Florence Foster Jenkins
The film's music strives never to be the first to step across that precarious line between laughter and sincerity.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
The makers ⏳🌊
- ComposerAlexandre Desplat
A French-born composer who has worked with director Stephen Frears on several films since "The Queen" (2006).
- DirectorStephen Frears
Told this true story with a direction that holds warmth and distance toward its characters at once.
- ScreenplayNicholas Martin
Adapted Florence's life into a story in which comedy and affection coexist.
- StarringMeryl Streep
Took on the role of Florence Foster Jenkins, practicing a restrained style of singing deliberately off pitch while knowing exactly where the notes lay.
- StarringHugh Grant
She plays St Clair Bayfield, the companion who tries to shield her from the world's cynicism.
- StarringSimon Helberg
He plays her accompanist, Cosmé McMoon, and anchors the film's emotional center.
I. The New York patron
(The film) Set in New York in 1944, Florence Foster Jenkins tells the true story of Florence Foster Jenkins, a wealthy society patron who believed herself to be an opera singer. Stephen Frears directed, Meryl Streep took the title role, and Hugh Grant and Simon Helberg played the two men around her. (The composer) The music fell to Alexandre Desplat. The French composer had already worked with Frears on “The Queen” in 2006, and this time he was called back almost as a matter of course. (Character) Rather than pushing forward with grand gestures, Desplat's music tends to peer into a character's inner life through small forces. A chamber-music texture and a restrained sound centered on piano and strings are counted among his hallmarks. (The challenge) The task this film set him was a double one. He had to let the absurd songs Florence actually sings sound absurd, while still capturing, without a trace of mockery, the heartfelt love that lay behind them.
Desplat's main theme opens the film and sums up the heroine's world in a single phrase.
- The short melody of the opening returns throughout the film like a leitmotif pointing to Florence herself.
- The light exchange between strings and woodwinds shows how artificial, and how lovable, a stage her world really is.
- Its near-waltz motion points to the elegance of the 1940s New York society in which she lives.
- A harmony or two that is not entirely bright slips in, hinting early at the bitterness hidden behind the story.
II. Mistress of the Verdi Club
(The stage) The story begins in New York society, at the Verdi Club, the music patrons' circle Florence founded. She has long supported musicians, and she longs to take the stage herself. (The companion) At her side is St Clair Bayfield, a former actor and her companion. He has appointed himself the guardian of her world against the noise of reality. (The accompanist) Cosmé McMoon, the young pianist newly hired, cannot hide his shock the first time he hears her sing. Yet he soon comes to feel courtesy and affection for his strange employer. (Where the music sits) The music of this opening concentrates on introducing the characters. A short piano melody attached to McMoon and a theme that sums up Florence herself appear here for the first time and return throughout the film.
Desplat's short piano theme attached to the accompanist Cosmé McMoon.
- A brief melody for solo piano, it is a leitmotif that transcribes his cautious, courteous nature exactly.
- The choice of piano as the central instrument signals his position as an accompanist stepping into Florence's world.
- The way the melody fails to close cleanly, trailing off as if hesitating, suggests he cannot settle comfortably into the situation.
III. The laughing song
(Practice) Florence takes private lessons and throws herself into singing practice every day. She sincerely believes her voice is extraordinary. (Missing the mark) Her pitch and rhythm often go astray, yet she seems entirely unaware of it. Those around her swallow their laughter in her presence. (Complicity) Bayfield sweetens critics and reporters in advance, and the seats are filled with friendly faces. His protection is meticulous but not flawless. (Where the music sits) The laughter in this chapter is not cruel. These passages demand a performance that knows the right note and deliberately misses it, and they are designed as sound that holds comedy and affection at once.
Taken from Johann Strauss II's operetta, it is used at a small recital Florence gives for invited guests of the Verdi Club.
- In the original, it is a comic song sung by the maid Adele in the operetta Die Fledermaus, notable for passages that imitate laughter.
- Meryl Streep knows the correct pitches and sings them deliberately off, a restrained piece of acting far harder than simply singing badly.
- A highlight is the way Simon Helberg's accompanist, through his expressions and his piano playing, follows each mistimed beat and catches the laughter.
- Only by knowing how difficult the original's dazzling coloratura (ornamental runs that rise and fall rapidly) is can one fully grasp the drop in this scene.
IV. A voice on record
(The turn) Florence goes to a recording studio with McMoon and, as a Christmas gift for members of the Verdi Club, commits her voice to disc for the first time. This private record unexpectedly leaks out into the world. (The spread) Carried by radio and word of mouth, her singing becomes a craze laced with ridicule. She herself takes it as popularity and love. (The decision) Amid the growing attention, she resolves to take the stage at Carnegie Hall with one of Mozart's most difficult arias. Bayfield tries to stop her, but her mind is made up. (Where the music sits) In this film, the music divides into two voices. The flawless formal singing heard early in the film from Lily Pons's stage and the version Florence makes of the same melody in the lesson room are set side by side, laying bare the distance between ideal and reality.
Early in the film the formal operatic version rings out first from Lily Pons's stage, and Florence's version follows at her first lesson with McMoon.
- The most famous passage of Léo Delibes's opera Lakmé, it is a proving ground for coloratura sopranos, marked by bell-like high ornaments.
- Hear the version sung by a trained singer alongside the one Streep and Helberg create in the lesson scene, and the distance between the two voices becomes the story itself.
- The contrast of the same melody flowing flawlessly on one side and wobbling precariously on the other is the film's entire score in miniature.
