novareads.musicMusical

Shine

1996

The hands on screen belong to the actor, and the sound in our ears is mostly a real pianist's recording. Between the two, Hirschfelder's music lets us hear what rings inside one man's head.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. OriginsAustralian release, 1996Ten years of preparationFirst title, Flight of the B…2. MusicHirschfelder's original scoreHelfgott's own recordings34-track soundtrack3. ConflictFather and sonStudy abroad blockedThe ultimatum4. ClimaxRachmaninoff's ThirdSound fading awayElectronic drone5. ReturnBumblebee in the restaurantVivaldi on the trampolineBack to the stage6. LegacyRush's Best Actor OscarOscar nomination for score20th-anniversary documentaryShine1996Music that follows a pianist's collapse and re…
Where the story unfolds 🧭🗺️
NUnited KingdomPerthLondonPerth

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The makers ⏳🌊

  • ComposerDavid Hirschfelder

    A former keyboardist in pop bands, he earned an Academy Award nomination for this film's score and was nominated again for “Elizabeth.”

  • DirectorScott Hicks

    After seeing Helfgott perform in 1985, he spent nearly a decade preparing the film, and was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Director.

  • ScreenplayJan Sardi

    Joining in 1990, he reshaped the story, and the film earned him an Academy Award nomination for Best Screenplay.

  • LeadGeoffrey Rush

    He went back to the piano lessons he had given up as a boy and played the adult David with no hand double, winning the Academy Award for Best Actor.

  • LeadArmin Mueller-Stahl

    His portrayal of Peter, a father in whom love and obsession are one and the same, earned him an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor.

  • LeadNoah Taylor

    He played the teenage David, torn between his dream of studying abroad and his father.

Play all 5 on YouTube ↗

I. A film ten years in the making

(Origins) 「Shine」 is a film that began with the life of the Australian pianist David Helfgott. Director Scott Hicks saw Helfgott perform in Adelaide in 1985 and resolved to turn his story into a film. Winning the consent of Helfgott and his wife, Gillian, alone took about a year. After research and interviews, screenwriter Jan Sardi came aboard in 1990. The first draft bore the title 「Flight of the Bumblebee」. By the time the film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in January 1996, nearly ten years had passed. (The composer) The score was entrusted to David Hirschfelder. Born in Ballarat, Victoria, in 1960, he was a pop musician who had played keyboards for Little River Band and for John Farnham's band. The film that made his name as a film composer was Baz Luhrmann's 「Strictly Ballroom」. Luhrmann is the director of 「Moulin Rouge!」, covered earlier in this series. Just how Hicks came to choose Hirschfelder is not widely known. (Two strands) Hirschfelder's work ran along two strands. One was choosing passages from the great piano works of Chopin, Liszt, and Rachmaninoff to fit each scene, then shaping and recording them. The other was writing new underscore to bridge the gaps between them. The soundtrack album runs to thirty-four tracks, mixing Hirschfelder's original music with classical masterpieces. Many of the performances of those masterpieces are said to be by Helfgott himself. (Hands) Geoffrey Rush, who played the adult David, resumed the piano lessons he had abandoned at fourteen and sat down at the keyboard with no hand double. Often the hands on screen belong to the actor while the sound in our ears is Helfgott's recording. This layering creates the musical texture of the entire film.

♪With the Help of God, Shine1996

An original piece by Hirschfelder that opens the soundtrack album. Its title tells us, before anything else, where the film's title came from.

  • Hirschfelder's underscore sets the piano at its center and lays strings and harp over it. It sounds like a deliberate choice not to stand out among the classical masterpieces played on the same instrument.
  • The original music is said to make up less than half of the album. Even so, this underscore earned nominations for the Academy Award and the Golden Globe for best score. Both prizes went to Gabriel Yared for 「The English Patient」.
  • In Australia it won the AACTA Award for Best Original Music Score and the APRA Award for film music. The keyboardist of a pop band had, in effect, won recognition for a film about classical music.
  • The bright, hopeful melody points to David's dreams and imagination. Keep in mind how this brightness later darkens, and the cues that follow will speak more clearly.

