novareads.musicMusical

Mr. Holland's Opus

1995

The scattered melodies of a life gather, at the end, into a single symphony. This is a film score that carries one teacher's thirty years into the architecture of music.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. BeginningsUS release, 1995The dream of a symphonyA Portland high school2. ThemesA four-note fanfareIris's pianoCole's flute3. The classroomThe sunset clarinetRock and roll lessonsMarching band4. FamilySign languageBeautiful BoyA father's reconciliation5. FinaleThemes convergeRock and orchestraAn eight-and-a-half-minute s…6. LegacyGrammy for arrangingAn instrument-donation found…An 18-minute concert versionOpus1995Thirty years in the life of a music teacher wh…
Where the story unfolds 🧭🗺️
NUnited States of AmericaPortlandNew York

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The people behind it ⏳🌊

  • ComposerMichael Kamen

    Writing both the underscore and an imaginary symphony, he carried one teacher's life into the architecture of music, and after the film he founded a foundation to support music education.

  • DirectorStephen Herek

    Reuniting with Kamen, his collaborator on “The Three Musketeers,” he directed the story of a teacher spanning thirty years.

  • ScreenplayPatrick Sheane Duncan

    He wrote the screenplay and earned a Golden Globe nomination for Best Screenplay for this film.

  • StarringRichard Dreyfuss

    His portrayal of Glenn Holland earned him an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor. The scene in which he sings “Beautiful Boy” while signing it is especially remembered.

  • Lead roleGlenne Headly

    She played Iris, the wife who believes in her husband's dream and is the first to learn sign language so she can talk with their son.

Play all 6 on YouTube ↗

I. The composer who became a teacher

(The film) “Mr. Holland's Opus” opened in the United States in December 1995. Directed by Stephen Herek from a screenplay by Patrick Sheane Duncan, it stars Richard Dreyfuss. It is the story of a composer who dreams of writing a symphony, takes a job as a high school music teacher to make a living, and ends up spending thirty years there. It was shot mainly at Grant High School in Portland, Oregon. Dreyfuss received an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor for the role. (The composer) The music was by Michael Kamen. He studied oboe at New York's High School of Music & Art and at Juilliard, and as a student co-founded the New York Rock & Roll Ensemble, a band that blended classical music and rock. He went on to move freely between genres, from Pink Floyd's “The Wall” to film scores such as “Die Hard” and “Robin Hood.” He had already worked with Herek on “The Three Musketeers.” Holland, a classical musician who opens his students' hearts through rock, was in many ways a figure in Kamen's own image. (Structure) Kamen wrote two works side by side. One is “American Symphony,” the imaginary symphony Holland labors over for thirty years; the other is the film's underscore. The underscore was built from fragments of that symphony. The melodies attached to his wife, his son and his student run separately from scene to scene before gathering into a single piece at the end. On the album, the symphony was played by the London Metropolitan Orchestra and the rest of the score by the Seattle Symphony, all conducted by Kamen. (Lineage) If “Brassed Off,” covered earlier in this series, portrayed the band of a coal mine about to close, this film portrays a school music room facing budget cuts. Both films speak of music's power to hold a community together.

♪Mr. Holland Begins1995Film still — Richard Dreyfuss

The opening track of the score album. It portrays the ambition of the young Holland, who still believes himself a composer rather than a teacher.

  • The short four-note fanfare at the opening (a brass signal announcing a celebration or an entrance) is the leitmotif (a short recurring melody tied to a character) that stands for Holland. It is worth following all the way to the end of the film.
  • On the album, only this track and the symphony were performed by the London Metropolitan Orchestra. The film's beginning and end are joined by the sound of the same orchestra.
  • One critic noted that the piece's construction resembles Kamen's theme for “Robin Hood.” The likeness comes through in the way the brass drives it forward.
  • Bright and reaching straight ahead, this melody sounds like the music of someone who has not yet lost anything. It is worth comparing how much heavier the same theme becomes in the final track.
Listen on YouTube ↗

