novareads.musicMusical

Dreamgirls

2006

The same song, sung in a different voice and a different arrangement, can change a person's place in the world. The music of this film tells a story in which the song itself becomes power.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. OriginsUS release 2006From the 1981 Broadway showChicago→Detroit2. PeopleKrieger's musicCondon's adaptationHudson's debut3. IndustryRainbow RecordsWhite coversPayola4. Two voicesEffie's cryDeena's "Listen"Lead vocal swap5. ArrangementBallads and discoThe Underdogs' arrangementsFour new songs6. LegacyTwo Oscar winsNo. 1 on the Billboard 2003 Best Original Song nomineesDreamgirls2006Three women singers from Detroit, a chronicle …
Where the story unfolds 🧭🗺️
NUnited States of AmericaDetroitMiami BeachLas VegasLos Angeles

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The creators ⏳🌊

  • ComposerHenry Krieger

    The composer of the original musical, he wrote four new songs for the film and conducted the orchestra for the soundtrack.

  • LyricsTom Eyen

    He wrote the book and lyrics for the original show, won the 1982 Tony Award for Best Book of a Musical, and died in 1991.

  • DirectorBill Condon

    The screenwriter of “Chicago,” who wrote and directed this film and moved its setting to Detroit.

  • StarringJennifer Hudson

    Made a film debut as Effie White and won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress.

  • StarringBeyoncé Knowles

    Played Deena Jones and helped write the new song “Listen.”

  • StarringEddie Murphy

    Earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor as the showman James “Thunder” Early.

Play all 7 on YouTube ↗

I. From stage to screen

(The original) “Dreamgirls” has its roots in a musical that opened at Broadway’s Imperial Theatre in December 1981. It tells the story of a Black female vocal group in the 1960s and 70s rising from backup singers who prop up other people’s songs to pop stars. Director Michael Bennett built the staging in a near sung-through style, carrying most of the dialogue in song, and the show ran for 1,521 performances. (The composer) The music was written by Henry Krieger, a New York–born composer who spent his twenties writing for off-off-Broadway stages. In 1975 he and the writer Tom Eyen made a musical version of “The Dirtiest Show in Town,” and after seeing Nell Carter on that stage, the two conceived a story about Black backup singers. Krieger won a Grammy for the original cast album. (The film) The film version was written and directed by Bill Condon, who had written the screenplay for “Chicago.” Because the lyricist Eyen had died in 1991, Krieger wrote four new songs with other lyricists and conducted the orchestra for the soundtrack himself. The production team The Underdogs reworked the original arrangements, keeping the texture of the period while dressing them in the sound of contemporary R&B, and Stephen Trask contributed additional score. (The move) The stage version was set in Chicago, but the film moved the story to Detroit, home of the Supremes and Motown. With the addition of Rainbow Records, a label absent from the stage, the story widened from the rise and fall of one group into a history of the Black music industry. In its tangle of musicians, the managers who made them, and their record label, it shares a grain with this series’ “Straight Outta Compton.”

II. An amateur stage in Detroit

(The contest) 1962, an amateur talent contest at a Detroit theater. The Dreamettes — Effie White, Deena Jones and Lorrell Robinson — take the stage with “Move,” a song written by Effie’s brother C.C. Tight, compact three-part harmony and, in front of it, Effie’s big, full voice: this is the group as we first meet it. (The break) Whatever the contest’s outcome, Cadillac salesman Curtis Taylor Jr. snaps them up. Curtis lands them a job singing backup for the rhythm-and-blues star James “Thunder” Early, and in Jimmy’s number “Fake Your Way to the Top” the three stand behind someone else’s song for the first time. Jimmy, played by Eddie Murphy, recalls showmen like James Brown and Jackie Wilson, and his stage-churning moves ride straight on the rhythm of the song. (The cover) Curtis launches Rainbow Records out of his car dealership and releases its first single, “Cadillac Car.” But a white group promptly re-records the song, and the original is buried. The scene transplants into the story the cover practice of the 1950s and 60s, when white singers smoothly re-sang Black singers’ songs and took over the radio. (The sound) The music in this stretch is still modest. Beginning as small-combo rhythm and blues, the sound changes into ever more lavish clothes, adding strings and brass as the group grows. The shifting arrangements serve, in effect, as the story’s timeline.

