Mamma Mia!
This is music in which ABBA songs already out in the world become the dialogue of new characters, without a single word of their lyrics changed.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
Creative team ⏳🌊
- ComposerBenny Andersson
ABBA's keyboardist and composer, he rearranged the original songs for theater orchestra and produced the cast album.
- ComposerBjörn Ulvaeus
The co-writer who penned the lyrics to most of ABBA's songs, he opened the door to the project on the condition that the right writer and story be found.
- ProducerJudy Craymer
The producer who met ABBA's two songwriters during the “Chess” days, held on to the project for more than a decade, and finally brought it to the stage.
- BookCatherine Johnson
Starting from the idea of three possible fathers, she wrote a book that stitches the songs together like dialogue without changing a single line of the lyrics.
- DirectorPhyllida Lloyd
A director from the worlds of theater and opera, she staged the London premiere and directed the 2008 film as well.
- StarringSiobhan McCarthy
She played Donna in the West End premiere, leaving the role’s first voice on the cast album.
I. The songs came first
(Idea) “Mamma Mia!” is a musical in which the songs came before the story. In 1983 Judy Craymer was working for the lyricist Tim Rice, and watched up close as Rice made the musical “Chess” with ABBA’s two composers, Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus. Craymer recalls that around that time she heard “The Winner Takes It All” and pictured a whole play. A single pop song about love and loss, she felt, was already built like a monologue on a stage. (Persuasion) The two composers were lukewarm at first. They are said to have had no interest in a tribute show stringing hits together, or in a biographical play about ABBA. Craymer promised an entirely new story that would take the songs as its threads, and in 1995 Ulvaeus answered that if she found the right writer and the right story, they would give it a try. The idea of the playwright Catherine Johnson, who joined in 1997, was simple. A daughter about to be married does not know which of three men is her father. (Rule) There was one condition. The songs would not be changed. Johnson left the lyrics as they were and wrote the script (the book) so that each song sounds like the next sentence after the line of dialogue just before it. The arrangements (orchestrations) fell to the two composers and Martin Koch, who together carried the studio sound of the 1970s and ’80s over into the sound of a theater band, and the two composers produced the cast album themselves as well. Direction went to Phyllida Lloyd, who had worked in theater and opera. (Lineage) This form, which weaves existing popular songs into a new story, is called the jukebox musical. “Moulin Rouge!”, covered in this series, took a similar path on screen two years later; but where that film layered songs from many eras like a collage, “Mamma Mia!” fills two hours with the songs of a single group. The show opened on April 6, 1999, at the Prince Edward Theatre in London.
II. Three names in a diary
(The island) The setting is an island in Greece. Twenty-year-old Sophie has grown up in the small taverna run by her mother, Donna, and tomorrow she is marrying her fiancé, Sky. When the curtain rises, Sophie sings quietly to herself a song of modest dreams and mails three letters. The whole play begins with this single gesture of sending letters off. (The diary) Sophie does not know who her father is. Her mother’s old diary held the names of three men she had met that summer: Sam, Bill and Harry. Without her mother knowing, Sophie has invited all three to the wedding. The scene in which she reads the diary aloud to two friends is “Honey, Honey.” A breezy love song ABBA recorded in 1974 becomes here the chatter of girls giddy with a secret they are peeking into. (The mother) Then Donna appears. “Money, Money, Money” twists Donna’s weariness, the endless money worries of fixing up an old building, into cabaret-style exaggeration. As Tanya and Rosie, who once shared a band with Donna, arrive on the island, the play takes the shape of two generations of women gathered on one stage. (The guests) The three men reach the island one after another. Sophie sings “Thank You for the Music” in front of them and senses that she has something in common with each of the three. If the original was a thank-you to music, in this scene it sounds like a careful search, feeling along the bloodline. From here on the audience follows the play watching both Sophie’s secret and Donna, who knows nothing of it.