II. Clarinet at sunset

(Beginnings) In 1964, Glenn Holland takes up teaching, meant to be only a brief stint. His plan is to teach by day and write his symphony in the time left over. His wife, Iris, believes in that dream more than anyone. But the students in his classroom have no interest in his talk of music, and Holland has little interest in them either. (Fanfare) The cue that opens the film, “Mr. Holland Begins,” starts with a short four-note fanfare. It is a bright overture full of a young composer's ambition. Those four notes soon return, soft as a lullaby, inside the love theme for Iris. One person's melody changing shape with each place it occupies in a life: that is the principle that drives the entire score. (Sunset) The student who turns Holland's heart in his first year is Gertrude Lang, whose clarinet playing will not improve no matter how much she practices. Holland has her put down the sheet music and asks what she likes best about herself. Gertrude answers that it is her red hair, which her father calls the color of the sunset. Holland tells her to close her eyes and play the sunset. When she pictures an image instead of notes, the sound at last comes alive. (Realization) This scene is also the moment Holland becomes a real teacher. Teaching music does not end with passing on technique. It means helping students draw out something inside themselves as sound. Holland grasps this for the first time here. That realization becomes the way he stands in the classroom for the next thirty years.

♪Iris and Glen1995

The theme for Iris, the wife who believes in Holland's dream. It holds the warmth of the home a husband returns to, worn out by the world outside.

  • A solo piano sings the melody over woodwinds and soft strings. The choice of instruments calls to mind the couple seated at the piano at home.
  • The four-note fanfare of the first track returns here, softened into something like a lullaby. The same melody becomes a different person depending on how it is played.
  • This theme fills the opening of the symphony “American Symphony.” In the later concert version it became a movement in its own right, titled “Iris.”
  • Without ornament, the piano picks out each note one at a time, sounding like the sincerity of someone of few words.

III. Rock and roll lessons

(Direction) When by-the-book lessons fall flat, Holland brings the popular music his students love into the classroom. Showing them that a pop song on the radio is connected to a melody by Bach, he tells them classical music and rock are not separate worlds. The Toys' 1965 hit “A Lover's Concerto” was made by recasting the melody of the Minuet in G major attributed to Bach in 4/4 time. (Pushback) The school's grown-ups frown on rock and roll as a threat to discipline. The strict principal, Helen Jacobs, keeps a watchful eye on Holland yet gives his methods a chance. Holland is also handed the job of forming the school marching band, together with the gym teacher Bill Meister. With a touch of humor, the film follows the band from its clumsy beginnings to the day it lines up in formation on the field. (Rhythm) Louis Russ, a student athlete, joins the marching band. He cannot keep time at all, and Holland patiently teaches him rhythm. The scene in which the boy who knew nothing of rhythm finally marches beating the bass drum is drawn as a small victory. This student's story will later return as a heavy shadow. It is one of Terrence Howard's early screen roles. (Practice) The third cue on the score album, “Practice, Practice, Practice,” captures the spirit of this period. After spinning out Holland's theme at length, it moves into a passage in which piano and strings race along playfully. The drudgery of repetitive practice and the joy of a lesson coming to life are translated into musical tempo.

♪A Lover's Concerto · The Toys1965Sung by The Toys

A 1960s hit included on the song album. It echoes Holland's way of teaching, which finds the classical within popular music.

  • The melody's roots lie in the Minuet in G major attributed to Bach. Today the prevailing view is that the minuet was written by Christian Petzold.
  • It turns the original minuet (a court dance in 3/4 time) into 4/4 pop. A single change of meter, and music for a court ball becomes a 1960s girl-group song.
  • The song climbed as high as No. 2 on the US Billboard singles chart. For the students in the film, it was music far closer to home than classical.
  • Holland's way of teaching, starting from what students know and leading them toward what they do not, is captured in this single song.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. The son who cannot hear

(Birth) Iris becomes pregnant, and their son Cole is born. Holland is the kind of father who plays John Coltrane for his newborn and says children should listen to Mozart. The score album's cue “New Baby/Coltrane/Children Should Listen to Mozart” carries those hopes, offering a first faint glimpse of Cole's theme alongside Holland's. (Diagnosis) But it emerges that Cole cannot hear. For a father who believed music would bind him to his son, it was a hard thing to bear. Iris learns sign language and talks with their son, but Holland can scarcely find his way into that world. His work at school keeps growing, and the pages of his symphony only pile up on the piano. (Sign language) The film does not treat Cole's world as an object of pity. Anthony Natale, who plays the adult Cole, is himself a deaf actor. The film's American Sign Language was also praised as accurate. Quietly, the film shows that the distance between father and son comes not from disability but from an unwillingness to learn each other's language. (Loss) Around the same time, word comes that Louis Russ, who once beat the bass drum in the marching band, has been killed in Vietnam. The score album's cue “Vietnam” quietly underpins that loss with low-lying strings and woodwinds. A teacher cannot stop a child he nurtured in the classroom from being swept away by the history outside it. The film does not hide this helplessness.