II. The father's piano

(In the rain) The film opens on a rainy night. A drenched middle-aged man pounds on the door of a restaurant, words pouring from his mouth without pause. The film does not explain at once who he is. Instead it travels back in time to a boy in Perth in the 1950s. (The father) The first person to teach the boy David the piano is his father, Peter. A Jewish immigrant from Poland, he tells his son again and again that he must win, that only the strong survive. Played by Armin Mueller-Stahl, this father is drawn as a man in whom love and obsession are one and the same. He dreams that his son will one day play Rachmaninoff's Piano Concerto No. 3. That piece becomes the thread running through the whole film. (The competition) At the eisteddfod, a local music competition, the young David plays Chopin. The result falls short of his father's hopes. But Ben Rosen, a piano teacher in the audience, recognizes the child's gift. The father at first refuses to place his son in another man's hands, but in the end he gives way. (Timbre) In this passage Hirschfelder's underscore sets the piano at the center and lightly lays strings and harp over it. It is a bright timbre that wraps around the child's imagination and hope. When the father's voice turns sharp, the music sinks into the piano's low register. The same instrument moves between high and low registers and changes the air inside the house. This brief contrast sets up in advance the axis of the story to come.

♪The PolonaisePerformed by Seong-Jin Cho (piano) · 2015 Chopin Competition prizewinners' concert

The scene in which the young David plays Chopin at the eisteddfod. On the album this piece is followed immediately by a short cue, 「Did He Win?」, which depicts the wait for the competition's result.

  • The polonaise is a dance in triple meter that originated at the Polish court. Its hallmark is a rhythm that advances with the stately dignity of a procession.
  • Having left his native Poland to live in Paris, Chopin poured his longing for home into his polonaises. The setup of an immigrant father from Poland making his son play this piece resonates on top of that.
  • The album track is brief, a little over 1 minute 20 seconds. The film keeps its gaze less on the whole piece than on the child's hands and the father's face.
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. An invitation from across the sea

(The invitation) The teenage David, played by Noah Taylor, wins the state competition. The violinist Isaac Stern urges him to study in America, and the neighbors begin raising money for the trip. But his father forbids it on the grounds that the family would be torn apart. The violence and silence in the house grow thickest at this time. (Friendship) David grows close to the writer Katharine Susannah Prichard. Prichard, a real-life novelist who helped found the Communist Party of Australia, is played by Googie Withers. She offers the boy books and stories and gives him the courage to leave his father's side. Hirschfelder's cues on the album, 「Tell Me a Story, Katherine」 and 「Letters to Katherine」, point, just as their titles say, to the conversations and letters between the two. (The scholarship) At last David is chosen for a scholarship to the Royal College of Music in London. His father issues an ultimatum: if he leaves, he can never again be a son of this house. The son turns his back on those words and goes. Cue titles on the album such as 「Punished for the Rest of Your Life」 hint at the weight of the words exchanged at this time. (Contrast) In this chapter the music sets two worlds against each other. In Prichard's house harp and strings flow gently; in the father's house a low piano tolls heavily. It is the contrast between the open world outside and the closed world within. In showing that the same piano speaks in an entirely different voice depending on which side it stands, Hirschfelder sketches with a single instrument the situation in which a character is placed.

IV. The concerto they called a monster

(London) In London David meets Professor Cecil Parkes. Played by John Gielgud, the old professor cherishes his pupil's talent, yet calls the Rachmaninoff Third that David has chosen a monstrous piece. He means it is a piece that fingers alone cannot conquer, one that demands the heart as well. (The work) Rachmaninoff wrote this concerto in 1909 for a concert tour of America. That November in New York he gave the premiere himself as soloist. Because of its chords that demand a wide stretch of the hand and its passages that drive on without rest, it is still counted among the most difficult piano concertos. The son prepares the very piece his father dreamed of in the place farthest from his father. (Practice) The film lingers on the practicing. David pounding the keys late into the night, a score crowded with markings, a face that grows ever more silent follow one after another. On the album, 「Night Practice/Parcel from Katherine」 draws fragments of Rachmaninoff's melody into Hirschfelder's cue. The night's practice and Katherine's parcel, named in the title, are bound into a single current. (The boundary) In this chapter the boundary between film music and classical music blurs. Rachmaninoff's phrases lie beneath the scenes like underscore, while Hirschfelder's underscore follows behind them like the concerto's shadow. Before they know it, the audience is hearing the sounds ringing inside David's head along with him. Little by little, in this way, the next chapter's climax is prepared.