Sophie reads her mother’s diary to her friends and confides the existence of the three men. The moment a secret is first spoken aloud is painted as breezy chatter.
- Originally sung by two, the song is divided among Sophie and her two friends and turned into a conversation of reading diary passages and chiming in. Here the show’s way of speaking, with songs passing back and forth like dialogue, first takes hold.
- Each time one of the men from the diary appears, the song’s flow breaks off for a moment and the girls’ reactions cut in. These breaks let the audience remember the three names without effort.
- The original is an early ABBA song from the 1974 album “Waterloo,” among the earliest of the songs used in this show.
- In the 2008 film, Amanda Seyfried sang it with the actresses playing her friends.
III. A summer reopened
(Shock) The moment Donna comes face to face with all three men at once, the title song “Mamma Mia” bursts out. The exclamation that, in the original, lamented falling for a lover yet again becomes here a scream at the summer of twenty years ago crashing in all at once. Change a single circumstance and the same song earns an entirely different laugh. This is the passage where the show’s method is plainest. (Comfort) Tanya and Rosie soothe the dazed Donna with “Chiquitita,” then lift her back to her feet with “Dancing Queen.” The three, who once shared a stage under the name ‘Donna and the Dynamos,’ take up a hairbrush and a bedsheet as props and turn seventeen again for a moment. An original that sang of youth takes on new meaning in the hands of middle-aged friends. (Youth) The young are busy too. Sophie and Sky confirm their love with “Lay All Your Love on Me,” and at the hen party Donna and her friends dig out their old stage costumes and sing “Super Trouper.” While “Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!” plays, the three men crash the party, and Sophie begins to collar each candidate for father in turn with her questions. (Chaos) Act One reaches its climax in the first-act finale, “Voulez-Vous.” Each of the three men comes to believe he is the father, and over the disco rhythm their misunderstandings and Sophie’s bewilderment pile up layer by layer. The stage is as merry as a festival, but the curtain falls with nothing resolved. Act One closes having only added knots amid the laughter.
The title song absorbs Donna’s shock at meeting her three old lovers all at once. The lyrics are unchanged, but the new situation turns them into comedy.
- The short figure (a riff, a brief melodic fragment that stubbornly repeats the same bar) that ticks over and over in the introduction builds tension like the second hand of a clock. On stage, the sound reads as Donna’s pounding heart.
- Because the original was a song lamenting falling again and again for the same lover, it fits the plight of Donna as she faces three old lovers. It is the clearest example of how this show threads songs into the drama.
- The original reached No. 1 on the UK singles chart in early 1976.
- In the film, Meryl Streep sings it while clambering over the roof of a goat shed and up into a loft, so the physical comedy grows bigger than on stage. It is sung once more at the curtain call after the show ends.
Donna’s old bandmates lift the dazed Donna back to her feet. A song about being seventeen becomes a song of middle-aged friends reclaiming their youth.
- Opening with a glissando, in which a hand sweeps across the keys so the notes glide into one another, the introduction holds the most famous few seconds of the original. That single sound changes the air of the stage.
- It is ABBA’s only No. 1 on the US Billboard singles chart.
- The wedding march is this very song, slowed down and rearranged. The same melody appears twice in the show, dressed in different clothes.
- In the film, the scene grows as the island’s women join in one by one and parade down to the dock, so that the three friends’ song becomes the song of the whole island.