♪Cole's Tune1995

The theme for Cole, the son who cannot hear. The film's irony begins with a melody the son will never be able to hear.

  • A flute sings a lyrical melody. One critic likened its romantic mood to Ennio Morricone's “La califfa.”
  • As the piece unfolds, Cole's melody overlaps with Holland's theme. In the scene where father and son grow closer through sign language, the two leitmotifs are woven together.
  • The pop version, with lyrics set to this melody, is “Cole's Song,” sung by Julian Lennon. The same tune was used twice, once as an instrumental and once as a song.
  • In the concert version of the symphony, this melody became a standalone movement called “Cole's Tune.”

V. The road not taken

(Talent) Years pass, and as Holland prepares a school show, Rowena Morgan, a student with an exceptional gift for singing, appears before him. Rowena fills the stage with the Gershwin brothers' standard “Someone to Watch Over Me.” In the film, Jean Louisa Kelly, who plays Rowena, sings it herself; the song album features a recording by Julia Fordham. (Feeling) The song is like a murmur to oneself, a wish for someone to stand close and watch over you. The singer does not plead aloud but confides in a low voice. The film does not explain in words how the song must have sounded to Holland, unable to talk with his son at home and grown distant from his wife; it shows us his face instead. (Crossroads) Rowena dreams of singing in New York and asks Holland to leave with her. In the end, Holland stays with his family. The film neither romanticizes this feeling nor condemns it. It simply lights up, for a moment, another road one man might have walked, then returns to the road he was on. (Shadow) Kamen gave Rowena a melody in which woodwinds, cello and harp glide along. One critic reads it as a shadow of the love theme for Iris, turned inside out. Both are love melodies, but one is a promise kept and the other a road not taken. The two melodies are later set side by side within the symphony.

♪Rowena1995Performed by Seattle Symphony Orchestra

The theme for Rowena, the gifted student who dreams of New York. The road Holland did not take lives on in music.

  • Woodwinds and cello carry the melody over slow strings. A harp glissando (a technique of sweeping across the strings so the notes slide into one another) adds a wistful haze.
  • One critic reads this melody as an inversion of the love theme for Iris. The same longing splits into a love fulfilled and a love unfulfilled.
  • At over 6 minutes, it is one of the longest cues on the score album. Its length sounds like a hesitation drawn out.
  • Within the symphony this theme returns, both plainly and by suggestion. One can hear it as a sign that Holland put even this feeling into his work.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. The father's song

(Quarrel) When John Lennon dies in December 1980, Holland is devastated. Cole, now a teenager, confronts his father: did he really think his son wouldn't even know who Lennon was? Why had he never once tried to share music with him? Long-buried hurt pours out all at once in sign language. The quarrel breaks the long silence between father and son. (Lights) Holland searches for a way for audience members who cannot hear to feel the music too. At the school concert, the stage lights change in time with the music. It is an attempt to carry sound over into light. It is the moment when a man who has thought of music only through his ears all his life first thinks of it through another sense. (Dedication) On that stage Holland sings Lennon's “Beautiful Boy” while signing it. The lullaby-like song Lennon dedicated to his young son, Holland now offers to his own. It is the first song he has ever sung in his son's language. It is the scene for which Dreyfuss's performance in the film is most widely remembered. (Reconciliation) Through this scene Holland rebuilds his relationship with his son, and with his wife as well. The last track on the score album, “Cole's Song,” is a pop version that sets lyrics to Cole's theme, sung by Julian Lennon. In a film where a John Lennon song brings a father and son together, Lennon's own son lends his voice.

♪Beautiful Boy · John Lennon1980Official MV — John Lennon

A song Lennon dedicated to his young son. In the film, Holland sings it while signing it, offering it to his son who cannot hear.

