novareads.musicMusical

Jesus Christ Superstar

1971

It is music that layers electric guitar and symphony orchestra, gospel choir and vaudeville-style song within a single story, retelling the last week of Jesus through the troubled eyes of Judas, the betrayer.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. OriginsUK 1970 albumUS 1971 premiereTested as a single2. Point of viewJudas's uneaseA doubting JesusAn ending without resurrecti…3. SoundRock and orchestraOver a 5-beat meterVaudeville mockery4. ClimaxGethsemane's high notesThirty-nine lashesThe superstar question5. FilmDirected by JewisonThe Israeli desertThe bus framing device6. Legacy8 years in LondonLeading to EvitaThe album musicalSuperstar1971The last week of Jesus retold through the eyes…
Where the story unfolds 🧭🗺️
NPalestineBethanyJerusalem

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The makers ⏳🌊

  • ComposerAndrew Lloyd Webber

    He wrote this work by blending rock and orchestral music, and with the same partnership went on to create “Evita” and, later, “Cats.”

  • LyricistTim Rice

    His idea of telling the story through the eyes of Judas set the direction of the work.

  • DirectorNorman Jewison

    Shooting the 1973 film in the Israeli desert, he built a framing device in which the story is a passion play staged by a troupe of actors.

  • Lead roleTed Neeley

    He played Jesus in the film and has long been remembered for the high notes of “Gethsemane.”

  • LeadCarl Anderson

    Playing Judas on Broadway and in the film, Anderson brought a soul singer's voice and added depth to the character.

  • LeadYvonne Elliman

    Sang Mary Magdalene on the album, on Broadway and in the film alike.

Play all 8 on YouTube ↗

I. The record that came before the stage

(Proposal) The work is said to have begun with a suggestion from the church: Martin Sullivan, dean of St Paul's Cathedral in London, reportedly urged a musical about Jesus. Composer Andrew Lloyd Webber and lyricist Tim Rice hesitated at first. Only when Rice proposed telling the story through Judas's eyes did they find their way in. (Trial run) In the summer of 1969 the two began with a single song, “Superstar,” to test whether the public would accept such a subject. The single came out that November, with the instrumental “John 19:41” on the B-side. Unable to raise money for a staging, they released the whole work first as a double album. Recorded at Olympic Studios in London from March to July 1970, the album reached No. 1 on the US Billboard album chart in 1971. The stage followed after. (People) Lloyd Webber was a young composer with a classical training who had no qualms about rock. On the recording, Ian Gillan, newly joined to Deep Purple, sang Jesus, and Murray Head, fresh from the London run of the musical “Hair,” sang Judas. Members of Joe Cocker's Grease Band provided the backing. The same pair also launched “Evita,” covered elsewhere in this series, as an album first, and Lloyd Webber would later write “Cats.” (Film) The Broadway premiere opened in October 1971, and the London production the following year ran for eight years. Norman Jewison's 1973 film was shot in the deserts and ruins of Israel. It adopted a framing device in which a bus carrying the actors arrives in the wilderness and they begin the Passion play.

♪Overture1970

Before the curtain rises, it distills the work's entire sound world. In the film it plays over the actors arriving in the desert and preparing the performance.

  • The short, sharp guitar figure at the opening (a riff, a brief repeated instrumental phrase) serves as the work's signature.
  • Orchestra and synthesizer are layered one after another over the rock band, as if the classically trained Lloyd Webber were declaring an intent to bridge two worlds.
  • Melodic fragments of the songs to come flash by in advance, so returning to the start after hearing the whole reveals much that sounds new.
  • In the film version, André Previn's arrangement broadens the orchestra, lending it more of a film score's weight than the album version.
Listen on YouTube ↗

II. Judas's misgivings

(Overture) In the overture, orchestra and synthesizer pile up one after another over a sharp electric guitar. Without a single line of text, it announces that this work will tell a biblical story by blending rock and symphonic music. In the film, as this music plays, the actors step off the bus and unload sets and costumes. (Narrator) The first to sing is not Jesus but Judas. In the opening number, “Heaven on Their Minds,” he does not resent his teacher. He worries instead: if the crowd exalts Jesus as a god, Rome will not stand idly by, and then everything will collapse. The choice to open the story in the voice of a political realist set the color of the whole work. (Commotion) In the scene that follows, the disciples press about what lies ahead, and Mary Magdalene soothes Jesus with ointment. “Everything's Alright” sways along in units of five beats. Though it is a song of comfort, the ground beneath it is uneven. Judas cuts in over it, sharply asking whether the ointment could not be sold to help the poor. (Conspiracy) Meanwhile the high priest Caiaphas and the priests hold council. A low-lying bass and a piercing high voice face off until they reach the conclusion that one man must die to save the nation. The film added a short dialogue number not in the original, “Then We Are Decided,” to show the hesitation of Caiaphas and Annas.

