novareads.musicMusical

Brassed Off

1996

In the year the colliery shut its gates, the marches and hymns the band played were no longer cheerful tunes. They were the sound of a dignity one village tried to keep to the very end.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. DepartureUK, released 1996Grimethorpe true storyDirected by Mark Herman2. SoundGrimethorpe bandConducted by John AndersonJones's brief cues3. OpeningOrange JuiceFlugelhorn solo4. TurnDanny Boy outside the hospit…Band on the brink5. ClimaxWilliam Tell OvertureMusic stops, a speech6. AfterglowElgar atop the busClosing pit-closure captionsStaged at the CrucibleOff1996A year in the life of a miners' band that held…
Where the story happens 🧭🗺️
NUnited KingdomGrimethorpeDelph (Saddleworth)BirminghamLondon

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The people behind it ⏳🌊

  • ComposerTrevor Jones

    A Cape Town–born film composer who worked in Britain, he put the band's playing front and center and bridged the story with brief cues.

  • DirectorMark Herman

    Writing and directing, he brought Grimethorpe's 1992 to the screen as a feature film.

  • ConductorJohn Anderson

    He conducted the Grimethorpe Colliery Band on the film's soundtrack.

  • Lead actorPete Postlethwaite

    He played Danny Ormondroyd, the conductor who sees the band as the village's dignity.

  • Lead roleTara Fitzgerald

    Played Gloria Mullins, who comes home carrying a flugelhorn.

  • Lead roleEwan McGregor

    Played Andy Barrow, the tenor horn player.

Play all 4 on YouTube ↗

I. The pit village band

(Background) “Brassed Off” is a British film written and directed by Mark Herman. Its setting, the Yorkshire mining village of Grimley, is invented, but its model is Grimethorpe in South Yorkshire. In October 1992 the British government announced the closure of more than thirty pits, Grimethorpe among them. That same month the Grimethorpe Colliery Band won the national championship at the Royal Albert Hall. The film grew out of the fact that these two events happened together, in a single village. (Performance) Most of the brass heard in the film was played by the real Grimethorpe Colliery Band, conducted by John Anderson. Even in the scenes where the actors hold instruments, the sound belongs to the bandsmen. The flugelhorn solos were played by Paul Hughes, the cornet solos by Shaun Randall. (Composer) The original score was written by Trevor Jones. Born in Cape Town and trained in Britain, he made his name with films such as “The Dark Crystal,” “Labyrinth” and “The Last of the Mohicans,” and is known as a composer who handles large orchestras and electronic sound side by side. In this film, though, he steps back. Of the nineteen tracks on the soundtrack album, only six are his cues (short pieces of music fitted to a scene), and most of those last about a minute. The choice can be read as a recognition that the film's true protagonist in music is the marches and arrangements the band plays. (Connection) Ewan McGregor, who plays Andy, would sing for himself a few years later in “Moulin Rouge!,” which this series has covered. Here his instrument is the tenor horn.

II. Orange Juice

(Everyday life) The film opens by cutting between the shift change at the pit and the band's rehearsal room. For the conductor, Danny Ormondroyd, the band is not a hobby but proof that the village is still alive. The bandsmen pick up their instruments the moment they come up from the shaft. The marches they play carry a military-band dignity, but the faces of the players are steeped in the weariness of rumored closure. (Homecoming) Into that rehearsal room walks Gloria Mullins with a flugelhorn. She grew up in this village, and her grandfather was a celebrated bandsman. At first Danny hesitates over a woman player. But the piece Gloria pulls out to play is Rodrigo's “Concierto de Aranjuez.” The bandsmen call it 'Orange Juice,' which it sounds rather like. (Joining) When the jaunty “Floral Dance” ends and the room falls quiet, Gloria begins the slow adagio melody. One by one, the men who had been clowning around go silent. In this passage the film accepts Gloria into the band not through dialogue but through a single solo. (Secret) The audience soon learns that Gloria works for the colliery management and has come to assess the pit's profitability. Caught between old feelings for Andy and the village's suspicion, her position will send us back to this performance again and again.

♪Floral DanceFilm scene — Brassed Off

The piece the band was playing the day Gloria first came to the rehearsal room. The Aranjuez solo follows right after this jaunty tune ends.