  • The original, from Lennon's last studio album “Double Fantasy,” sounds as if it were whispered beside a sleeping child. It holds a father's promises and worries.
  • In the film, the song Holland sings and his signing hands carry the song together. It is a scene in which sound and gesture say the same thing.
  • The song compilation album includes the original by John Lennon and Yoko Ono. It is worth listening to Holland's version in the film side by side with the original.
  • A father-son quarrel that began with Lennon's death is resolved through Lennon's song. This structure makes the scene feel not like coincidence but like inevitability.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. Opus

(Cuts) In 1995, the school board slashes its budget and eliminates music and arts classes. After thirty years, Holland too must leave the school. He packs up the music room with his son. Among his things is the score of the symphony he never managed to bring to the stage. (Auditorium) About to leave the school, Holland turns back at a sound coming from the auditorium. What awaits him inside is best seen for yourself. But what the music does there can be told. (Convergence) In the cue “Thank You Mr. Holland,” Kamen calls back, one by one, the melodies he has scattered throughout the film. Cole's theme, the love theme with Iris and a playful fast passage go by in turn, and at the end Holland's own theme rises to its peak. It sounds as though thirty years were flowing past again in a few minutes. (Symphony) And then “An American Symphony” sounds. What we hear in the film runs from the point where the drum rhythm cuts in to the end, about 3 minutes. Drums and electric guitar sit right in the middle of the orchestra. The choice was controversial at the film's release, but many argue that for a symphony by a teacher who opened his students' hearts through rock, it is only natural. (Afterglow) The question the film leaves is simple. Between the masterpiece he never finished and thirty years spent teaching, which is a person's true work? The music does not answer in words. It answers instead by gathering every theme into a single piece.

♪Thank You Mr. Holland1995Film scene — Mr. Holland's Opus (final scene)

A cue that follows Holland as he enters the auditorium on his last day. The themes scattered throughout the film return here one after another.

  • Cole's melody, the love theme with Iris and a playful scherzo (a fast, humorous piece) go by in turn. The structure looks back over the whole film once more.
  • The final climax belongs to Holland's theme, first heard in the opening track. The same melody now sounds far heavier and grander than at first.
  • Because the music doesn't explain in advance but calls up memories one by one, the audience comes to grasp on its own what the scene means.
  • This cue serves as the threshold to the symphony that follows immediately.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪An American Symphony – Mr. Holland's Opus1995Film scene — Mr. Holland's Opus

The symphony Holland has been writing for thirty years. Every theme heard in the film is bound together in this one piece.

  • The album version runs about 8 minutes 30 seconds, passing through Holland's theme, Iris's theme, Cole's melody and Rowena's theme before reaching a finale built on Holland's theme. Only the last 3 minutes or so are heard in the film.
  • A rhythm section (the group of instruments that holds down a band's beat) of drums, electric guitar and bass is added to the orchestra. It was controversial at the film's release, but the reading that this is the music of a teacher who taught through rock won people over.
  • With this piece Kamen won the 1997 Grammy for Best Instrumental Arrangement.
  • It was later expanded into an 18-minute concert version in five movements, and a recording by the BBC Symphony Orchestra under Leonard Slatkin survives.
Listen on YouTube ↗

The lesser-known story

In a 1998 interview, Kamen spoke of revisiting, after the film, the New York music high school he had attended. The school had run out of instruments, he said, because the board of education no longer supplied them. The Mr. Holland's Opus Foundation he established in 1996 focused on exactly this problem, sending instruments to students who cannot learn music for lack of them. From 1998, Felice Mancini, daughter of the composer Henry Mancini, led the foundation, and over some 25 years built it into an organization with an annual budget of more than $6 million. It is a story that continued outside the film, one the credits never record. In the same interview, Kamen announced plans to conduct the symphony at halftime of a college football game in Los Angeles, leading the USC marching band and an orchestra of 2,000 students. The crowd was expected to number about 85,000. It was as if the scenes of Holland teaching the marching band on the field were being repeated in real life on a far larger scale. In the film the symphony is heard for only a little over 3 minutes, but Kamen reworked it for the concert hall. The result is an 18-minute version in five movements, “Iris,” “Cole's Tune,” “Marking Homework,” “Rowena” and “Finale.” The BBC Symphony Orchestra under Leonard Slatkin recorded it for the 2001 album “The New Moon in the Old Moon's Arms.” Turning the hours spent grading homework into a movement seems to carry through to the end the idea of making a teacher's daily life the raw material of a symphony. The recording, too, spanned two continents. According to the credits on Kamen's official site, it was made in March 1995 at Abbey Road and Air Lyndhurst Studios in London and at the Saint Thomas Center in Bothell, near Seattle. The crew also included David Heckendorn as music education consultant, a sign that the realism of the classroom scenes was honed with advice from a real music educator.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Leitmotif