♪MoveFilm scene — Beyoncé

The first song the Dreamettes sing, at the Detroit amateur contest. The film’s opening scene uses it to show the group as it originally was.

  • Harmony in which three parts interlock tightly recalls the girl-group sound of the early 1960s. Before anyone has been chosen as the star, the three sound like a single body.
  • Listen to Effie’s big voice leaping out in front of that harmony. The music tells us first that the group’s center was, at the start, Effie.
  • It is a short song of just over 2 minutes. Its length, ending as if chased off the stage, holds the hurried air of an amateur contest.
  • In the original stage show, too, this was the song of the contest scene that raises the curtain. The film placed it as track 1 on the album, making it the story’s point of departure.
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. The lead vocal changes

(Payola) The lesson Curtis draws from the failure of “Cadillac Car” is that a good song alone won’t get you on the radio. Paying off disc jockeys — payola — Curtis pushes the next single, “Steppin’ to the Bad Side,” up the charts. The song swells into a big ensemble in which Curtis, C.C., Jimmy and the three women trade sounds back and forth, and the moment Curtis crosses the line coincides with the moment the music is most exhilarating. (Miami) At an upscale Miami Beach club frequented by white patrons, Jimmy’s raw act is shunned. Curtis sends Jimmy off on a solo tour and sets the three women center stage under the name the Dreams. Then the lead vocal shifts from Effie to Deena. The calculation: winning over white audiences too requires a light, smooth voice. (Family) What holds the wavering troupe together is C.C.’s song “Family.” It is bitter that a song about leaning on one another as one household is used to make them accept the very decision that splits that household apart. (Demotion) The new song “Dreamgirls” lays Deena’s clear voice over glittering strings and a sleek pop rhythm. Effie now sings harmony from behind. The song announcing the group’s success also records one person’s demotion. Deena, played by Beyoncé Knowles, is drawn at this point as someone who faithfully produces the sound others have chosen.

♪Steppin’ to the Bad Side

The passage where Curtis manufactures a hit through payola. The label’s first step over the line is portrayed as the most exhilarating ensemble.

  • The voices of Curtis, C.C., Jimmy and the three women build up in a back-and-forth in which one sings and the many answer (call and response). It is the album’s signature ensemble, with seven voices woven together.
  • The lyrics cheerfully sing of stepping over to the bad side. Yet the scene is one where kickbacks are actually changing hands. The joy of the song and the darkness of the scene are deliberately set at odds.
  • As the song goes on, the scoring seems to grow and the rhythm to quicken. The music, in effect, keeps pace with the record climbing the charts.
  • The Broadway veteran Hinton Battle sings along. In the original, this was a big Act 1 number showcasing Michael Bennett’s choreography.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪DreamgirlsFilm scene — Beyoncé·Jennifer Hudson

The song that becomes the group’s new face after the lead vocal passes to Deena. It is a song of success, and a song of Effie being pushed to the back.

  • Unlike the raw rhythm and blues so far, the strings glitter and the rhythm is sleek. You can hear that the sound has turned to crossover pop aimed at white audiences too.
  • Deena’s clear, light voice steps forward, and Effie recedes into the harmony. Who sings from which position is itself the map of power.
  • This song shares its title with the work itself. It returns as the finale in the last scene, so it pays to remember the melody well on first hearing.
  • The song’s stage scene was dressed in costumes and lighting that recall the Supremes’ 1960s television appearances. The theater lighting designers Jules Fisher and Peggy Eisenhauer handled the film’s stage lighting.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. A song that refuses to leave

