novareads.musicMusical

Singin' in the Rain

1952

Hardly any of the songs were new; most were popular tunes some twenty years old. And yet the charm of this film's music lies in how those songs sound as though they had been written for this story from the start.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. OriginsUS release 1952Old Freed·Brown songsComden·Green screenplay2. Era1927 HollywoodFrom silent to soundThe Jazz Singer shock3. ThemesWhose voice it isSound and picture apartFilm reflecting film4. Great scenesTap dancing in the rainMake 'Em LaughGood Morning5. MusicJukebox musicalBroadway balletHayton as music director6. LegacyAFI's top musical1983 London stage1985 BroadwayRain1952As silent films were finding their voice, a ne…
Settings of the story 🧭🗺️
NUnited States of AmericaFranceHollywoodParisBroadway, New York

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The makers ⏳🌊

  • ComposerNacio Herb Brown

    The songs he had written for MGM talkies from around 1929 became the backbone of the film, and he also wrote new music for the ballet sequence.

  • ProducerArthur Freed

    A lyricist turned producer who wrote songs with Brown, he was the first to propose building an entire film out of their old songs.

  • DirectorStanley Donen

    Co-directing and co-choreographing with Gene Kelly, he wove the old songs into a single story.

  • LeadGene Kelly

    He played Don Lockwood while also serving as co-director and choreographer, and the dance in the rain secured his place in film history.

  • StarringDebbie Reynolds

    Cast as Kathy Selden, she held her own beside Kelly and O'Connor in “Good Morning” though she was not a trained dancer.

  • ConductorLennie Hayton

    As music director he refashioned the old songs in the sound of the 1950s MGM orchestra, earning an Academy Award nomination for scoring of a musical picture.

Play all 8 on YouTube ↗

I. The songs came first

(Catalog) “Singin' in the Rain” is a film in which the songs came before the story. Arthur Freed, the MGM producer, wanted to gather into one picture the songs he had written as a lyricist with the composer Nacio Herb Brown. Most of them had been written between 1929 and the mid-1930s for the early talkies, just as Hollywood was finding its voice. The screenwriters Betty Comden and Adolph Green set their story in the very era that gave birth to those songs, the moment when silent film was giving way to sound. (Composer) Brown was born in 1896 in Deming, New Mexico, and grew up in Los Angeles. As a young man he ran a tailor's shop and then made his fortune in real estate, writing and playing music on the side. He joined MGM in 1928 and began writing for the talkies, and with Freed as his partner he produced the songs for early movie musicals such as “The Broadway Melody” and “The Hollywood Revue of 1929.” He even made an appearance of his own in “The Hollywood Revue of 1929.” This 1952 film was less a new score from his pen than a gathering place for the songs he had already left behind. (Crew) Gene Kelly and Stanley Donen shared the direction and choreography, and the music director Lennie Hayton refashioned the old songs in the lush sound of the 1950s MGM orchestra. Within the studio, it is said, the project was at first regarded as nothing out of the ordinary. Set beside “Chicago,” which takes the show business of the same era as its stage and explores the gap between appearances and the true voice, it reveals two ways in which Hollywood has looked back on the entertainment of the 1920s.

II. The two faces of the red carpet

(Premiere) Hollywood, 1927. The silent-film stars Don Lockwood and Lina Lamont arrive at the premiere of their new picture. Before the reporters, Don tells how he was raised in a cultured family and pursued an actor's career with dignity. But the screen shows us the very opposite: the days when he drifted through neighborhood saloons and cheap vaudeville stages with his sidekick Cosmo Brown, and threw himself around as a stuntman. (Off the beat) The comedy of this scene comes from the mismatch between words and pictures. Over Don's genteel narration plays “Fit as a Fiddle,” in which the two men dance absurdly with violins in hand, and from the very first scene the audience understands that the film will be about the distance between what is said on the surface and what is really there. Later on, sound and image falling out of step becomes the central event of the story; here it appears once beforehand, in the form of a joke. (Meeting) Chased by fans, Don leaps into a passing car, whose driver, Kathy Selden, is an aspiring stage actress who looks down on movie actors. The two part after a quarrel. At a party that night the studio head demonstrates a picture that talks, but the guests laugh it off as a passing fad. Then Kathy bursts out of a giant cake and sings “All I Do Is Dream of You” with the chorus girls. To see her, who swore she would devote herself to serious theater, singing a giddy flapper dance tune is both embarrassing and endearing. The commotion ends at last with a slice of cake flying into Lina's face.

