • ComposerLeonard Bernstein

    A conductor and composer who, after On the Town, joined forces with Robbins once more and wove classical music, jazz and Latin rhythms into a single score.

  • LyricsStephen Sondheim

    Made a Broadway debut at twenty-five with the lyrics for this show, and later became the composer of Sweeney Todd and other works.

  • BookArthur Laurents

    Wrote the book and set the story not in Los Angeles but on the streets of New York's West Side.

  • DirectorJerome Robbins

    Conceived the work, directed and choreographed the stage production, and co-directed the 1961 film with Robert Wise, sharing the Academy Award for Best Director.

  • LeadChita Rivera

    Played Anita in the original production and led the number America.

  • LeadRita Moreno

    Won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress as Anita in the 1961 film, and returned for the 2021 film in a new role while also serving as executive producer.

Play all 8 on YouTube ↗

I. A back-alley Romeo and Juliet

(Conception) In 1949 the choreographer Jerome Robbins proposed moving Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet” to present-day New York. It was first conceived as a tragedy between a Catholic family and a Jewish family on the Lower East Side, under the working title “East Side Story.” The plan then lay dormant for nearly five years. It came back to life in 1955, when the playwright Arthur Laurents and Bernstein, at a hotel in Los Angeles, got to talking about a newspaper story on Mexican American youth gangs. The setting shifted to Manhattan’s West Side, to streets where young Puerto Rican immigrants and young white working-class men collided. (Composer) Leonard Bernstein was then a conductor and composer nearing forty. Bernstein and Robbins had already made the ballet “Fancy Free” and the musical “On the Town” together in 1944, and Bernstein moved freely among classical music, jazz and Broadway. Bernstein wanted to write the piece in a form close to opera, but Robbins and Laurents wanted something lighter, a lyric theater piece. Out of this tug-of-war came the form we know today, in which song, dance and drama move as one body. (Lyrics) At first Bernstein meant to write the lyrics as well. But Laurents brought in a twenty-five-year-old newcomer, Stephen Sondheim, and during the Washington tryout Bernstein voluntarily gave up the co-lyricist credit. (Premiere) The curtain rose on September 26, 1957, at Broadway’s Winter Garden Theatre, and the show ran for 732 performances. The orchestrations were done by Sid Ramin and Irwin Kostal, following Bernstein’s meticulous instructions. Kostal later also orchestrated the film versions of “Mary Poppins” and “The Sound of Music,” both covered in this series. Robert Wise, who co-directed the 1961 film, was also the director of “The Sound of Music.”

II. The fingers speak first

(Whistle) When the curtain rises, whistles and finger snaps are heard before a single line of dialogue. The Jets stroll down the street, and the Sharks block their way. Without a song, the two gangs push against each other with gesture and rhythm alone. Within minutes, the “Prologue” tells us that this story will move through dance and music before it moves through words. (Tritone) That whistled signal holds an interval that threads through the entire work: the tritone, a span of three whole tones laid end to end. Shunned by old music theorists as unsettling, this interval sharpens the edge of the fight in the “Prologue” and the “Jet Song,” and later returns wearing an entirely different face. (Street) The 1961 film opens the scene with aerial shots high above Manhattan and then descends into real streets. Once the stage’s abstract space became a genuine alley, the dancing grew rougher and broader too. Soon after, in the “Jet Song,” the Jets loudly proclaim their loyalty to the gang and their pride, and Riff, their leader, decides to bring Tony, a former comrade, to that night’s dance. (Premonition) Tony, who has left the gang to work in a shop, is left alone to sing “Something’s Coming.” It is a song of expectation, of something drawing near that cannot yet be named. Over a quick, restless beat the melody keeps leaning forward, but Tony does not know what it is. According to the scholar Steven Suskin, the only compositional contribution Sondheim made to this work was polishing this song’s refrain.

♪Prologue1957Film scene — West Side Story (1961)

These are the opening minutes, in which whistles, finger snaps and dance alone, without a song, establish the relationship between the two gangs.

