The Who
The violence of a sound that smashed guitars and the ambition to raise an opera from the wreckage lived side by side in a single band.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
Members and associates ⏳🌊
- MemberRoger Daltrey
The leader and singer who founded the Detours, he brought Townshend's songs to life onstage with his body and his voice.
- MemberJohn Entwistle
A player who raised the bass to a lead instrument, he wrote the band's black-humored songs such as "Boris the Spider" and died in 2002.
- MemberPete Townshend
Handling guitar and most of the songwriting, he designed Tommy and Quadrophenia.
- MemberKeith Moon
A drummer who churned up whole songs rather than keeping time, he died in 1978 at thirty-two.
- ManagerKit Lambert
As manager and producer, he instilled in the band a pop-art image and the ambition of the rock opera, and died in 1981.
- RivalryJimi Hendrix
A labelmate at Track Records and the rival who faced them over the running order at Monterey in 1967.
I. Four young men from west London · 1944–1964
(Formation) The band formed in London, England, in 1964. Its ground was the working-class neighborhoods of west London that link Acton, Shepherd's Bush and Chiswick. Its roots lay in the Detours, a local band Roger Daltrey had been leading for several years. (Daltrey) Daltrey was born in Hammersmith in March 1944. He left school early and put the band together while working in a sheet-metal factory, playing lead guitar at first. Toughened by factory labor, he was the band's de facto boss in its early days. (Entwistle) Born in Chiswick in October 1944, John Entwistle had formal musical training on piano, trumpet and French horn. He joined on bass around 1961. His habit of standing motionless on stage, only his fingers flying, later earned him the nickname 'the Ox.' (Townshend) Born in Chiswick in May 1945, Pete Townshend was the son of Cliff, a saxophonist in the RAF dance band, and Betty, a singer. A school friend of Entwistle's, he took over guitar in 1962. He later recalled that Gustav Metzger's lectures on 'auto-destructive art' at Ealing Art College were the root of his guitar-smashing on stage. (Moon) In the spring of 1964, seventeen-year-old Keith Moon from Wembley stepped into the seat a departing drummer had left. The story goes that he offered to sit in at a gig, hammered so hard he broke the drum pedal, and was hired on the spot. (Chance) That year the band briefly worked as the High Numbers, then took on Kit Lambert and Chris Stamp, both former assistant film directors, as managers and became the Who once more. Lambert, the upper-class son of the composer Constant Lambert, and Stamp, from the East End, were a pair of opposites. That autumn, at a gig at the Railway Hotel in Harrow, Townshend jammed his guitar neck into the low ceiling and snapped it. When the audience burst out laughing, he smashed the guitar outright, and the accident soon became the band's ritual.
II. My generation · 1965–1967
(Debut) In January 1965 their first single, “I Can't Explain,” made with the American producer Shel Talmy, reached No. 8 on the British chart. Townshend made no secret that he had written it in imitation of the Kinks. Jimmy Page, who would later form Led Zeppelin, is said to have played on Talmy's sessions as a session guitarist. Page recalled that Moon's joke that a new band would go down like a lead balloon planted the seed of the name Led Zeppelin. (Image) Lambert packaged the band as pop art: jackets cut from the Union Jack, target T-shirts, and the slogan 'Maximum R&B' on the posters for their Tuesday residency at the Marquee Club. Townshend made the windmill, a wide sweep of the arm to strike the strings, his stage signature, while Daltrey made his of whirling the microphone by its cable. (Generation) In the autumn of 1965 “My Generation” rose to No. 2 in Britain, and the band became the voice of the mod generation. Around then, after a fight among the members, Daltrey was briefly pushed out of the band before returning, and he wrote in his autobiography that from then on he resolved to keep his temper in check. (Contract) To break free of the Talmy contract, Lambert released “Substitute” on another label in 1966, and Talmy sued. Under the settlement, Talmy is said to have collected royalties on Who records for years afterward. So the song the Sex Pistols would later cover came into the world tangled up with money. With the cost of the gear they wrecked at every show on top of that, the band is said to have been short of money even while scoring hits. (Monterey) In 1967 Lambert and Stamp founded Track Records and signed Jimi Hendrix, newly arrived in London. That June at the Monterey Pop Festival in America, the two camps clashed over the running order; a coin toss sent the Who on first, and they smashed their gear. Hendrix followed by setting his guitar on fire. The show opened the door to America. The year-end The Who Sell Out was a playful album with fake radio ads slipped between the songs.