(The rift) In the mid-1960s the Dreams become the hottest group around, but Effie’s place keeps shrinking. When this is compounded by a walk-off in the middle of a television performance, Curtis brings in the secretary Michelle Morris as a new member. On New Year’s Eve 1966 in Las Vegas, Effie is pushed out of the group. (The quarrel) “It’s All Over” is a quarrel conducted in song. Five people trade clipped bits of melody, piling up emotion, in a scene close to operatic recitative — singing as if speaking — translated into the idiom of R&B. The more the voices tangle and rise, the more isolated Effie becomes. (The cry) Next comes “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going.” Where everyone has turned away, Effie sings that she will not leave, that they must not abandon her. Beginning almost as speech, the song swells into a gospel plea and at the end surges into belting that breaks through the entire orchestra. Though the one who should answer has already gone, the song does not stop. (The debut) Jennifer Hudson won the role of Effie through an audition that drew 783 applicants, and this was Hudson’s first film. The scene took four days to shoot. In the stage version this song closed Act 1; in the film, too, it sits at the point where the story breaks at the waist, closing the first half.

♪And I Am Telling You I’m Not GoingFilm scene — Dreamgirls (2006)

The song Effie unleashes when she is left alone after the quarrel; the first half of the film closes here. It became the emblem of the entire work.

  • It flows on without a break from the quarrel of the preceding “It’s All Over.” At first it is less a song than something close to sobbing speech. Listen for the point where the boundary between dialogue and song collapses.
  • As the song goes on, the accompaniment thickens and the voice surges into a technique that drives the chest voice up into the high notes (belting). The idiom of gospel, a plea to God in church, is carried over into a plea addressed to one man.
  • In the 1981 original, Jennifer Holliday sang this song and won the Tony Award for Best Actress. Holliday’s recording reached No. 1 on the Billboard R&B chart in 1982 and won a Grammy.
  • In the film Jennifer Hudson sang it and, in a debut role, won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. For the song’s music video, the scene from the film was used as is, rather than separately shot footage.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. One song, two versions

(Years later) 1973. The Dreams have become superstars, and Rainbow has moved its headquarters to Los Angeles. Curtis, now married to Deena, is absorbed in a plan to make his wife the star of a film of “Cleopatra.” Meanwhile, back in Detroit, Effie is raising her daughter alone and living on welfare. (Message) Jimmy records “Patience,” a song that carries the air of its time. Sung with Lorrell, C.C. and a gospel choir, it is rejected by Curtis as too heavy. A single song reveals what the label sells and what it throws away. At Rainbow’s 10th-anniversary show, Jimmy starts in on his assigned number, then upends the stage with an improvised rap, and is thrown off the label on the spot. In this chapter Jimmy’s story closes in tragedy. (Comeback) On the stage of a neighborhood club, Effie sings “I Am Changing.” If “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” was a song that clings to someone, this is a song that rebuilds oneself. The same voice turns in another direction. (Hijack) Reconciled with Effie, C.C. writes “One Night Only” for his sister. When the song catches on locally, Curtis has the Dreams rerecord it as a disco version and pushes it with payola. One song splits into ballad and disco, and the two are crosscut against each other on screen. What was done to Curtis with “Cadillac Car,” Curtis now does to Effie.

♪Patience

A song Jimmy records with a message for the times, only for Curtis to reject it. It is one of four songs written new for the film.

  • The lyrics are by Willie Reale. It is the first time Jimmy, once a flamboyant showman, speaks calmly to the world, and the song recalls the way soul music in the early 1970s was turning its eye to social issues.
  • Eddie Murphy, Anika Noni Rose as Lorrell and Keith Robinson as C.C. are joined by a gospel choir. The arrangement lets the voice spread outward from one person to a community.
  • This is the song the label discards. The audience watches a beautiful song being kept from the world. The scene shows what Curtis’s Rainbow is beginning to lose.
  • It was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Song. At the end of disc 2 of the deluxe edition is a conductor’s demo of the song played by Krieger himself, so you can hear its skeleton before the arrangement.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪One Night Only / One Night Only (Disco)Film scene — Beyoncé·Jennifer Hudson

The moment when Curtis hijacks the ballad C.C. wrote for Effie, turning it into a disco version for the Dreams. Two versions of the same song face off on screen.