  • The first interval of the whistled signal is the tritone, an unsettling interval spanning three whole tones. The entire work grows from this single interval.
  • Finger snaps and brief silences alternate, creating a tension that seems ready to explode even though no one is fighting yet.
  • Percussion carries so much weight that five of the 31 players in the original stage orchestra were percussionists. Drums and cymbals mark the movement like the actors’ footsteps.
  • The film version opens with aerial shots above Manhattan and captured Robbins’s choreography in real streets. This dance is also often performed in concert as the first number of the “Symphonic Dances.”
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. Mambo in the gym

(The dance) At the neighborhood gym dance, the two gangs dance apart on the same floor. “The Dance at the Gym” is a suite of dances running through blues, promenade, mambo, cha-cha, meeting scene and jump. The emcee tries to mix the two groups, but when the mambo arrives and the brass and percussion burst forth, the dance turns into a confrontation. (The meeting) In the middle of that uproar, Tony and Maria see each other. Maria is the younger sister of Bernardo, leader of the Sharks. The music subsides as though everything around them were blurring, and a quiet cha-cha plays; its melody previews, as a dance, the tune of “Maria,” which Tony will soon sing. Love, in other words, is already present in the music before any words. (The name) After the dance, Tony sings “Maria,” repeating the name just learned. Here the tritone that stood for the fight returns, but this time it rises at once by a half step to arrive at a stable note. This movement, in which an unstable note is released into a restful one, is called resolution. The same interval that is a threat in the gang’s song becomes a thrill in Tony’s. (The balcony) Tony seeks out the fire escape of Maria’s building, and together the two sing “Tonight,” wishing the night would never end. Shakespeare’s balcony scene has moved to the iron stairway of a Manhattan tenement. On stage this duet comes before “America,” but in the film it was moved after “America.”

♪The Dance at the Gym1957Conducted by Gustavo Dudamel · Simón Bolívar SO “Mambo”

Inside a single gym the two gangs’ dances collide, and in the middle of that uproar Tony and Maria meet for the first time.

  • A medley of dances in which blues, promenade, mambo, cha-cha, meeting scene and jump follow one another without pause. Each time the kind of dance changes, so does the relationship between the two groups.
  • In the mambo, brass and Latin percussion explode all at once and the dancers shout. It is the moment the dance becomes a trial of strength.
  • The suddenly hushed cha-cha recasts the melody of the song “Maria,” still to come, as a dance. Even before the two learn each other’s names, the music is already singing of love.
  • A performance of the mambo from the “Symphonic Dances” by the Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra under Gustavo Dudamel became widely known, and this passage is now beloved as a concert encore as well.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Maria1957Sung by Aaron Tveit · 2017 New York Phil New Year’s Eve

It is the song Tony sings alone after the dance, holding on to a single name just learned.

  • In the first three notes that call out the name, the tritone appears and at once rises a half step to settle comfortably (resolution). The interval that was a threat in the Prologue becomes a thrill here.
  • As the same name is repeated endlessly, the accompaniment waits, laid low, while the song climbs higher and higher and the feeling swells.
  • These three notes reappear throughout the work, used like a leitmotif for Maria and for love.
  • On the original stage it was sung by Larry Kert. In the film, the songs of Tony, played by Richard Beymer, were dubbed by Jim Bryant.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. Two Americas

(Immigration) That same night on a rooftop, Anita, Bernardo’s girlfriend, and the Shark women sing as though quarreling over their homeland, Puerto Rico, and their new land, America. This song is “America.” When one side longs for the island they left behind, the other strikes back by touting the conveniences of life here. A hemiola, alternating a rhythm that divides six beats into two with one that divides them into three, sets the meter askew and gives the argument its spring. (Adaptation) What on stage was a dispute among women, the film turned into a contest between men and women. Sondheim reworked the lyrics for the film, bringing the discrimination immigrants face more directly into view. (Composure) The two gangs gather at the drugstore and settle on a rumble. On stage, “Cool,” led by Riff, is both a song and a dance urging them to hold down their excitement. It uses a fugue, in which several voices take up a single melody in turn over a jazz rhythm, and its subject, too, contains the tritone. The film moves this number after the rumble, turning it into a scene in which the leaderless gang holds back an explosion. (Vows) The next day, in the bridal shop where Maria works, the two sing “One Hand, One Heart,” acting out wedding vows with mannequins for guests. The melody was originally written for “Candide.” (Quintet) On the night before the rumble comes the “Tonight” quintet. Tony and Maria await the hour they will meet again, Anita the night she will spend with her lover, and the two gangs the rumble. Through counterpoint, layering different melodies at once, five strands of waiting converge in a single moment.