♪Heaven on Their Minds1970Musical stage: Tim Minchin (Judas) · arena tour

Judas steps forward as the first narrator, confessing his anxiety for his teacher and his political fears. The work's point of view is fixed in this song.

  • A doggedly repeated guitar riff returns throughout the work like a marker of Judas's unease.
  • Murray Head on the album sings rough and direct, while Carl Anderson in the film uses a soul singer's wide range, giving the same Judas a different grain.
  • Judas sings of worry more than anger. The more we come to share that worry, the heavier the betrayal to come weighs on us.
  • In the film, a distant shot of Judas standing alone on a desert hill heightens the song's sense of isolation.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Everything's Alright1970Musical stage: Mel C·Tim Minchin·Ben Forster

A song in which Mary Magdalene soothes Jesus, with the quarrel between Judas and Jesus layered over it.

  • It moves in five beats to the bar (time signature 5/4). Because it never divides neatly into fours or threes, a strange unsteadiness lingers beneath the words of comfort.
  • Mary's gentle melody alternates with Judas's sharp interjections, revealing the relationship between the two within a single song.
  • Late in Act One, after “The Temple,” the song is briefly sung again (a reprise), and this time it sounds closer to a lullaby lulling a weary Jesus to sleep.
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. Hosanna and the Temple

(Entry) As Jesus enters Jerusalem, the crowd greets him with “Hosanna.” It is a hymnlike chorus, yet on the same stage Caiaphas's low voice warns that the crowd must be dispersed. Acclaim and threat collide within a single song. (Fervor) In “Simon Zealotes,” Simon the Zealot whips up the crowd's fervor and urges them to rise against Rome. The gospel-style chorus grows ever hotter, but in “Poor Jerusalem” Jesus quietly answers that none of them knows what they truly want. In the film Larry Marshall played Simon, turning the scene into dance on a desert hillside. (Foreboding) The brief “Pilate's Dream” begins with nothing but an acoustic guitar. The Roman governor calmly recounts the end of a Galilean he saw in a dream, a passage that foreshadows the trial to come. (Anger) In “The Temple,” the clamor of merchants and moneychangers storms past in a fast rock rhythm. After Jesus's anger erupts, the music suddenly slows; the sick throng around him, and he is worn out. There Mary briefly sings “Everything's Alright” again, followed by a song in which Mary lays bare her own heart. It is the most private monologue in the work. (Mary) Yvonne Elliman played Mary on the album, on Broadway and in the film. The film role earned Elliman a Golden Globe nomination.

♪I Don't Know How to Love Him1970Musical stage: Mel C (Mary) · arena tour

After the commotion of the temple scene, Mary is left alone, bewildered, unsure what it is she feels for Jesus.

  • Yvonne Elliman's album recording is documented as having been finished in a single take at Olympic Studios in June 1970. The unadorned voice suits the song's hesitant way of speaking.
  • In 1971 Elliman's single and Helen Reddy's cover sat in the Billboard Hot 100 top 40 at the same time, a rare case of two recordings of one song charting together.
  • This melody returns in Act Two, in “Judas' Death,” from Judas's own mouth. One character taking up another's melody to bind the two together is the leitmotif (leading motif) at work.
  • Elliman played Mary on the album, on Broadway and in the film, and was nominated for a Golden Globe for the film version.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. Silver and supper

(The deal) The turning point of Act Two is the scene in which Judas goes to the priests. In this passage, running from “Damned for All Time” into “Blood Money,” Judas keeps insisting he is not a bad man. The priests press the silver into his hand. Brass flashes in, and the priests coax him to spend the money on good works. Their tone sounds almost gracious. Here the music paints Judas not as a villain but as a man driven into a corner. (Supper) “The Last Supper” opens with a leisurely chorus. The disciples are giddy, saying they will write the Gospels someday. Over that calm, Jesus foretells betrayal and denial, and the music splits apart. The showdown between Jesus and Judas climbs ever higher, their voices crossing as if stabbing at each other. (Parting) After Judas leaves the table, the disciples fall asleep. The languid chorus returns with the same melody as before, yet now it sounds indifferent. The same song takes on an entirely different meaning depending on what surrounds it. (Conducting) André Previn supervised the film's music. Previn kept the album's rock-band sound while writing more broadly for orchestra, and the arrangement earned an Academy Award nomination for music, shared with Lloyd Webber and Herbert W. Spencer.