IV. Crossed confessions
(Nightmare) Act Two opens with the entr’acte, the intermission music, followed by Sophie’s nightmare. In “Under Attack,” a dream of the three would-be fathers converging on her at once turns a 1982 single from the end of ABBA’s career into a scene of a hunted mind. The excitement of the night before the wedding has now turned to dread. (Regret) Donna is shaken too. In “One of Us” she broods alone over a love that left, and standing face to face with Sam she trades “SOS” with him. The feelings of two people who resent each other yet cannot let go cross inside a single song. Even as they sing one song together, the two voices never quite reach each other. (Advice) With “Knowing Me, Knowing You,” Sam opens up to Sophie about his own experience of marriage. The breakup song of the original has, in effect, moved over to become an older man’s rueful advice. Meanwhile Tanya laughingly shakes off the young man trailing after her with “Does Your Mother Know,” and Rosie follows by making the first move on Bill with “Take a Chance on Me.” These lively numbers give the audience room to breathe in a second act that grows steadily heavier. (Memory) Harry and Donna recall the summer of their youth together in “Our Last Summer.” The setting of the memory in the song is not a Greek island but Paris. It is a lovely season, but one already gone. Most of the songs in Act Two look back on the past like this, and that backward gaze slowly shifts the weight of the play from the search for a father toward the mother.
This is the duet Donna and Sam sing when they first stand squarely face to face. Feelings that resent yet cannot let go cross inside a single song.
- The two share one song, yet they sound less like they are speaking to each other than like each is delivering a monologue. The distance of being together and still not reaching each other is built right into the way the song speaks.
- The verse (the opening part that tells the story) hesitates in a minor-key color that sounds dark and lonely, then seems to burst open into a bright-sounding major key in the chorus. This contrast divides the pent-up heart from the cry that breaks free.
- The original is often cited as the song that put ABBA, who had stalled after “Waterloo,” back on the international charts.
- In the film, it was sung by Pierce Brosnan and Meryl Streep.
Harry and Donna retrace a summer from their youth together. The song embodies the mood of the second act's backward-looking numbers.
- A song sung on a Greek island summons a summer in Paris. That the song’s setting differs from the play’s present reminds us that this memory is already in the past.
- The melody flows calmly, never excited, creating the voice of reminiscence in which longing and regret are blended together.
- The original is a track from the 1980 album “Super Trouper.” It shows that not only well-known hit singles but album tracks too took important places in the show.
- In the film, it becomes a scene sung by the three would-be fathers and Sophie together on a boat, widening the two-person reminiscence into a song shared by many.
V. Through my fingers
(Preparations) On the morning of the wedding, Donna brushes her daughter's hair and helps her into the dress. “Slipping Through My Fingers” is the song of a mother watching her grown child and realizing how quickly their time together has slipped away. This duet, the quietest in the show, plants the true center, a mother and a daughter, in the middle of a story that has spent itself searching for a father. (Confrontation) Then Sam comes looking for Donna. In “The Winner Takes It All” she pours out, all at once, everything she has swallowed for twenty years. The very song that first gave Craymer the idea for the show is placed at its climax. In the original it sounds like resignation after a breakup; here it becomes a confession made face to face with one person. (Weight) This number lays the heaviest burden in the whole show on its performer. Over a song that begins low and calm and grows higher and darker with each verse, the actress playing Donna must act through singing. From Siobhán McCarthy in the West End premiere to Meryl Streep in the 2008 film, this scene has become the measure of each actress's Donna. (Silence) The brief silence after the song ends is the heaviest moment in the show. A stage that has rolled from one buoyant number to the next comes to a halt for the first time. In that stillness the audience senses that the wedding may not go entirely as planned. It is not the music but the place where the music stops that foreshadows the next scene.
A mother's song as she helps her daughter get ready on the wedding morning. The true center, hidden beneath the surface story of a search for a father, comes into view.
- The original is a parent's song about watching a child leave the house each morning. In the show that morning becomes the morning of the wedding, and the weight of letting go grows far heavier.
- This is the only duet in the entire show sung by mother and daughter alone. The way the two voices travel separately and then come together traces their relationship exactly.
- The original appeared on the 1981 album “The Visitors.”
- In the film it was sung by Meryl Streep and Amanda Seyfried, and, as on stage, it became one of the show's standout quiet scenes.
The show's climax, in which Donna pours out to Sam everything she has swallowed for twenty years. It is also the song that first gave producer Craymer the idea for the show.