Spitting postwar working-class teenage defiance at the adult world in a stammer, the song made the band, at a stroke, the voice of the mod generation.
- Listen first to Daltrey's delivery. In every verse he deliberately stutters before words, a device explained both as an imitation of a pilled-up mod and as a borrowing from the stammering vocals of blues songs. The other members answer him with short choral replies in a back-and-forth (call and response) structure.
- Between the verses Entwistle's bass steps forward for a short solo. In the pop singles of the day it was rare for the bass to take the lead. The story goes that his strings kept snapping during the sessions, so he bought several of the same bass.
- As the song goes on, the tonal center (key) rises a step at a time, again and again. Feel the tension build as the same song repeats from ever higher ground.
- In the final stretch, the guitar's long howl against the amp (feedback) tangles with Moon's drum barrage, and the song ends as if collapsing. It sounds like the on-stage destruction of gear carried over to tape.
III. Pinball and opera · 1968–1970
(Baba) Around 1967 Townshend fell deeply under the teachings of the Indian spiritual master Meher Baba. In the middle of an era of hallucination and tumult, he found meaning in Baba's disciplined thought, and that interest became the foundation of his next work. Ever since the 1966 9-minute mini-opera “A Quick One,” Lambert had kept urging him to write a longer story. (Tommy) Tommy, the double album of May 1969, told the story of a boy left unable to see, hear or speak by a childhood trauma, who becomes an idol through his skill at pinball and, once awakened, is abandoned by his followers. Lambert shaped the song order and the dramatic arc like a stage director. The themes of spiritual awakening and mass idolatry carried questions drawn from Baba into the language of rock. (Stage) The album sold hugely, and the band's finances are said to have improved greatly. Performances of Tommy in its entirety peaked at dawn at Woodstock in August 1969, and in June 1970 they reached New York's Metropolitan Opera House. (Leeds) Once tagged an opera band, they proved the opposite. Live at Leeds, recorded in February 1970 at a show in the Leeds University refectory, captured the raw sound of the four almost untouched. Townshend's short, heavy, chopping guitar, Entwistle's bass moving like a lead instrument, Moon's drums storming without a gap, and Daltrey's voice fighting for space on top all locked together. It is still counted among the greatest live albums in rock history. (Accident) That January, outside a pub in Hatfield, Moon was driving to escape a crowd when he ran over and killed his own driver, Neil Boland. The inquest ruled it an accident, but those close to him testified that he never shook it off for the rest of his life.
Weaving spiritual questions drawn from Meher Baba and the theme of mass idolatry into a two-disc story, this album turned a singles band into a rock-opera band.
- The opening track, “Overture,” is an operatic prelude that lays out the album's main melodies in advance. Listen for the French horn, played by Entwistle himself.
- The signature track “Pinball Wizard” begins on acoustic guitar. Townshend's fast strumming, with the middle note of each chord held on a different note (suspended chords), builds tension before thick electric chords burst in. He said he wrote it to win over the critic Nik Cohn, a pinball fan.
- The studio recording sounds lighter and thinner than you might expect. Compare the same songs with the Woodstock or Leeds recordings and you can hear how much heavier and rougher they became on stage.
- The repeated choral passage late in the final track is the part that was playing at Woodstock just as the sun came up. Follow it from its start, like a quiet prayer, to the swell of the whole band.
Made just as the opera-band label was sticking, it is the record that proved how fierce a band the four were on stage.