♪1st Movement Cadenza from the Rach 3Performed by Yunchan Lim (piano) · 2022 Cliburn final round

The passage in which David, in London, throws himself into the concerto called a monster. The album gives a separate track to the cadenza of the first movement, the heart of this concerto.

  • In the cadenza (a passage where the soloist alone displays virtuosity), the orchestra stops and only the piano remains. David's plight, wrestling alone with an enormous piece, maps directly onto the musical form.
  • Rachmaninoff left two cadenzas for this first movement. One is a version with thick, heavy chords; the other is lighter and faster. The composer himself chose the lighter one for his recording. Which one to play is considered a point on which pianists divide.
  • The first theme of the first movement is a simple melody of only a few notes. Some suggested it was taken from a Russian chant, but Rachmaninoff stated that he had borrowed it from nowhere. It is worth following how that simple melody swells to enormous proportions in the cadenza.
  • The concerto was dedicated to the pianist Josef Hofmann, but Hofmann is said never to have performed it on the public stage.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. The moment the sound disappears

(The competition) At the Royal College of Music's concerto competition, David plays the Rachmaninoff Third. It is the film's climax and its most talked-about scene. As the camera cuts among the audience, the conductor, and the sweat-soaked face of the performer, the music races toward its end. (Silence) Then, at a certain moment, the sound of the orchestra recedes. All that remains are the dull blows of the keys being struck, the sound of breathing, and a low, droning hum. The hands on screen still move, but the music cannot be heard. The audience is pulled from the seat of a listener hearing the performance from outside into the performer's own body. (Design) Hirschfelder is said to have laid a low droning sound beneath Rachmaninoff's phrases in this passage. The album's 「The Rach. 3」 is the result. Within the film, however, it shows in sound the limit of what one person can bear. It is a scene in which taking music away becomes the most powerful music of all. (The price) The performance ends in applause, but David collapses on the spot. The film skips briefly over the long void that follows. Back in Australia he telephones his father, but the answer from the other end of the line is cold. The piece the father dreamed of and the son achieved has, in the end, driven the two apart.

♪The Rach. 3

The music for the scene in which sound drains away at the climax of the Royal College of Music competition. The concerto and Hirschfelder's electronic sounds mingle within a single track.

  • Beneath the concerto's grand sound lies a sustained tone (a drone) made from electronic sound. This low hum sounds like pressure resonating inside the performer's ears and body.
  • As the orchestra recedes, only the dull resonance of the keystrokes and the sound of breathing remain. Because it heightens tension by subtracting music, the scene is often cited when people speak of the power of silence in film music.
  • Only when you listen with the film's scene in mind does this track's meaning fully come alive.
  • It is the moment when the piece the father dreamed of breaks the son. The same melody that once meant hope now comes to mean the price.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. Back to the keyboard

(Return) After a long time David comes out into the world. Clumsily meeting the world again, he returns to the restaurant from the opening scene and sits down at the piano. When he pours out Rimsky-Korsakov's 「Flight of the Bumblebee」, the diners hold their breath. The story broken off in the prologue resumes here. (Release) Around this time comes the freest scene in the film. David, in his overcoat, leaps on a trampoline as a Vivaldi motet unfolds skyward in a soprano's voice. It is the moment when a man long crushed lifts his body into the air for the first time. Without a single line of dialogue, it depicts release through music and movement alone. (Encounter) Through Sylvia, who works at the restaurant, David meets Gillian. At the side of Gillian, played by Lynn Redgrave, he gradually regains order in his life. Coming to terms with his father's death also happens during this period. (Resonance) The film turns toward the stage once more. What happens on that stage is better seen for yourself. Suffice it to say that what the music offers here is no victory fanfare. As the title of a track near the album's end, 「Familiar Faces/Rach. 3 Encore」, suggests, the music listens for the tremor of the moment he discovers familiar faces in the audience. Into that tremor returns the shadow of the concerto that had long lain submerged. Like 「Brassed Off」, released the same year, this film holds to the very end the truth that music can break a person and can also raise them up again.