- Over a piano accompaniment, a melody of the same shape repeats with each verse, rising and deepening little by little. Because the emotion builds through repetition, the performer can move within a single song from resignation to anger and on to confession.
- The original, sung by Agnetha Fältskog, topped the UK singles chart in 1980. On stage, a song of resignation becomes words spoken while looking one person straight in the eye.
- The brief silence that follows the song is part of the scene too. A show that has raced along on high spirits comes to a halt for the first time.
- On stage Donna sings directly to Sam; in the film the song was sung by Meryl Streep.
VI. A wedding that sings of dreams
(Wedding) The wedding march that fills the chapel is a slowed-down arrangement of “Dancing Queen.” The song with which the mothers reclaimed their youth in the first act now returns as the bride's processional. What is revealed here, and who makes which choice, is for you to discover in the theater. The music, though, does not hurry through this decisive passage. While the dialogue stretches on, the songs step back, returning only once hearts are settled. (Blessing) The song that returns is “I Do, I Do, I Do, I Do, I Do.” Its very title repeats the words of the marriage vow five times, and with brass and chorus it completes the ceremony in an unexpected way. All the crossed paths that have piled up dissolve at once into celebration. (Return) The show circles back to where it began. “I Have a Dream,” which Sophie sang alone as the curtain rose, sounds again at the end. The melody is the same, yet at first it is a vague wish, and at the end it is the song of someone who has lived through a great deal in a single day. The reprise, in which an earlier song comes back, closes the story into a single circle. (Curtain call) After the curtain falls, another show begins. The cast return in glittering costumes to sing “Mamma Mia” and “Dancing Queen,” and at the very end comes “Waterloo,” a song never heard in the show itself. The encore reaffirms the starting point: the songs came before the story. In 2008 the film version, again directed by Lloyd, was shot on the Greek island of Skopelos, carrying the same story onto the screen.
The song Sophie sang alone as the curtain rose sounds again at the end. Having crossed a single day, the same melody carries a different weight.
- A fine example of the reprise, in which an earlier song is sung again later in the show. Placing the same song at the beginning and the end closes the story like a circle.
- The original was released in 1979, with a children's choir from the Stockholm International School joining on the chorus. On stage Sophie fills that part alone, and the innocence of children's voices becomes a twenty-year-old's soliloquy.
- The overture and prologue, the cast album's first track, open with this melody, and the final track is this song as well.
- The film also opens with this song, carrying over the stage version's framing structure intact.
Lesser-known stories
(The date) The premiere on April 6 fell exactly twenty-five years after ABBA won the Eurovision Song Contest with “Waterloo.” But the reason behind the date was more practical. According to Craymer's recollection, director Lloyd was tied to an opera production schedule in London, so the show had to open by April 7 at the latest. Behind a date remembered as an anniversary lay a tight timetable. (The theater) As planning neared its end, the large Prince Edward Theatre became available. To fit its size, the cast and crew, the set and the budget all had to be expanded in a hurry. Today's grand staging was not planned from the start but scaled up after the fact. (The bet) Of the two composers, Andersson was the more cautious, and either of them could have halted the project at any time. Craymer and Andersson agreed that on opening night one of them would get to say, ‘See, I told you so,’ and the one who said it was Craymer. The story survives in Craymer's own account. (Cut songs) The current song list was not fixed from the beginning either. “Summer Night City” was used through the London previews before being cut, surviving only as a short instrumental fragment in the underscore. ABBA's unreleased song “Just Like That” is said to have been dropped just before the first public preview, though its title was printed in the preview program. (Hidden songs) ABBA songs that appear nowhere in the list of numbers are also hidden in the show. The wedding march is a slowed-down arrangement of “Dancing Queen,” and Donna hums a few bars of “Fernando” while fixing a door. Neither made it onto the cast album, so you can hear them only in the theater.