- In the signature track “Young Man Blues,” the band keeps stopping dead mid-song and then hitting single notes one at a time, a stop (break) passage. Listen closely for the moments when silence and roar trade places.
- Townshend ran a Gibson SG Special into Hiwatt amps for a thick, tearing tone (distortion). With no rhythm guitarist, he moves between chords and solos on his own.
- Entwistle's bass is effectively a second lead instrument. Listen for the bass filling with fast lines the space left when the guitar heads off into a solo.
- “My Generation” stretches into an improvised medley of nearly 15 minutes, with fragments of melody from Tommy surfacing along the way.
- The original LP flaunted its raw, in-the-room feel, with a sleeve dressed up like a bootleg and even a note to the effect that the crackling noise should not be corrected.
IV. A failed dream and two masterpieces · 1971–1974
(Lifehouse) After Tommy, Townshend dreamed bigger: “Lifehouse,” a combined film·stage project depicting a future society in which music binds people together. In early 1971 he even staged experimental shows at London's Young Vic theatre, building songs together with the audience, but the concept was hard even for his bandmates to follow, and in the end it collapsed. Townshend recalled being deeply worn out by the failure. (Next) When the recording begun with Lambert in New York fell apart, producer Glyn Johns culled the remaining songs into a single album: Who's Next, released in August 1971. Locking repeating organ figures and synthesizers into the roar of a rock band, the album went to No. 1 in Britain. The fragments of a failed project had become the band's finest work. (Independence) In 1973 the band built its own studio, Ramport, in Battersea, London. The members each began releasing solo records, Entwistle first, in 1971. When Daltrey questioned the accounts, relations with Lambert·Stamp cracked, and Bill Curbishley eventually became the new manager. (Quadrophenia) Quadrophenia, from October 1973, told the story of Jimmy, a mod boy of the 1960s who heads for the sea at Brighton in search of his identity. Jimmy's four split personalities were expressed through four themes, each modeled on one of the band members. It was a look back dedicated to the mod audience that had followed them in their early days, and a work in which a band on the threshold of thirty turned to examine its own origins. (Tour) The tour was rocky. The band had to play along to prerecorded synthesizer tapes, and the machines often fell out of sync. In November, at the Cow Palace in San Francisco, Moon collapsed from pills he had swallowed before the show, and Scot Halpin, a nineteen-year-old in the audience, came up on stage to drum the final songs.
Salvaged from the collapsed “Lifehouse” project, the song paints both a wasted teenage landscape and a longing for liberation. Its title comes from Meher Baba and Terry Riley, the composer of repetitive music.
- The relentless repeating notes of the intro were made with the automatic repeat function of a Lowrey organ. Don't miss the moment when, after the same figure has run on for a long while, the piano and Moon's drums come in.
- Listen for the change in vocal delivery. Daltrey sings the verses with force, then Townshend takes over the middle section in a gentle voice.
- At the end Dave Arbus's violin enters and speeds up, racing on like an Irish dance (a jig). It was reportedly Moon who suggested bringing in this player.
- Producer Glyn Johns's recording lets every instrument be heard clearly apart. Notice the clean, solid sound, with drums and organ never smothering one another.
A song that looks back on the late 1960s, swept up in revolutionary fervor, with a cynic's conviction that the world will not change even when new faces take power.
- Underpinning the whole song is a repeating figure made by running an organ through the filter of a synthesizer (EMS VCS3) so that it throbs like a pulse.
- The album version runs over 8 minutes 30 seconds. In an era when the 3-minute single was the norm, the sheer length, with its long guitar riffs, verses and instrumental stretches, was radical.
- Late in the song the whole band drops out, leaving a long passage of synthesizer alone. At its end, Moon's drums storm in and Daltrey lets out a long scream, one of the most famous moments in rock history.
- The film of Moon's last performance, shot at Shepperton in 1978, is of this song too. Compare it with the studio version and hear how freely his drums roam.
The band's second rock opera, which revisits its roots through the story of a young mod named Jimmy, made at the band's own studio, Ramport.