♪Flight of the Bumble BeeFilm scene — Geoffrey Rush

The scene in which David, back at the restaurant, pours this piece out before the diners is the best-known moment in the film. The playing is Helfgott's recording; the hands on the keys belong to Geoffrey Rush.

  • The original is a short orchestral interlude from Rimsky-Korsakov's opera “The Tale of Tsar Saltan,” written for the moment when the prince turns into a bee and flies away. The soundtrack album carries the arrangement (transcription) Rachmaninoff made for piano. Once again, the name that threads through this film is Rachmaninoff.
  • A chromatic scale (a scale that touches every white and black key of the piano in turn), climbing and falling by tightly packed half steps, runs on without pause and paints the beating of the bee's wings.
  • The film's first draft was titled “Flight of the Bumble Bee.” From the very start, the director saw this piece as the emblem of his hero.
  • It is worth hearing alongside the piano duel in “The Legend of 1900,” also in this series. Both films use flying fingers not as a display of virtuosity but as a way to lay bare a character's inner life.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Nulla in Mondo Pax SinceraSung by Zinovia Zafeiriadou Vidovic (soprano)

This Vivaldi motet plays as David, in his overcoat, leaps on a trampoline. On the album it is sung by the soprano Jane Edwards and placed as the final track.

  • It is the opening number of Vivaldi's motet (a solo·choral piece on a sacred text) RV 630. The Latin title means, roughly, that there is no true peace in this world. Yet the music itself flows on, calm and serene. That mismatch between title and sound lends the scene a strange depth.
  • The slow, rocking rhythm matches the body's rise into the air and its fall back down. Because this is one of the few passages where no piano is heard at all, the sense of release lands all the harder.
  • Britain's classical station Classic FM recalled that for some time after the film, this piece was inseparable from the image of an Australian man on a trampoline. It is a case of a single film breathing new life into a half-forgotten Baroque vocal work.
Listen on YouTube ↗

The lesser-known story

The film's first draft was titled “Flight of the Bumble Bee.” Hicks began the project after seeing a performance in Adelaide in 1985. Winning over the Helfgotts took about a year, and research and interviews took several more. In 1990 Jan Sardi joined as screenwriter. The finished film's title became so widely known that the fact it set out under the name of a single piece lies buried in the production company's records. The man who actually taught Helfgott at the Royal College of Music in London was the pianist Cyril Smith. In the film the teacher appears under a different name, Cecil Parkes. In 1956, just as he was beginning a concert tour of the Soviet Union, Smith suffered a stroke in Kharkiv that left his left arm paralyzed. From then on he continued performing duets for three hands with his wife, the pianist Phyllis Sellick. The composer Malcolm Arnold wrote his “Concerto for Two Pianos” for three hands for the pair, and it premiered at the Proms in 1969. When the film changed the teacher's name, this story was left off the screen. How Hirschfelder created the film's music was not widely known. In 2016, the film's twentieth anniversary, a 28-minute documentary appeared in which the film historian Andrew Pike interviewed him. In it Hirschfelder recalled which passages of the great piano works he chose, how he shaped and recorded them, and how he wrote the score that bridges them. The documentary is available through the catalogue of the distributor Ronin Films and on Vimeo On Demand.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Concerto

(Word origin) The Korean hyeopjugok (協奏曲) means a piece in which players perform (奏) together (協). The Latin root of the Western name concerto, concertare, also carries the sense of 'to contend,' so the character of this music, in which soloist and orchestra trade phrases as if in contest, is already present in the name. (In film·musical-theater music) A piece written for a single solo instrument to play together with an orchestra. It usually has three sections (movements) at different tempos. In “Shine,” Rachmaninoff's Third pits one piano against an entire orchestra, mirroring the plight of a hero wrestling alone with an enormous world. Picture a gym class in which one student passes a ball back and forth with the whole class: the game goes on only if the one on his own holds out without tiring.