  • Effie’s version is a slow ballad built on piano and voice. Her plea to stay by her side for just one night is recorded so close you can hear her breathe.
  • The Dreams’ version dresses the same melody in a fast disco beat, strings and glittering sound effects. Depending on the arrangement (the reworking of a song’s instruments and rhythm), the same tune flips in meaning from a desperate confession to a dazzling dance number.
  • The film stages the contest between the songs through crosscutting that alternates the two versions. What happened in chapter 2, when “Cadillac Car” was buried by a white cover, is repeated this time by Curtis’s own hand.
  • The disco version was first released in late summer 2006 as a 12-inch club single and a digital download. In the stage version, too, the face-off between the two versions was the central scene of Act 2.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. A demand to be heard

(Awakening) Los Angeles. Deena learns that Curtis hijacked “One Night Only,” and of all his dealings along the way. Deena reaches out to Effie, and the two women, long estranged, sit face to face again. Here the film’s center of gravity returns to the relationship between the two women. (New song) “Listen” was written new for the film. Scott Cutler and Beyoncé Knowles added melody to Krieger’s music, and Anne Preven wrote the lyrics. The stage version had no solo in which Deena pours out her heart at length; the film filled that gap and made Deena another protagonist of the story. (Voice) In the song, Deena demands that the man who made her finally listen to what she has to say. Deena’s voice, a light and controlled pop vocal in “Dreamgirls,” here begins quietly over piano and opens wide over a full orchestration. Someone who had only ever made the sounds others chose for her uses her whole range for the first time. (Mirror) If “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” is a song about refusing to leave, “Listen” is a song about being able to leave. The signature songs of a woman abandoned by one man and a woman bound to one man stand facing each other like mirror images. Heard back to back, they make it clear that this film is ultimately the story of two voices.

♪ListenOfficial MV — Beyoncé

The song in which Deena, who could never speak in her own voice, sings what is truly in her heart for the first time. It was written new for the film and does not appear in the stage version.

  • It begins quietly with a few piano notes, and as the song unfolds, strings and drums join one after another. The growing size of the orchestration traces someone who hesitates and at last lays her whole heart bare.
  • Deena’s voice, lightly reined in on “Dreamgirls,” here opens out with full force in the upper register. Listen to the same actor’s two songs back to back and your ears will tell you how much the character has changed.
  • The music is by Krieger, Scott Cutler and Beyoncé Knowles, the lyrics by Anne Preven. It is a rare case of a lead actor helping to compose her own character’s song.
  • It was nominated for the Academy Award and the Golden Globe for Best Original Song and won the Broadcast Film Critics Association Award for Best Song. Before the film opened, it went to radio first as the soundtrack’s first official single.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. Back to the first stage

(Homecoming) The Dreams give their farewell concert at a Detroit theater, the very stage where the story began. In “Hard to Say Goodbye” the three sing a song of parting with the stage, and when they reach the final number, their positions on the stage change. (Reprise) The finale, “Dreamgirls,” is a reprise of the song from chapter 3. A song that once pushed one woman to the back now rings with an entirely different meaning. The melody is the same, but the voice standing in front of it and the place of the harmonies have shifted, so the same song sounds like both an apology and a homecoming. (Gaze) This last scene holds one more moment that the song does not put into words. The film sets that moment at the point where the music swells the highest. So the audience feels its weight through the music before any line of dialogue explains it. What that moment is, it is best to see for yourself. (Legacy) The film received 8 Academy Award nominations and won Best Supporting Actress for Jennifer Hudson and Best Sound Mixing. All three songs nominated for Best Original Song were written new for the film. The soundtrack reached No. 1 on the Billboard 200. In following a singer through collapse and recovery in song, it pairs well with this series’ “La Vie en Rose.”