V. From the garden to the judgment hall

(Prayer) In the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus is left alone. The Jesus of this work is not a figure of certainty from the start. He is weary and angry, and asks why he must die. “Gethsemane” begins as a low monologue, soars to cries that all but argue with the Father, and finally subsides into acceptance. Ian Gillan on the album and Ted Neeley in the film both hit their highest notes in this song, and the passage is still counted as the hurdle any actor in the role must clear. (Arrest) In “The Arrest,” the crowd swarms like reporters, firing off questions. “Peter's Denial” is short and quiet. The music does not exaggerate the moment when what was foretold actually comes to pass. (Mockery) The song that overturns the mood in an instant is “King Herod's Song.” To a jaunty vaudeville (popular variety theater) piano and beat, Herod taunts Jesus to show him a miracle. This ludicrous number, thrust into the middle of a tragedy, lays bare the frivolity of power all the more chillingly. In the film Josh Mostel played the role. (Trial) In “Trial Before Pilate,” Pilate wavers to the end. In the passage counting out the thirty-nine lashes, the counting voice and the ever more violent orchestra lock together into the hardest few minutes of the work to endure. Meanwhile Judas realizes what he has done.

♪Gethsemane (I Only Want to Say)1970Stage musical Ben Forster (Jesus) · arena tour

Left alone just before his arrest, Jesus argues with God and questions him, and in the end accepts. It is the emotional peak of the work.

  • Its structure starts from a low, quiet monologue and bursts open as the pitch climbs and the orchestra thickens. A single song passes step by step through doubt, anger and resignation.
  • The top-note cries of Ian Gillan on the album and Ted Neeley in the film became emblems of the role, and today's actors playing Jesus are still measured by this passage.
  • The moment when the music suddenly falls away after the cry is crucial. In that space where the sound recedes, we hear the character's resolve.
  • In the decades since the 1973 film, Neeley has taken up the role again on stage.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪King Herod's Song1970Stage musical Alice Cooper (Herod) · In Concert

Breaking into the trials, King Herod mocks Jesus, daring him to work a miracle. It is a song that deliberately twists the course of the tragedy.

  • Vaudeville-style piano and rhythm (vaudeville being popular entertainment that strings together song, dance and jokes), recalling the variety shows of old America, deliberately clash with the rock music on either side.
  • The light, upbeat music lays bare the cruelty of the powerful. It sounds like a passage where laughter and terror sit side by side.
  • The melody of this song was originally “Try It and See,” submitted to Britain's 1969 Eurovision Song Contest preliminaries and rejected. With new lyrics, it found its way here.
  • In the film, Josh Mostel played Herod as a pleasure-seeking monarch.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. Superstar, and after

(Remorse) In “Judas' Death,” Judas sings again the melody Mary once sang. It is a moment when whom he loved, and how, is revealed not in words but in melody. Carl Anderson, who played Judas on Broadway and in the film, earned a Golden Globe nomination for the anguished cry of this passage. (Question) In “Superstar,” the dead Judas returns and sings like the host of a show. He asks why it had to be then and there, and who you really were. Backed by a female chorus on a soul-styled refrain, this is the most dazzling number in the work. The film adds a stage effect in which Judas appears as if descending from the sky. Jesus does not answer. That silence hands the question to the audience. (Stillness) By “The Crucifixion,” the rock rhythm has vanished. Electronic sounds, scattered orchestral fragments and Jesus's last words, breaking off at intervals, take the place of music. These few minutes, carried not by melody but by shards of sound, stand in contrast to every song before them. (Afterglow) What remains after that is “John Nineteen Forty-One,” a wordless piece for strings. While this music plays, the film returns to the framing device of its opening scene. What that final scene shows is better seen for yourself. But the fact that the work ends without singing of the resurrection stirred fierce controversy at its premiere, and it remains a point on which interpretations still divide.

♪Superstar1969Stage musical Tim Minchin (Judas) · arena tour

The dead Judas returns and asks Jesus who he really is. Written first and released as a single, it is the song from which the whole work began.

  • The refrain, backed by a female chorus, borrows the idiom of Black American church gospel and soul music. It feels as though a show stage suddenly opens at the end of the Passion story.
  • Murray Head's single, recorded in October 1969 and released in November, was the trial run that introduced the whole work to the world.
  • Judas only asks, and Jesus does not answer. A song built without an answer turns the question back on the audience.
  • In the film, Carl Anderson appears in white as if descending from above, revealing the director's intent not to paint Judas only in dark tones.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪John Nineteen Forty-One1969Film scene — Jesus Christ Superstar (1973)

A wordless piece for strings that plays after all the songs have ended. It is also the music that envelops the film's final scene.