♪Fit as a FiddleFilm scene — Gene Kelly·Donald O'Connor

This is the passage where the dignified past Don recounts to the reporters collides head-on with the vaudeville years shown on screen.

  • Over Don's genteel narration, the two men saw away at violins and dance comically. This scene, where words and pictures clash, previews the theme of the whole film as a joke.
  • Strictly speaking, this is not a Brown song. Written in 1932 with music by Al Hoffman and Al Goodhart and lyrics by Freed, it came from Freed's catalog.
  • The routine of mixing tap dance with pretending to play the violin carries over intact the conventions of variety shows (vaudeville), where song, dance and gags were all performed at once on stage.
  • On the official soundtrack LP it appears as a duet by Gene Kelly and Donald O'Connor. The double act these two actors perform throughout the film first takes shape in this number.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪All I Do Is Dream of YouFilm scene — Debbie Reynolds

A dance tune sung by Kathy, who claimed to dream of the stage, as she bursts out of a party cake, laying bare her pride and her reality at once.

  • The song was first used in “Sadie McKee” (1934). Here it is turned into a quick, giddy arrangement to suit the Charleston of the 1920s new-woman dancers (flappers).
  • As the short-skirted chorus girls kick up their heels in unison around the song, the fact that Kathy stands at the very heart of the show business she scorned becomes the joke.
  • The official LP includes both Debbie Reynolds's version and Gene Kelly's version. The reprise of the song filmed for the movie was cut after a preview, and the footage is believed to be lost.
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. In an empty studio

(Clown) Kathy vanishes, and Don is crestfallen. Beside him, Cosmo puts on a one-man riot to make his friend laugh. This is “Make 'Em Laugh.” Donald O'Connor takes on a sofa, walls, a mannequin and stage props, falling, rolling, running up the wall and flipping into somersaults. The song cheerfully lays out the outlook of those who live to make others laugh, but the physical stunts say far more than the words. It is in effect the only song Freed and Brown wrote new for this film. (Reunion) A few weeks later, Kathy is discovered working as a bit player in another picture at the same studio. She confesses that she was in fact a fan of Don's all along. Don is about to declare his feelings but hesitates. A silent-film actor, he says he cannot find the words without the proper setting, and leads her onto an empty soundstage. (Stage set) One switch at a time, he builds the scene. He turns on a sunset glow, raises a breeze with a wind machine, sends up mist, and stands a ladder in for a balcony. Then he sings “You Were Meant for Me.” First sung in “The Broadway Melody” (1929), the song becomes here a scene of heartfelt confession in the middle of a fake stage set. In that filmmakers declare their love through the very apparatus of film, this passage shows clearly the way the picture reflects upon itself.

♪Make 'Em LaughFilm scene — Singin' in the Rain

A one-man riot Cosmo stages to make his crestfallen friend laugh, and in effect the only song Freed and Brown wrote new for this film.