♪America1957Sung by the 2021 film cast · West Side Story

On a rooftop, Anita and the Sharks quarrel in song over their home island and their new land.

  • The heart of it is the hemiola rhythm, alternating between dividing six beats into twos and into threes. The meter staggers as if missing a step, giving spring to the back-and-forth quarrel.
  • This rhythm is often described as recalling the huapango, a Mexican folk dance. Handclaps and Latin percussion form the rhythm’s backbone.
  • On the original stage it was a dispute among women led by Chita Rivera’s Anita, and the film turned it into a contest between men and women, reworking the lyrics as well.
  • Rita Moreno, who played Anita in the film, and George Chakiris, who played Bernardo, won the Academy Awards for Best Supporting Actress and Best Supporting Actor, respectively.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Cool1957Film scene — West Side Story (1961)

It is a jazz number that, before the rumble, or in the film after the rumble is over, urges them to rein in their seething rage.

  • Over a low, slow jazz rhythm, finger snaps keep the beat, and the whole piece holds itself on the brink of bursting.
  • Midway, a fugue unfolds in which several instruments take up a single melody one after another. As it piles up like a round, the pent-up energy grows and grows.
  • The fugue’s subject also contains the tritone, so the unease of the Prologue keeps sounding beneath a song that urges calm.
  • On stage Riff leads it before the rumble, and in the film Ice leads it after the rumble. With the change in order, the number’s meaning shifts to a song of holding back grief and rage.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Tonight Quintet1957Film scene — West Side Story (1961)

On the night before the rumble, the different kinds of waiting of five characters and two gangs overlap at once within a single number.

  • Tony and Maria's love song, Anita's anticipation and the two gangs' vows to fight all flow at once, each with its own words and melody. This technique of layering several melodies together is called counterpoint.
  • Above the gangs' fast, sharp rhythms, the balcony scene's “Tonight” melody rises up in full voice. We hear with our own ears that love and violence are waiting for the same night.
  • It carries on the tradition of the operatic ensemble, in which several characters sing their private thoughts at the same time. It sounds like the passage where Bernstein's wish to write the work like an opera shows most clearly.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. Night under the highway

(The fight) The rumble breaks out under the highway. In “The Rumble,” the orchestra piles short, sharp figures one on top of another, carrying over the very speed of the brawl. Tony steps in to stop the fight, but when the knives come out the leaders of both gangs fall, and one of them falls by Tony's hand. Act I ends in that shock. (Irony) On stage, Act II opens with Maria, who knows nothing, singing “I Feel Pretty.” A light song in triple time, a girl in love giddy before the mirror, becomes irony when set before a tragedy only the audience knows. In the film the number was moved ahead of the rumble, and that shadow vanished. (Dream) Tony comes to Maria, and in “Somewhere” the two dream of a place without violence. On stage the lovers do not sing it themselves. It unfolds as a dream ballet in which the two gangs dance together while a girl's voice sings from offstage. The film reduced the scene to a duet for the pair. The song's opening melody becomes a leitmotif standing for hope and follows the work to its end. (Satire) Meanwhile the Jets, collared by a policeman, seize the moment to sing “Gee, Officer Krupke.” It is a vaudeville-style satire mimicking what a judge, a psychiatrist and a social worker say about juvenile delinquents. Set in the middle of the tragedy, this laughter instead lays bare the dead end the kids are trapped in. In the film this number, too, was moved ahead of the rumble and sung by Riff.

♪Somewhere1957Live Nadine Sierra (soprano) · 2018 Berlin

After the rumble, the two lovers dream of a place with neither violence nor hatred, and this melody follows the work to its end.