  • The title points to the Bible verse describing the garden tomb where Jesus was laid. The choice to leave only strings in place of words stands in for the stillness of that place.
  • Because it follows the earlier tumult and the fragmentary sounds of “The Crucifixion,” even its simple flow of harmonies brings a deep sense of consolation.
  • It first appeared on the B-side of the 1969 “Superstar” single, so the beginning and the end both lead back to the first record through which the work reached the world.
  • In the film, the story returns to its framing device while this music plays, and that final image has drawn widely differing interpretations.
Listen on YouTube ↗

Lesser-known stories

(Recycled) The melody of Mary's song “I Don't Know How to Love Him” predates the work. In the autumn of 1967 it had already been published, with different lyrics, as a song called “Kansas Morning.” Rice set new words to the melody between December 1969 and the following January. It is recorded that the pair's agent, David Land, bought the song's rights back from the music publisher Southern Music for 50 pounds. That a signature song grew out of an exercise from their years of obscurity was easily overlooked once the work became a great success. (Rejected entry) The source of “King Herod's Song” is more unexpected still. In 1969 the two submitted a song called “Try It and See” to Britain's preliminaries for the Eurovision Song Contest. That year Britain's representative was Lulu. The song did not make the final shortlist. That breezy pop tune, its lyrics rewritten, became the song of a king mocking Jesus. The twisted humor of the place it occupies comes from this history. (Banned) It is a classic now, but its first reception was cold. The BBC at first refused to broadcast the album, calling it blasphemous. Performances were banned in South Africa and in what was then the Hungarian People's Republic. And yet a record also survives that Pope Paul VI praised the film version. That reactions to one and the same work diverged so sharply is seldom recalled today. (The vacancy) Ian Gillan, who sang Jesus on the album, turned down the film because of a Deep Purple tour. The man who took his place was Ted Neeley, then appearing on stage in “Tommy”; Jewison met him in person before giving him the role of Jesus.

Glossary notes 📚🔎

Rock opera

(In film · musical scores) A work that, like an opera, tells a continuous story from beginning to end, but through rock music. Electric guitar, bass and drums are at its core, and the songs serve as the characters' dialogue. Imagine staging an entire school play with songs by the bands your classmates love. (Elsewhere) Opera originally refers to the Western classical music drama performed by singers and an orchestra.

Concept album

(Literal meaning) Concept is the English word for an idea or plan, so a concept album is a record bound together by a single idea. (In film · musical scores) Rather than a collection of separate songs, it is an album built to flow from beginning to end around a single theme or story. “Jesus Christ Superstar” first appeared as just such an album before it ever reached the stage. It was less a book of short stories than a whole novel released in song. (Elsewhere) In advertising or fashion, concept means the creative direction that sets a look and a mood.

Sung-through

(Literal meaning) In English, sung-through means sung all the way through, from start to finish. (In film · musical scores) A musical form that carries the whole story in song, with no spoken scenes. Even when the characters quarrel or make plans, they do it in song. Think of a game in which you and your friends agree to talk only in rap all day. Lloyd Webber's “Evita” and “Cats” are close to this approach too.

Guiding motif (leitmotif)

(Literal meaning) In the German Leitmotiv, leit means 'to lead.' The term means a short motif that leads the story. (In film · musical scores) A short melody that recurs whenever a particular character, emotion or event appears. When it sounds, the audience recognizes what it is tied to. In this work, Judas later sings Mary's melody again, linking the two characters. It is like a game in which the same music plays every time the boss appears, and you tense up.

Riff

(In film · musical scores) A short, catchy figure that a guitar or bass plays over and over. In rock it serves as both the backbone and the face of a song. The sharp guitar in “Overture” and “Heaven on Their Minds” is an example. Like the short clapping rhythm repeated during a cheer on the playground, it lodges in your head after just a few hearings. (Elsewhere) In everyday English, riff also means to improvise at length on a given subject.

Time signature (5 beats)

(In film · musical scores) A sign that tells how many beats to count in a bar. Most songs are counted in four or three, but “Everything's Alright” is counted in five (5/4). This gives it a curious sway, as if each step goes one beat too far or falls one short of the familiar meter. It is like jumping rope to a count of one, two, three, four, five and feeling your feet slip slightly out of step.

Reprise

(Literal meaning) The French reprise means to take up again, to repeat. (In film · musical scores) The return, later in a work, of a song heard earlier. It is usually shorter, or its lyrics and mood have changed, revealing how circumstances have shifted in between. The brief return of “Everything's Alright” at the end of Act One is an example. It is like singing the class song from the start of the school year again at graduation, where the same song somehow sounds different. (Elsewhere) In fencing, a renewed thrust made immediately after a first attack is parried is called a reprise.

Vaudeville

(In film · musical scores) A form of popular variety entertainment that was hugely fashionable in America from the late 19th to the early 20th century. It strung together short turns of song, dance, comedy and acrobatics. When a musical uses music in this style, the mood becomes jaunty yet somehow comic and exaggerated. “King Herod's Song” is a case in point. Picture someone at a talent show deliberately mimicking an old-time comedy routine as they sing.