V. Carnegie Hall
(The stage) In October 1944, Florence at last steps onto the stage of Carnegie Hall. The tickets sell out, and even soldiers in uniform fill the seats. (The performance) She sings the hardest pieces she has prepared. Laughter begins to break out bit by bit in the hall, but on stage she remains full of conviction. (The crack) For the first time, a gap opens in the protective shield Bayfield has guarded so carefully. Backstage and in the audience, the two men's gazes turn in different directions. (Where the music sits) The music of this chapter carries both a dazzling challenge and the precariousness beneath it. While the orchestra supports from behind, the voice on stage wavers somewhere between fulfillment and fracture.
The most difficult Mozart aria, which she attempts on the Carnegie Hall stage.
- The most famous passage in Mozart's opera The Magic Flute, it is counted as the summit of the coloratura soprano repertoire, demanding an extremely high range and rapid ornamentation.
- Why she chose this piece, of all pieces, explains at once the character's confidence and her innocence.
- The passage in which the voice onstage and the orchestral accompaniment drift apart, yet she presses on to the very end, is the most precarious moment in the film.
- Even on real opera stages it ranks among the most difficult pieces in the repertoire, so to grasp the drop in this scene it is worth first knowing the original's notoriety.
Desplat's orchestral cue, underpinning the concert's climax.
- The theme heard earlier expands across the full orchestra, lending weight to the evening's performance.
- So that the unrest in the audience and the conviction of the figure onstage can unfold at once, the music takes neither side and holds both.
- The passage where brass and strings swell together is one of the rare moments in the film that calls on a large ensemble.
VI. The final curtain call
(Homecoming) After the concert, Florence returns home. How much she comes to learn of the world's reaction is the part the film handles most delicately. (The question) A single question she puts to Bayfield carries the weight of the entire film. The few seconds of silence before the answer comes are the most musical moment in the work. (Resolution) Here Desplat's music finds a place that is neither mockery nor pity. It quietly retraces what it was she loved all her life. (Afterglow) By the ending the music returns to the melody of the opening, but heard with the whole story behind it, that melody no longer sounds the way it did at first.
Desplat's closing piece, gathering the story together.
- The melody, flowing in a calm tone that is neither mockery nor pity, is the film's very attitude toward its heroine.
- Her theme from earlier returns transformed, its harmony grown noticeably calmer, so that the same melody takes on a different meaning.
- Scoring that once again brings the piano forward turns the focus back to her bond with McMoon, and to a pure love of music itself.
The lesser-known story
Julia Kogan, a former opera singer, claimed that she had first proposed the idea for the film and contributed to the screenplay, and she waged a credit dispute that lasted some 5 years. In 2021 she was at last officially recognized as a contributor to the story and screenplay. Because this dispute is nowhere visible on the finished screen, most viewers watch the film unaware of it. Meryl Streep underwent real vocal training for the role, and producing a controlled error — knowing the correct pitch yet singing subtly off it — is regarded as an even trickier skill than simply singing well. The filmmakers and vocal coaches have described this preparation in a number of interviews. The recordings the real Florence Foster Jenkins made in the 1940s have been officially reissued and can still be heard today. Set the film's performance side by side with the actual recordings, and it becomes clear where the adaptation exaggerated and where, on the contrary, it held back. The real Carnegie Hall concert took place on October 25, 1944, and caused such a stir that tickets were scalped. According to her biographers, she died on November 26, a little over a month after the concert, and what happened in between is still told slightly differently from one biography to the next.
Notes on terms 📚🔎
Leading motive (leitmotif)
(Meaning) The German word leitmotif means a leading (Leit) motive (Motiv), and refers to a short melody used repeatedly to mark a particular character or emotion. (In film·musical scores) It is the practice of bringing back the same melodic fragment, slightly altered, whenever a character appears on screen or their feelings stir. Just as in a round the next singer takes up the same tune, the audience knows at once whose story it is from that melody alone.
Coloratura
(Meaning) Coloratura, Italian for coloring or ornamentation, comes from the idea of dressing a sound in brilliant decoration. (In film·musical scores) It refers to a highly demanding vocal technique that adorns the line with rapid runs up and down, or to a soprano who uses such technique. Think of the friend in gym class who is unusually good at the hard moves nobody else can pull off — coloratura is that friend in song.
Aria
(Meaning) The aria, from the Italian for air or atmosphere, is the passage in an opera where a character stops in their tracks and pours out their heart alone in song. (In film·musical scores) It is a song in which the plot pauses and the spotlight falls on one character's emotions. It is like the moment at a school show when the dialogue stops and one person sings a solo.
Operetta
(Meaning) Operetta, meaning little opera, refers to a musical stage work lighter than opera, with more spoken dialogue and a sense of humor. (In film·musical scores) Unlike serious opera, it denotes works that mix satire and farce. The “Laughing Song” Florence sings in this film is itself a number from an operetta.
Coda
(Meaning) Coda, Italian for tail, is a closing section attached separately to the end of a piece. (In film·musical scores) It is a short musical knot tied on after the story is over, to leave a lingering resonance. Like the postscript to a letter, it is one more line left behind after the body has ended.
Orchestration
(In film·musical scores) It is the work of deciding which instruments will play, how many, and how they are arranged. Depending on whether the scoring stays modest and centered on strings or summons everything down to the brass for grandeur, the same melody can feel entirely different. It is like deciding how many classmates will take which part in a class choir.