  • Katie Moss wrote this piece about a spring festival in Cornwall. The same rhythmic pattern repeats over and over, giving the feel of walking as if in a dance.
  • A favorite of British brass bands, it sounds to the audience like familiar local music. The contrast with the unfamiliar Spanish melody that follows is sharp.
  • Its light, bright mood makes the stillness of the adagio that follows all the more striking. By setting the two pieces side by side, the film creates the moment when the air in the rehearsal room changes.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪En Aranjuez Con Tu AmorFilm scene — Brassed Off

The piece the bandsmen call 'Orange Juice.' With this single flugelhorn solo, Gloria becomes part of the band.

  • The original is the slow second movement of Rodrigo's “Concierto de Aranjuez,” written for guitar and orchestra. Here the flugelhorn takes the singing melody in place of the guitar.
  • The flugelhorn has a wider bore than the trumpet, giving it a rounder, darker sound. Its tone, which whispers like a human voice rather than soaring brilliantly, suits Gloria's quiet confidence.
  • The actual player is Paul Hughes of the Grimethorpe band. The scene is matched so that the actor's fingering and the bandsman's sound are heard as one.
  • The grace notes at the ends of phrases, that is, ornaments (short notes that brush quickly past the main note), imitate the bends of flamenco singing. It sounds as if southern light had suddenly fallen into a Yorkshire rehearsal room.
Listen on YouTube ↗

III. The vote and the debts

(Vote) The miners must vote on whether to accept the redundancy package the company has put on the table. The union wants to fight, but those who remain are already exhausted. The film does not turn this conflict into a loud scene. Instead it shows empty seats appearing, one by one, in the rehearsal room. To say you are quitting the band is also to say you are leaving the village. (Breadwinner) Danny's son Phil is hounded by debt. The bailiffs strip the house, and his wife leaves with the children. Phil earns money by dressing as a clown at children's birthday parties. The scenes in which a face at the end of its rope shows through the comic makeup are the most painful in the film. (Contest) Still, the band enters the contest. The scene in which bands march one after another through the streets of a hill village was actually filmed on the main street of Delph, in the Saddleworth area. It transplants the Whit Friday band contest held there every year. The brisk beat of the marches and the slumped shoulders of the bandsmen share a single frame. (Score) In this chapter Trevor Jones's cues pass briefly. They are heard only as threads stitching the village's time together, leaving the work of lifting the emotion to the band's playing. In this structure, the film score retreats behind the music performed within the story rather than decorating the scenes.

♪We'll Find a Way

The longest of Trevor Jones's cues on the soundtrack. It holds the hearts of characters searching for something to cling to amid collapsing households and shaken relationships.

  • The other Jones cues run from thirty seconds to just over a minute, but this one lasts more than 3 minutes. It is where the film gives its original score the most room.
  • Its hallmark is a writing style that stays in the background rather than ringing out like the band. It sounds less like music that speaks the scene's emotion for it than music that stands quietly beside the characters.
  • The title belongs to the same family as track names that seem drawn from lines of dialogue. Set beside other cue titles such as “A Sad Old Day” and “Honest Decent Human Beings,” it suggests that Jones attached his music in units of dialogue and emotion.

IV. Night outside the hospital

(Turn) What changes the story's direction is Danny's body. His lungs ruined by years in the pit, he collapses after a performance and is taken to the hospital. Around the same time, the pit's fate is sealed. Gloria discovers that her report never meant anything from the start. The decision had already been made. (Disbanding) The bandsmen decide to fold the band. They have neither the money nor the will left to go to the final. The place they choose for their last performance is not a stage but the lawn outside the hospital where Danny lies. In the dark of night, the miners stand with their instruments, looking up at his window. (Performance) The piece they play is Percy Grainger's arrangement of “Danny Boy,” that is, the “Londonderry Air.” The Irish folk melody unfolds slowly over the low harmonies of the brass. That the conductor's name matches the title of the piece comes across like the bandsmen's awkward sincerity. Standing at the window of his hospital room, Danny says nothing. (Stillness) In this scene, the silence after the music lingers as long as the music itself. Without applause or cheers, the bandsmen lower their instruments. The film seems to be saying that the band is finished here. Yet it is in this very silence that the resolve leading to the next chapter begins to grow.

♪Danny Boy – Londonderry AirFilm scene — Brassed Off

The piece the bandsmen, on the verge of disbanding, play at night on the hospital lawn for their fallen conductor. They believe it will be their last performance.