(Literally) The German Leitmotiv means a leading (leiten) motive (Motiv), a short musical fragment that leads the story along. The Korean yudodonggi (誘導動機, 'guiding motive') is a direct rendering of the same word. (In film · musical theater scores) A short melody attached to a particular character, emotion or place. When that melody returns, the audience thinks of the character even if they are not on screen. In this film, Holland's four-note fanfare, Iris's piano theme and Cole's flute melody each serve as leitmotifs. It is like a video game in which the same sound effect or theme plays whenever a certain character appears. You can tell who is coming from the sound alone. (Elsewhere) In literary and film criticism, the word also refers to a symbol or scene that recurs within a work.

Fanfare

(In film · musical theater scores) A short, vigorous signal played by brass instruments such as trumpets. It originally announced a king's entrance or the start of a ceremony, and in film music it often heralds a hero's appearance or a fresh start. The first track of this film is a four-note fanfare announcing young Holland's ambition. Think of the short ba-bam that blares from the loudspeakers at the opening ceremony of a school sports day. When it sounds, everyone knows something is about to begin.

Scherzo

(Literally) Scherzo is Italian for 'joke' or 'jest.' True to its name, it refers to a piece of fast, playful character. (In film · musical theater scores) A fast movement placed between heavier or slower movements in a symphony to change the mood. Film music uses this kind of writing for busy or mischievous scenes. The passage in the latter part of this film's “Practice, Practice, Practice” where piano and strings dash about is an example. It is like the moment when a serious lesson has gone on for a while and the teacher suddenly cracks a joke, and the whole classroom loosens up.

Minuet

(Literally) Minuet comes from the French menu, meaning 'small.' The name came from the small, delicate steps of the dance. (In film · musical theater scores) An elegant 3-beat dance performed at European courts in the 17th and 18th centuries. Its hallmark is a beat counted one-two-three, one-two-three. The Toys' “A Lover's Concerto” is a pop song that recasts the Minuet in G major attributed to Bach in 4-beat time. The same tune feels completely different once the meter changes. It is like singing a children's song learned in class to a rap beat, where it sounds like another song altogether.

Rhythm section

(Literally) Section means a part or area. A rhythm section is the group of instruments in a band responsible for the rhythm. (In film · musical theater scores) It usually consists of drums, bass guitar, and guitar or piano, and holds up the music's beat and foundation. “An American Symphony” adds this rhythm section to the orchestra, mixing the drive of rock into a classical symphony. It is like the friends turning the rope at either end in a game of jump rope. They have to keep the beat steady so the person in the middle can jump freely.

Glissando

(Literally) Glissando is an Italianized form of the French glisser, 'to slide.' (In film · musical theater scores) A technique of moving from one note to another by gliding through the notes in between without a break. A harpist sweeps a finger along the strings, and a pianist slides the back of the hand down the keys. In Rowena's theme, the harp glissando creates a dreamy, wistful haze. Think of it as the feeling of coming down a playground slide, put into sound. Instead of going down the stairs one step at a time, you slide all the way down in one go.

Score

(Literally) The English score originally meant a notch or tally mark. Its use for the full score, in which the parts for many instruments are stacked vertically on the page, also comes from the lines ruled to align them. (In film · musical theater scores) The entire body of background music a composer newly writes for a film. The term score album is used to distinguish it from albums that collect existing songs. This film had separate releases, Kamen's score album and a song album collecting pop songs from the 1960s–80s. To use a school play as an analogy, the background music newly written for the drama club is the score, and the medley of hit songs played during intermission is the song album. (Elsewhere) In sports, a score means the points in a game.