  • The song breezily lays out the worldly wisdom of a man who sells laughter, but it keeps the eyes busier than the ears. Donald O'Connor runs up a wall and flips backward, wrestles with a mannequin, and pushes physical comedy (slapstick) to the limit.
  • For this film O'Connor won the Golden Globe for best actor in a musical·comedy. The scene is regarded as his signature performance.
  • It has long been pointed out that its melody and structure closely resemble Cole Porter's “Be a Clown” (“The Pirate,” 1948). Donen, the co-director, candidly acknowledged the similarity.
  • On beat after beat, brass and percussion drop in like sound effects to match each fall and collision. It sounds as if the band were chasing O'Connor's every move.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪You Were Meant for MeFilm scene — Gene Kelly·Debbie Reynolds

A silent-film actor who needs the right setting to find his words builds his own stage for a confession from the lights, wind and mist of an empty soundstage.

  • First sung in “The Broadway Melody” (1929), it was one of the signature love songs of the early talkies. Some twenty years later it was called back into a film about that very era.
  • The opening of the song is a spoken-style introduction (verse). It flows along as he switches on the effects one by one, and only when it reaches the main melody, the refrain (chorus), does the confession truly begin.
  • The irony of the number lies in the premise that sincerity emerges from within fake stagecraft such as an artificial breeze and sunset lighting. A gentle string accompaniment wraps around that artifice.
  • The dance is calm, built on walking and turns rather than dazzling technique. It is the quietest moment among the film's numbers, setting off the commotion that follows.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. Commotion at the microphone

(Talkies) When Warner Bros.' “The Jazz Singer” becomes a smash hit, the studio orders that Don and Lina's costume drama “The Dueling Cavalier,” then in production, be turned into a talking picture. The problem is Lina's voice. The elegant lady on screen opens her mouth and out comes a high, shrill accent, and in front of a microphone she cannot even speak properly. (Sound) The hero of this chapter is not a song but sound itself. The microphone hidden in a bouquet loses her voice each time Lina turns her head, while the rustle of her pearl necklace and even the thump of a heartbeat are picked up loud enough to shake the recording booth. At the preview, film and sound slip out of sync until a woman's voice comes out of the leading man's mouth, and the audience dissolves into laughter. The mismatch of words and pictures that was a joke in the first scene now becomes a disaster threatening the studio. (Diction) During their elocution lessons, Don and Cosmo tease their teacher and tap-dance to “Moses Supposes.” This number is not by Freed and Brown but a new song composed by Roger Edens with lyrics by Comden and Green, turning tongue-twisting wordplay into rhythm. (Dawn) On a night of despair, the three hit on the idea of turning the costume drama into a musical, putting Kathy's voice into Lina's mouth. As the elated trio greet the dawn after staying up all night, “Good Morning” bursts forth. At the moment the problem is solved, the grammar of the movie musical, in which song becomes dialogue, works at its most buoyant.

♪Good MorningFilm scene — Singin' in the Rain (1952)

A song of joy that bursts out at dawn from three people who have stayed up all night and found a way to save a failed costume drama by turning it into a musical.

  • The song was originally sung by Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland in “Babes in Arms” (1939). Here it is reborn as a song and tap dance for three.
  • Moving from the kitchen to the living room, the three take turns mimicking a range of dances, from the Charleston to flamenco to the hula. Each time, the music briefly twists itself to follow that dance's rhythm.
  • Debbie Reynolds, who was no dance specialist, had to hold her own between two dancers in this number. The story goes that shooting ran from morning until night.
  • At the end, the music cuts off sharply just as the three of them topple backward over a sofa. The pleasure of sound and movement landing in exact unison answers the disastrous preview scene, in which the sound fell out of sync.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. In the rain

(The walk home) After seeing Kathy home, Don is left alone on a street in the pouring rain. He sends his driver away and folds his umbrella. What this scene does in the story is very simple: a man in love is feeling good. Yet it is precisely that simplicity that made it some of the most famous minutes in film history. (Movement) The song begins low, almost as if he were talking to himself. Then, the moment Don swings from a lamppost, the orchestra swells, and from there the dance takes over the story. Gene Kelly walks the curb like a tightrope, stands deliberately beneath a gushing drainpipe, and finally splashes in a puddle like a child. Each movement is a stage in a joy that keeps growing, and the music shifts its speed and weight to match. When a policeman approaches, he quietly stops and hands his umbrella to a passerby. The scene holds even the moment when his giddiness settles back down into reality. (The shoot) Kelly filmed the scene while suffering a fever of over 39 degrees Celsius, and the shoot took two or three days. There is also a story that his wool suit shrank from the soaking. First sung in a 1929 stage revue, the song thus became the film's title, and came to be remembered longer for this scene than for the song itself.