  • Percy Grainger's arrangement of the old Irish folk tune, the “Londonderry Air.” Beneath the melody, the harmonies shift slowly, casting a deep shade.
  • The band's low instruments sustain long notes like an organ, laying down a floor on which the melody can float. It suits the still air of the night scene.
  • The shared name of the piece and the conductor is the scene's hidden device. Through the music, the bandsmen hand him the words they could not say to his face.
  • The silence after the music ends is part of the scene, too. Because no applause is heard, the final chord stays longer in the ear.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. The Albert Hall

(Resolve) The bandsmen gather again. The money to get to the final comes from an unexpected source. Their faces as they board the bus are not excited but rather calm. It looks less like a journey to win than a journey to leave a record that they saw it through to the end. (Stage) The final at London's Royal Albert Hall was actually filmed at Birmingham Town Hall. The seats are packed with contest spectators, and on stage the Grimley bandsmen wear band uniforms instead of their pit clothes. The piece they have chosen is Rossini's “William Tell Overture.” (Gallop) When the fast march at the end of the overture is carried over into brass, the film's pace quickens all at once. The cornets split the same note rapidly without pausing for breath, while below them the euphoniums and tubas hold up a beat like hoofbeats. The weariness and loss built up over the earlier chapters turn, for these few minutes, into pure skill and power. (Withholding) What happens on stage after the performance is the heart of this film. It will not be revealed here. Let it only be said that in that scene the music stops, and that Danny's voice fills the silence. The very structure, in which a speech takes the place where the overture's roar has faded, shows what this film means to say.

♪William Tell OvertureFilm scene — Brassed Off

The piece the Grimley band plays in the final at the Albert Hall. For a few minutes, accumulated weariness and loss turn into skill and power.

  • The final section of the overture Rossini set before his opera, a galloping march, arranged for brass band by G. J. Grant. The cornet solo is played by Shaun Randall.
  • At its heart is double tonguing (a technique that alternates two strokes of the tongue to split fast notes). This is where the sound comes from, surging on without pause like the beat of hooves.
  • In the orchestra the fast notes belong to the strings; here the brass must carry every one of them. That is why it was chosen as a showpiece for the contest stage.
  • It is a tune made familiar by cartoons and commercials. Yet in this scene the familiarity is not comic at all; it sounds instead like the release of people who have held back for a long time.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. The march on the bus

(Homecoming) In the final scene the band members ride through the streets of London on an open-top double-decker bus. Danny conducts from the front, and the band plays the best-known passage of Elgar's Pomp and Circumstance March No. 1, its slow middle section. It is the melody the British remember as the song "Land of Hope and Glory." (Paradox) This melody usually rings out at state occasions and celebrations. But when miners who have lost their jobs play the same piece, its meanings pile up in layers. Pride and a bitter smile, love for home and a question put to the nation all live together inside a single melody. The film does not decide which it is; it simply lets us hear it. (Record) As the music plays, brief captions about real pit closures and lost jobs scroll across the screen. In this way the film adds, at the very end, that the story we have just watched was not entirely invented. (Resonance) If Buena Vista Social Club, covered earlier in this series, showed musicians who kept on playing after an era had faded, Brassed Off shows people who would not put down their music in the very year their livelihoods collapsed. Both films show that music can be not a means of making a living but a thread that holds a community together.

♪Pomp and Circumstance

The piece Danny conducts in the final scene, atop a double-decker bus passing through London. The band plays the slow middle section of Elgar's March No. 1.

  • The slow, broadly singing middle section of a march is called the trio. In Britain this trio melody is better known as the song "Land of Hope and Glory."
  • In J. Ord Hume's brass band arrangement, the melody begins in the low register and builds gradually upward. The sound widens little by little, keeping pace with the bus as it moves down the street.
  • Usually a melody for state occasions, but played by miners from a closed pit it carries pride and irony at once. Which way to hear it is left to the audience.
  • As the music plays, captions about real pit closures pass across the screen. The music rings out like a festival while the words on screen are a record, so the film's final impression lingers in layers.