Lesser-known stories

The work’s first title was “One Night Only.” Krieger and Eyen began it with Nell Carter in mind and at one point staged it at a Joseph Papp workshop under the name “Project #9.” But in 1978, when Carter took a role in a television series, the work stalled. 1 year later Michael Bennett revived it as “Big Dreams.” The title of what later became the central number of Act 2 was, in other words, originally the name of the whole show. In the early workshops, Effie was a character who died at the end of Act 1. Jennifer Holliday, then a twenty-year-old gospel singer, objected, and Act 2 was eventually rewritten to enlarge Effie’s role. The story of Effie’s comeback that audiences know today came out of that rewrite. Because it belongs to the backstage history of the workshops, it is almost unknown to those who have seen only the finished show. The film adaptation was long delayed. David Geffen, who held the rights, turned down a number of offers after Bennett’s death in 1987 in order to protect the original staging. In the late 1980s Howard Ashman was preparing a film starring Whitney Houston, and in the late 1990s director Joel Schumacher envisioned Lauryn Hill as Deena and Kelly Price as Effie, but none of it came to pass. The 1982 original cast album left out about half the score, since scenes that run song and dialogue together had to be cut down into stand-alone tracks. The two-disc deluxe edition of the 2006 film soundtrack covered far more, including songs used onstage, and slipped a hidden track in at the end of disc 2. The album reached No. 1 on the Billboard 200 in week 5 of its release; the following week it held the top spot with 60,000 copies sold, then the lowest figure ever for a No. 1 album. It was a No. 1 earned in the holiday-season lull.

Glossary 📚🔎

Sung-through

(Word origin) The English sung-through means that a piece is sung (sung) from start to finish (through). (In film·musical scores) A musical form that carries nearly every scene in song, with almost no separately spoken dialogue. The stage version of “Dreamgirls” came close to this approach, while the film added more spoken dialogue. Imagine setting everything you have to say to a friend to song. Greetings, quarrels and making up all become song. In a sung-through musical, that really happens.

Recitative

(Word origin) From the Italian recitare (to recite), it means a song sung as if reciting. (In film·musical scores) Originally, the passages in opera sung close to the rhythm of speech to move the plot along quickly. It pairs with the song that spins out a beautiful melody at length (the aria). Scenes like “It’s All Over,” in which the characters trade quarrels in short melodic phrases, draw on this tradition. Think of reading a poem aloud in language-arts class, not flatly but with its rhythm alive. It sits somewhere between speech and song.

Belting

(Word origin) The English belt means to let loose loudly and forcefully. (In film·musical scores) A technique that carries the chest resonance of the speaking voice straight up into the high notes, singing them loud and strong. Rather than slipping lightly into falsetto, it pushes through with a full sound, so it is often used in scenes where emotion erupts. It is like calling out to a friend at the far end of the schoolyard, putting the force not in your throat but in your belly and chest. A singer, though, lands that sound precisely on pitch and sustains it. (Elsewhere) In everyday English, a belt is the strap worn around the waist.

Backup singers

(In film·musical scores) The singers behind the lead who add harmonies and answer the refrains to fill out the song. The three women of “Dreamgirls” start out as Jimmy’s backup singers. The scene in which Effie steps back to sing harmony after the lead vocal changes shows that the difference in role was a difference in rank. Picture a choir contest where the whole class holds up the harmonies behind a classmate singing solo. They are less visible to the audience, but they lay the foundation of the sound.

Call and response

(Word origin) In English, it means a call and a response. (In film·musical scores) A practice in which one person sings a line and others sing back as if answering. A tradition handed down from African music and the gospel of Black American churches, it became the backbone of rhythm and blues and soul. The way several characters trade lines in “Steppin’ to the Bad Side” follows this pattern. It works on exactly the same principle as a cheer squad at a game, where the leader shouts one chant and the crowd answers with the next.

Reprise

(Word origin) The French reprise means to take up again, to repeat. (In film·musical scores) Singing a song heard earlier again later in the show. Rather than repeating it exactly, it is often sung after the situation has changed, loading the same melody with new meaning. The finale of “Dreamgirls” is a reprise of the song from chapter 3. It is like singing the school song you first heard as a new transfer student again at graduation, where the same song sounds entirely different. (Elsewhere) In fencing, a reprise is a renewed attack made immediately after the first one is parried.

Payola

(Word origin) Coined by attaching -ola, a suffix common in American phonograph brand names of the 1920s–30s, to pay. (In film·musical scores) The practice of a record label secretly giving money or gifts to radio DJs or stations to get its songs played often. In the United States it became a major scandal in the late 1950s and was then outlawed. In “Dreamgirls,” Curtis moves the charts this way not once but twice. Think of secretly handing out snacks to win votes in a class-president election. The problem is that popularity is manufactured by money rather than by the song being good.