♪Singin' in the RainFilm scene — Gene Kelly

As a man in love folds his umbrella in the rain, the song grows from a murmur to himself into a festival of orchestra and dance.

  • The song is unusual even in its form. Whereas most songs of the day opened with a speechlike introduction (the verse), here the 32-bar refrain (the chorus) comes first and the 24-bar introduction follows. In the film, too, the core melody flows in from the very first bar.
  • The song, hummed low at first, swells with strings and brass all at once the moment he swings from the lamppost. From this point on, tap dancing rather than singing drives the rhythm.
  • In 1929, in “The Hollywood Revue of 1929,” Cliff Edwards sang it light and fast to ukulele accompaniment. Kelly's version slows the tempo and adds breathing room, turning the same song into something else entirely.
  • Kelly's dance in the rain ranked 3rd on the American Film Institute (AFI) list of the 100 greatest movie songs. On January 1, 2025, the song's copyright term expired in the United States, and it entered the public domain.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. The Broadway dream

(The pitch) Laying out the framework of the film that will be reborn as a musical, Don sketches a scene in his head for the studio boss. It is the story of a young dancer fresh from the country who sets foot on Broadway in New York and rises from shabby stages to star in a great theater. The screen shows that vision just as he imagines it, and for more than ten minutes the film halts its story and flows on dance alone. (The ballet) This “Broadway Melody Ballet” weaves together “Broadway Melody” (1929) and “Broadway Rhythm,” stitching new ballet music by Brown in between. The bright show music grows more dazzling each time the young man climbs another step toward success. Then, when Cyd Charisse appears in a green dress, the music turns to a sultry, sensual jazz. When it reaches the fantasy sequence of a white veil billowing endlessly in the wind, the music too passes into a slow, dreamlike sound led by the strings. (The treadmill) The dancer finds success, but in the end she leaves him for someone else. He then meets another young man setting foot on Broadway just as he once did. The same melody rings out again, telling us that dreams and success repeat without end. The final line, in which the boss reacts as if he had only imagined the scene and never actually seen it, slyly reminds us that this great block was a festival outside the story. That is why the ballet has been called both an interruption of the film's flow and the film's very heart.

♪Broadway Melody BalletFilm scene — Cyd Charisse·Gene Kelly

Don's vision of a Broadway success story for the new film, a fantasy within the film that halts the story for more than ten minutes and flows on dance alone.

  • Brown's newly written ballet music was spliced in between “Broadway Melody” (1929) and “Broadway Rhythm.” In effect, old songs and new music were sewn into a single piece.
  • When Cyd Charisse appears, the bright show music turns into slow, sultry jazz. The hazy tones of saxophone and of trumpet fitted with a mute (muted trumpet) sound like a signature pointing to her.
  • In the fantasy sequence of a white veil fluttering in the wind, the music passes into a dreamlike sound of long-sustained strings. It is worth listening for how the same character is painted with entirely different music in a glittering club and in a dream.
  • The short melody that introduced the young dancer rings out again at the end, returning the story to its beginning. Within that repetition lies the sense that success and parting keep recurring.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. The voice behind the curtain