Cadenza

(Word origin) The Italian cadenza comes from the Latin cadere ('to fall'). It originally referred to the close in which a piece settles toward its end. The present meaning hardened out of the custom of soloists showing off their skill just before that close. (In film·musical-theater music) The passage in a concerto where the orchestra falls silent and the soloist alone unfurls dazzling feats of technique. In earlier times performers often improvised them on the spot, but Rachmaninoff wrote his own. The first movement of the Third Concerto has two cadenzas, a heavy version and a lighter one. It is like the moment at karaoke when the backing track drops out and the singer holds a long note alone; in that brief moment, every bit of skill is laid bare. (Elsewhere) In cycling or running, cadence means the rhythm of pedal strokes or footfalls.

Underscore (background music)

(Word origin) The English underscore means a score laid down beneath (under). The name itself tells you how it is used: music laid under a scene. (In film·musical-theater music) Background music heard by the audience but not by the characters. In “Shine,” the Chopin and Rachmaninoff that David plays are music the character hears too. The new music for harp and strings that Hirschfelder wrote is underscore, heard by the audience alone. Think of the background music in a video game that the player hears but the character doesn't. Just as the music shifts and the tension rises when you enter a boss room, underscore quietly steers the mood of a scene. (Elsewhere) On computers, the underline character (_) is called an underscore.

Sustained tone (drone)

(Word origin) The English drone originally meant a male bee, and the humming sound it makes. The name likens a single unbroken, ever-sounding note to that hum. (In film·musical-theater music) A technique of laying down a long-held note whose pitch barely changes. The low hum of the bagpipes is the classic example. In the competition scene of “Shine,” Hirschfelder laid an electronic drone underneath to convey the pressure crushing the performer's mind. During an exam, the steady hum of a classroom's fluorescent lights or a refrigerator goes unnoticed at first, until at some point it is all you can hear. A drone tightens the listener's nerves in just that way, little by little. (Elsewhere) These days, a remotely piloted aircraft with no one aboard is called a drone, a name it earned because the whir of its rotors sounds like a bee.

Arrangement (transcription)

(Word origin) Transcription comes from the Latin transcribere ('to copy over'). From this came the sense of rewriting music for one instrument so another can play it. (In film·musical-theater music) A piece originally written for another instrument or for orchestra, rewritten so it can be played on a different instrument. The “Flight of the Bumble Bee” in “Shine” is originally an orchestral piece within an opera; in the film it is played in the version Rachmaninoff adapted for a single piano. It is like copying out the note names of a song a classmate sang at karaoke so you can try it on the recorder. Squeezing a whole orchestra's sound into one piano, though, keeps the fingers far busier. (Elsewhere) In biology, copying the information in DNA into RNA is called transcription, and a written record of recorded speech is also called a transcription.

Polonaise

(Word origin) The French polonaise means '(dance) in the Polish style.' A Polish dance spread across Europe under a French name. (In film·musical-theater music) A stately dance in triple meter. It grew out of a processional dance in which nobles walked slowly in a line. Chopin, who left his homeland to live in Paris, wrote many polonaises, and they hold both longing for home and pride in it. In “Shine,” the young David plays a Chopin polonaise at a competition. Picture the opening parade at a school sports day, each class marching in proudly in neat rows, and you can feel its rhythm.

Motet

(Word origin) The word motet is commonly explained as coming from the French mot ('word'). The name arose from a medieval custom of singing new words (texts) over an existing melody. (In film·musical-theater music) A vocal work set to a sacred text. Depending on the era, it may be a choral piece or a solo. Vivaldi's motets take the form of a soloist singing with orchestral accompaniment. The music in the trampoline scene of “Shine” is just such a motet. Just as a school choir contest has songs for the whole class and solos sung by a single representative, a motet may be sung by many voices or by one.