  • At the opening, the melody leaps up nearly seven notes in a single bound (a leap of a minor seventh). Some have pointed out that this leap resembles the opening melody of the second movement of Beethoven's “Emperor” Piano Concerto.
  • On stage it unfolds as a dream ballet in which the two gangs dance together while an offstage girl's voice sings; in the film it became a duet for Tony and Maria.
  • The opening melody becomes a leitmotif standing for hope and returns in the final scene. It is worth listening closely to what the same melody has come to mean by then.
  • Sung by many singers, including Barbra Streisand and Tom Waits, it is widely loved as a standalone song outside the show as well.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. The song that remains

(Confrontation) Anita hurls “A Boy Like That” at Maria, a razor-edged song telling her to forget a man like that. Maria answers with “I Have a Love,” refusing to bend in her love. The two women's voices face off within a single number, until Anita's melody gradually leans toward Maria's and at last the two sing together. By the time the song ends, one character's heart has changed. (Crossed paths) From there the story tips swiftly as misunderstanding and chance pile up. Bernstein wrote almost no new songs for this stretch. Where events outrun song, the music sustains the tension by briefly calling back motifs heard earlier. (Finale) In the final scene the music offers no new melody but quietly calls back “Somewhere.” What that dreamed-of place has now come to mean, the melody says in place of words. In the last chord, over a bright C major, the bass stubbornly holds an F# a tritone away, so the curtain falls without ever fully resolving. The interval that began in the Prologue's whistle thus lingers to the very end. (Legacy) The 1961 film was nominated for Academy Awards in 11 categories and won 10, including Best Picture and Best Scoring of a Musical Picture. The soundtrack album stayed at the top of the Billboard stereo album chart for 54 weeks. In 1960 Bernstein arranged the music into the orchestral suite “Symphonic Dances,” and in 1985 he himself conducted and recorded the complete score with opera singers. In 2021 Steven Spielberg brought the work to the screen once again.

♪A Boy Like That / I Have a Love1957Vocals Julie Andrews·Carol Burnett · 1962 Carnegie Hall

A furious Anita and an unyielding Maria face off within a single number, until at last they come to sing the same song.

  • Anita's song drives low and rough, while Maria's soars high and long. The difference in the pitch of their voices is the very difference in where the two stand.
  • The number joins two songs into one. As Maria's melody seems to draw Anita in and the two end up singing together, a change of heart takes place within a single song.
  • In the film, Betty Wand sang part of the songs of Anita, played by Rita Moreno. This number is cited as the prime example.
Listen on YouTube ↗

The lesser-known story

Today the work's recordings rank among the great bestsellers, but the start was anything but smooth. Columbia Records at first declined to record the original cast album, saying the score was too dark and too difficult. In the end Goddard Lieberson took on the production and recorded it three days after the premiere, yet it was not until 1962, after the film came out, that the album climbed high on the charts and went gold. Eclipsed by the film soundtrack's record-breaking success, this hesitation was easily forgotten. Bernstein wrote this work and “Candide” during the same period, and music passed between the two scores. The music of “Gee, Officer Krupke” came from the Venice scene of “Candide,” and “One Hand, One Heart” was first conceived as a song for Cunégonde. Because “Candide” failed at the box office at its 1956 premiere, this connection long remained in the footnotes of scholarly studies. Years later, in his lyrics collection Finishing the Hat, Sondheim harshly criticized several of the work's lyrics himself. He felt, for instance, that the witty wordplay of “I Feel Pretty” did not suit a character like Maria. The lyricist of a signature work turned out to be the harshest judge of his own lyrics. Some scenes of the 1961 film were shot on real streets slated for demolition under the Lincoln Square redevelopment. This was the San Juan Hill area, home to many Black and Puerto Rican residents, and Lincoln Center rose where it was torn down. In recent years Lincoln Center has revisited this history itself through an initiative called “The Legacy of San Juan Hill.”