(The premiere) As at the beginning, the story returns to a premiere. The new film, now a musical, is a success, and the audience applauds Lina's singing on the screen. Only a few people backstage know whose voice it really is. Lina uses the secret as a weapon to keep Kathy in the shadows for good. When the audience calls for an encore and Lina must sing live, Kathy steps up to the microphone behind the curtain. (The voice) In this scene the music brings to the stage, one last time, the question that runs through the whole film: whose voice is it? “Singin' in the Rain” is sung again, but this time it is not joy in the rain; it is a performance in which the mouth and the sound belong to different people. First-time viewers would do well to watch for themselves how the curtain moves here. It is at this point that the film shows most dramatically what it means for sound and image to come together. (Afterglow) Finally, “You Are My Lucky Star” plays. With this song, taken from “Broadway Melody of 1936,” the film becomes a quiet duet, and the picture comes to rest before a giant billboard for the new film. The title on that billboard is the title of the very film we are watching. And so a story about the passage from silent pictures to talkies ends in front of its own poster.

♪You Are My Lucky StarFilm scene — Gene Kelly·Debbie Reynolds and others

A quiet duet after the commotion has passed, with which the film brings down the curtain in front of its own billboard.

  • The song comes from “Broadway Melody of 1936.” After the commotion of the earlier numbers has died down, its gentle melody and string accompaniment slowly cool the film's fever.
  • Earlier in the same film there was also a scene of Debbie Reynolds singing this song alone, but it was cut from the release print. The recording survived and appears, in her voice, as the final track of the official LP.
  • Some of Reynolds's songs were sung in her place by the singer Betty Noyes. That a film about who owns a voice used a stand-in voice on its own set lends this final song a curious resonance.
  • As the orchestra draws out its final chord, the picture comes to rest before the billboard. The close of the music and the close of the film arrive together in a single shot.
Listen on YouTube ↗

Lesser-known stories

(The first stage) The first person to sing the title song “Singin' in the Rain” in public was neither Gene Kelly nor Cliff Edwards, who is often credited as the original singer. Doris Eaton Travis sang it first in the 1929 stage revue “The Hollywood Music Box Revue,” and Edwards made the song widely known that same year through the film “The Hollywood Revue of 1929.” After that it was used several more times, in a Jimmy Durante picture and in works such as “Little Nellie Kelly” (1940), starring Judy Garland. The 1952 rain scene was simply so powerful that it eclipsed the 20-odd years that came before it. (A look-alike song) Experts have long noted that “Make 'Em Laugh” closely resembles Cole Porter's “Be a Clown.” “Be a Clown” was a song from “The Pirate” (1948), another MGM picture, in which Gene Kelly starred. Co-director Donen made no secret of the resemblance and even said it came close to plagiarism, but Porter never sued. Since it was a matter within the same studio, and since the film was a huge success, the issue was quietly buried. (Whose voice) The film takes borrowing someone else's voice as its subject, and the same thing happened on the set. Some of Reynolds's songs, including the scene in which Kathy sings in place of Lina, were sung by Betty Noyes. Conversely, in the scene where Kathy dubs Lina's dialogue, the real voice of Jean Hagen, who played Lina, was used, since Reynolds's accent was judged not to fit. The story inside the film and the facts outside it are turned inside out. (The cut scenes) Reynolds's solo “You Are My Lucky Star” was cut from the release print, but the recording survived and was included on the soundtrack LP. By contrast, no film survives of the reprise of “All I Do Is Dream of You,” cut after a preview. That some scenes have left traces only on record is hard to know unless you have sought out the record and listened for yourself. (The rain) The story that milk was mixed into the rainwater to make the streaks show up on screen is widespread, but it is not true. What made the rain stand out so sharply was backlighting. It is a fine example of how the more plausible an anecdote is, the more easily it gets repeated along with the myth of a great scene.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Jukebox musical (catalog musical)

(Meaning) A jukebox is a machine that plays a chosen record when you drop in a coin. Like a machine that picks out and plays existing hits, the term means a musical pieced together from songs that are already known. (In film·musical scores) Rather than writing new songs, it is a musical that gathers an existing list of songs (the catalog) by a single composer or singer and then builds a new story so those songs can fit in naturally. “Singin' in the Rain,” which strings together old songs by Freed and Brown, is a classic early example. It is like laying out the stickers you already have and then planning a picture diary so that every one of them gets used. (Elsewhere) In everyday life a catalog is a product brochure, but in the music industry it means the full list of songs to which a composer or company holds the rights.