Glossary notes 📚🔎
Jukebox musical
(Meaning) A jukebox is a machine that plays a record when you insert a coin and choose a song. The “juke” is said to come from a word used in Black communities of the American South for a rowdy bar where people danced and partied. (In film·musical theater music) A musical built by stringing together already famous popular songs rather than songs newly written for the show. Some, like “Mamma Mia!,” use the songs of a single singer or group; others, like “Moulin Rouge,” mix songs from many eras. It is rather like making a playlist of your favorite songs, then inventing a story to fit their order and acting it out for your friends. The difficulty is that the songs were originally written for other stories, so each scene has to fit its song precisely.
Script (book)
(Meaning) In English the script of a musical is called the book. The name arose because the dialogue and scene structure, everything except the songs, is bound together like a single book. (In film·musical theater music) In a musical, crafting the dialogue, characters and plot between the songs is called the book, and the person who writes it is the book writer. In “Mamma Mia!” the songs already existed, so Catherine Johnson's book set the story around them, giving each song something to say in its place. It is like agreeing to sing three songs at a school talent show and linking them into one story with short skits in between. (Elsewhere) In everyday use a book is simply a book, and in horse racing or sports it can also mean the ledger in which bets are taken.
Orchestration (arrangement)
(Meaning) “Orchestra” comes from the orchestra of the ancient Greek theater, the circular floor in front of the stage where the chorus danced and sang. Orchestration means shaping music to fit that orchestra. (In film·musical theater music) The work of taking a piece whose melody and harmony are set, deciding which instrument takes which part, and clothing it in actual sound. The same piece can become lavish or forlorn depending on its orchestration. “Mamma Mia!” reworked the sound of ABBA's studio recordings so a theater band could play it every night, and it was nominated for the 2002 Tony Award for orchestrations. It is like tteokbokki made from the same ingredients tasting different depending on who seasons it and how. (Elsewhere) In information technology, coordinating and automatically managing many computers and programs so they run together is called orchestration.
Entr'acte (intermission music)
(Meaning) Entr'acte is French for “between (entre) the acts (acte).” (In film·musical theater music) In a two-act musical, the short piece the band plays just before the second act begins, once the intermission is over. It strings together a few bars from first-act songs to draw the audience back into the mood of the show. It appears on the “Mamma Mia!” cast album as the first track of act two. It plays a role much like a fight song ringing out again before the second half of a soccer match, calling the crowd back to their seats.
Reprise
(Meaning) Reprise is French for “to take up again, to repeat.” (In film·musical theater music) Singing a song heard earlier again later in the show. It may be sung the same way or with altered lyrics or mood, but because the story has moved on in the meantime, the same song takes on a different meaning. “I Have a Dream” in “Mamma Mia!,” placed at the beginning and end of the show, is one example. It is like singing the school song at graduation that you first sang at your entrance ceremony: the same song, yet it feels entirely different.
Major and minor
(Meaning) The jang and dan of jangjo (長調, major) and danjo (短調, minor) mean ‘long’ and ‘short.’ The names come from calling the interval between the first and third notes of the scale a major third when it is wide and a minor third when it is narrow. (In film·musical theater music) Major scales generally sound bright and vigorous, minor scales dark and forlorn. Film and musical scores use this difference to show a character's shifting heart. When a song hesitates in minor and then bursts open into major, it sounds as though pent-up feeling is breaking free. Play the children's song “The School Bell Rings, Ding Ding Ding” in a minor key and the very same tune suddenly sounds like a sad song; that is the difference between major and minor.
Glissando
(Meaning) Glissando is a musical term formed from the French glisser, “to slide,” with an Italian-style ending attached. (In film·musical theater music) A technique of joining notes in a sliding sweep rather than striking them one by one. On the piano the player runs a fingernail or the back of the hand along the keys, and the harp and trombone can make this sound too. The piano's cascading descent at the opening of “Dancing Queen” is exactly this, transforming the mood onstage within seconds. It is like sliding down from the top of a slide in one swoop instead of stepping down the stairs one at a time.