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Tritone

(Word origin) The Korean samoneum ('three whole tones', 三全音) means a distance of three (三) whole tones (全音) joined end to end. The English tritone likewise means three whole tones. In the Middle Ages it was shunned as unsettling to the ear and nicknamed the devil in music. (In film·musical scores) These are two notes six half steps apart, such as C and the F# above it on the piano keyboard. Pressed together, they make a sound that is uneasy and wants to move somewhere. In “West Side Story” this interval runs like a thread through the whole work, from the Prologue's whistle to “Cool,” “Maria” and the final chord. Think of it as the sound of a mind that cannot settle, like the night before an exam.

Resolution

(Word origin) The Korean haegyeol ('untie and settle', 解決) means to untie (解) what is knotted and bring it to a close (決). In music, too, it is used in the sense of releasing tension and bringing things to rest. (In film·musical scores) It is the movement of a note or chord that sounds unstable toward one that sounds at ease. In “Maria,” the tritone rising at once by a half step and settling is exactly a resolution. Conversely, when the resolution never comes, the listener keeps waiting for something. Recall the jolt when the last step on a staircase is lower than you expected, and the relief when your foot finally lands on it. (Elsewhere) In everyday use it means working out a problem or conflict and putting it to rest.

Leitmotif

(Word origin) The German Leitmotiv means a leading (leit) motive (Motiv). The Korean term yudodonggi ('guiding motive', 誘導動機) likewise carries the sense of a short musical idea that leads the listener. (In film·musical scores) It is a short melody that recurs whenever a particular character, feeling or idea appears. In this work, the opening melody of “Somewhere” points to hope and the three notes of “Maria” to love, and both return many times. When the same melody comes back in another scene, the memory of its earlier appearance rises with it. It is like a game where the same music always plays just before a certain boss appears, so you know who is coming before you even see the screen.

Counterpoint

(Word origin) The English counterpoint comes from the Latin punctus contra punctum, that is, note (point) against note. It means weaving music by setting a note of another melody against each note of one melody. (In film·musical scores) It is the compositional technique of sounding several different melodies at once while weaving them so that each keeps its own shape. That the lovers, Anita and the two gangs in the “Tonight” quintet can each sing a different song at the same time and still be heard as one piece of music is thanks to counterpoint. Picture a classroom where several groups each shout a different chant, yet the beats line up so perfectly that it sounds like a single cheer.

Fugue

(Word origin) Fuga means flight, escape, in Latin and Italian. The name comes from the way one melody runs off ahead and another voice comes in chasing after it. (In film·musical scores) It is a form in which a single short theme is taken up in turn by several voices or instruments entering one after another at staggered intervals, building up layer by layer. Bach is its foremost composer, and in “Cool” Bernstein set this old form over jazz rhythms to express pent-up tension. It is similar to a round, in which the next singer follows the same tune one bar later. In a fugue, however, the entering voice sings it at a different pitch.

Hemiola

(Word origin) Hemiola comes from the Greek hemiolios, meaning one and a half, that is, a ratio of 3 to 2. The name captures the rhythmic shift of dividing the same span into three and then into two. (In film·musical scores) It is a rhythmic technique that sets the beat askew by grouping the same span of time sometimes in threes and sometimes in twos. In “America,” counting six beats as one-two-three-one-two-three and then switching to one-two-one-two-one-two is the classic example. That feeling when a friend suddenly changes the rhythm of the jump rope and your foot almost misses a step is the very flavor of hemiola that breathes life into a dance tune.

Orchestration

(Word origin) Orchestra comes from the orchestra of the ancient Greek theater, the place in front of the stage where the chorus danced. Orchestration came to mean dividing up the music among those players. (In film·musical scores) It is the work of deciding which instruments will play the composer's melodies and harmonies, when and how, and turning them into an actual score. On Broadway the composer and the orchestrator often work separately. For this work, too, Sid Ramin and Irwin Kostal produced the score for an ensemble of 31 players based on Bernstein's detailed instructions. Just as the same recipe tastes different depending on what dish you use and how much of each ingredient you put in, the same melody sounds entirely different played by a violin and by a trumpet. (Elsewhere) In computing, coordinating several servers or programs so they run together is called orchestration.