Dubbing

(Meaning) From the English dub, meaning to lay a recording down again or on top. (In film·musical scores) The process of replacing or supplementing an on-screen actor's voice or singing with sound recorded separately afterward. Dubbing that covers Lina's voice with Kathy's singing is at the center of this film's plot, and on the actual shoot, too, some of Reynolds's songs were sung by another singer. Watching a foreign cartoon with Korean voice actors is exactly what dubbing is. (Elsewhere) In popular music, dubbing can also mean a single performer recording the same song several times in layers to thicken the sound (overdubbing).

Lip-sync

(Meaning) A combination of lip and sync (synchronize): matching the shape of the mouth to the sound. (In film·musical scores) A method in which a prerecorded song is played and the actor only moves their lips along with it. Most movie musicals record the songs first, and on set the actors perform while mouthing along to that sound. At this film's final premiere, the scene in which Lina moves her lips to Kathy's singing behind the curtain is precisely lip-syncing. It is the same as playing a song at a school talent show and dancing along while only mouthing the words. (Elsewhere) In everyday speech it is often used, somewhat disparagingly, for a singer who does not actually sing on stage.

Verse and chorus

(Meaning) The words come from verse, a stanza of a poem, and chorus, a part sung by many together. (In film·musical scores) In old American popular songs, the verse is an introduction that sets up the situation in a speechlike way before the song proper, and the chorus is the core melody everyone remembers. “Singin' in the Rain” is unusual in that the chorus comes first and the verse follows. In “You Were Meant for Me,” the verse plays while Don turns on the lights, and the confession begins in the chorus. Think of the verse as the part of a presentation where you open with 'What I'd like to tell you today is…' before the main point, and the chorus as the conclusion your friends remember. (Elsewhere) Chorus can also refer to a choir or to the ensemble performers of a musical.

Reprise

(Meaning) From the French reprise, meaning to take up again or to repeat. (In film·musical scores) Singing again, later on, a song heard earlier. Often the lyrics, the mood or the singer changes, so the song takes on a meaning different from the first time. In this film, a reprise of “All I Do Is Dream of You” was shot and then cut, and at the final premiere the title song is sung again in an entirely different situation. It is like a field-day cheer sung with gusto before the race and sung again after a loss as everyone comforts one another: the same song, but its meaning changes. (Elsewhere) The word can also mean a rerun on television, or, in fencing, a move that renews an attack.

Dream ballet

(In film·musical-theater music) A sequence in which the story pauses and a character's dream or fantasy unfolds at length through dance and music alone, without dialogue. It was a frequent device in American stage musicals and MGM movie musicals of the 1940s~50s. The “Broadway Melody Ballet,” in which the scene Don imagines is rendered for some ten minutes purely in dance, is the classic example. It is rather like staring blankly out the classroom window, playing out a long reverie of scoring the winning goal in a cup final, until the teacher's voice jolts you awake. (Elsewhere) Ballet usually refers to a classical dance performance itself, but here it names a long dance sequence within a musical.

Backstage musical

(Literal meaning) Backstage is the back of the stage, that is, the dressing rooms and rehearsal rooms hidden from the audience. (In film·musical-theater music) A musical about the people who make shows or films. Because the songs and dances appear as performances or shoots within the story, the moments when characters burst into song explain themselves naturally. Singin' in the Rain is a story about people making a movie, and A Chorus Line, covered in this series, belongs to the same lineage. It is like how, at a school festival, the story of the friends who quarrel and make up while preparing the show is more fun than the show itself.