Lesser-known stories

(Four days) The film dramatically intertwines the pit closure with the contest victory, but in reality the interval was even shorter than in the film. The government announced its plan to close pits, Grimethorpe among them, on October 13, 1992. The Grimethorpe Colliery Band won the National Championship at the Royal Albert Hall four days later, on October 17. Frank Renton conducted, and the test piece was Philip Wilby's "The New Jerusalem." According to the records, several band members were reportedly still working at that colliery at the time. Because the film did not retell these events directly but transposed them to the fictional Grimley, the real dates survived only in the records of the brass band world. (Filming) The Whit Friday street contests are traditionally held in late spring. Yet the day the Delph contest scene was filmed is recorded as October 23, 1995. Some local papers wrote that it was shot on the actual contest day, so memories differ. The Albert Hall scene, too, was filmed not in London but at Birmingham Town Hall. Even people who have seen the film many times rarely know that the final stage audiences take for London was in fact another city. (Sampling) A passage from Danny's speech was sampled the following year at the opening of Chumbawamba's hit "Tubthumping." Many people know the song, but few know that the voice heard before it begins comes from this film. (Stage) In 1998 the film premiered as a play in Paul Allen's adaptation at the Crucible Theatre in Sheffield, then moved on to the National Theatre in London. The music for this stage version was also performed by the Grimethorpe Colliery Band. In effect, the real band took part twice in a drama based on its own story.

Glossary 📚🔎

Brass band

(Literal meaning) Brass means the metal alloy, yellow brass. The name of the metal the instruments are made from became the name of the ensemble itself. (In film·musical scores) An ensemble made up solely of brass instruments, such as cornet, flugelhorn, tenor horn, trombone, euphonium and tuba, plus percussion. In Britain, from the 19th century on, workers' bands sprang up at every colliery and factory, competing in regional and national contests. It is much like a school sports team that goes through regional qualifiers to reach the nationals. A band like Grimethorpe was the team that represented its village. (Elsewhere) In English, brass is also used for high-ranking military officers or the top people in a company. The film's title, Brassed Off, is a pun that combines brass with the sense of being thoroughly fed up.

Original score

(Literal meaning) A score originally means the full score, gathering the parts for many instruments in one place. In film it came to mean all the music newly written for that film. (In film·musical scores) Music that is not borrowed from existing pieces but newly written by a composer to fit the film's scenes. In Brassed Off, the short pieces by Trevor Jones are the original score, while the marches and arrangements the band plays are existing works. It is the difference between playing a famous song for a school play and a classmate composing a piece just for that play. (Elsewhere) In sports, a score means the points.

Cue

(In film·musical scores) A single segment of music that starts and stops to fit a particular scene in a film. Some last a few seconds, others several minutes. Most of the Trevor Jones pieces on the soundtrack album are short cues of about a minute. Think of it as a fragment of music that enters where the scene changes, the way the music shifts in a game the moment the boss appears. (Elsewhere) In theater and broadcasting, a cue is a signal telling an actor or crew member to begin. In billiards, it is the stick used to strike the ball.

Flugelhorn

(Literal meaning) The German Flügel means wing or flank. The name is said to come from a horn once used in hunting or the army to send signals to the flanks of a formation. (In film·musical scores) It resembles the trumpet in shape and pitch, but its tubing is wider and flares in a conical shape, giving a soft, round tone. A brass band usually has just one, and it is often given slow, lyrical solos. Just as the same song feels different shouted across a playground and sung quietly into a friend's ear, if the trumpet is a shout, the flugelhorn is closer to a whisper.

Arrangement

(Literal meaning) Pyeongok (編曲) means 'weaving (編) a piece together.' It is the work of reshaping an existing melody to suit different instruments or a different ensemble. (In film·musical scores) The task of redistributing a piece originally written for orchestra or guitar among the instruments of a brass band so it can play it. That the William Tell Overture and the Concierto de Aranjuez sound in brass in this film is thanks to the arrangers. If you rewrite a song you learned from piano music for a recorder ensemble, you have to adjust the pitch and harmony to fit the instruments, and that is exactly what arranging is.

Test piece

(In film·musical scores) The set piece that every competing band in a brass band contest must play. Having everyone play the same piece allows a fair comparison of the bands' abilities. The test piece at the real 1992 National Championship was Philip Wilby's "The New Jerusalem." It is like a jump-rope contest, where everyone must perform the same moves so the judges can compare who does it better.

Trio

(Literal meaning) Italian for three. The name survives from the old custom of playing the middle section of dances and marches lightly on three instruments. (In film·musical scores) The middle section of a march or minuet, usually slower and flowing like a song, that sits between the vigorous outer sections. The most famous melody in Elgar's Pomp and Circumstance March No. 1 is precisely this trio. It is like a field day where the whole school slowly sings its school song between fast cheering chants. (Elsewhere) In everyday use, it means a group of three people, or a performing group of three.