- Four themes, each modeled on one of the four members, recur throughout the album. Listen and compare how the same melody returns in the first and last tracks.
- Field recordings of waves, rain and passing trains link one song to the next. They paint the story's setting, the Brighton seafront, in sound.
- Entwistle recorded the brass parts in layer upon layer (overdubbing), building a sound as thick as an orchestra's. Listen for the layers of horns in a song like “5:15.”
- The centerpiece, “Love, Reign o'er Me,” opens with rain and thunder before Townshend's piano enters. The long, soaring high note Daltrey sustains at the end is counted as the moment his voice climbed highest.
V. The rock band at thirty · 1975–1978
(Film) In 1975 Ken Russell's film Tommy opened. Daltrey took the title role, stepping out as an actor, and Elton John, in a pair of gigantic boots, sang “Pinball Wizard.” Elton John's recording was also released as a single and made the British charts. (Confession) That same year, on The Who by Numbers, Townshend wrote head-on about the doubts and self-disgust of a rock star reaching thirty. The light, jaunty “Squeeze Box” was a hit, but the album as a whole is regarded as his most intimate confession. The stage, meanwhile, remained as enormous as ever. In May 1976 a concert at Charlton Athletic's football ground in London topped 120 decibels and entered the Guinness Book of Records as the loudest concert ever. (Punk) In 1977, on the night after a thirteen-hour meeting with Allen Klein over royalties, Townshend ran into the Sex Pistols' Steve Jones and Paul Cook at a London club. The young punk musicians, whom he had expected to write him off as the old guard, told him instead that they admired the Who, and he later recalled that the confusion and self-questioning of that night became the basis of the song “Who Are You.” (Decline) In the mid-1970s Moon moved to Los Angeles and sank deeper into drink. He put on weight, and his playing faltered. A performance filmed at Shepperton Studios in May 1978 for the film The Kids Are Alright became his last appearance before an audience. (Death) On September 7, 1978, three weeks after Who Are You came out in August, Moon died in a flat in Mayfair, London. He was thirty-two. He had overdosed on a medication prescribed to help him stop drinking. The night before, he had attended a Buddy Holly tribute hosted by Paul McCartney. On the album cover, the back of the chair he sits in is stenciled with the words 'Not to be taken away.'
A song about the confusion and questions of identity from the night he met the punk generation, and the title track of the last album Moon left behind.
- In the intro, layered choral voices repeat the title over a pulsing synthesizer figure. The song is built from questioning voices stacked one upon another.
- Midway through, the tempo suddenly slows and only an acoustic guitar remains. This quiet passage (the bridge), set in the heart of a rough rock song, is where the song catches its breath.
- Entwistle's bass traces melodies beneath the chords without pause. Listen to the left and right speakers in turn to hear how the guitar and bass are divided.
- The album version runs over 6 minutes; the single was cut short. Only the album version lets you hear the long instrumental stretch in the second half intact.
VI. After Cincinnati · 1979–1989
(Jones) The remaining three decided not to stop. In 1979 Kenny Jones, formerly of the Faces, took over the drums, and keyboardist John 'Rabbit' Bundrick joined them. That same year the films Quadrophenia and The Kids Are Alright were released, bringing mod culture back to life for a new generation. (Tragedy) On December 3, 1979, just before a concert at the Riverfront Coliseum in Cincinnati, fans holding general-admission tickets surged toward the few doors that had been opened, and 11 people were crushed to death. Fearing chaos in the hall, the authorities did not tell the band until the show was over. When the members heard the news they were devastated, and at the next day's concert in Buffalo they paid tribute to the victims. In later years the members are known to have spoken of it as a deep wound. (Farewell) Face Dances (1981) and It's Hard (1982) groped toward a new sound with the new drummer, but Townshend felt he could no longer write songs for the Who. In 1982 the band set out on a farewell tour. In October the Clash opened for them at Shea Stadium in New York. It was a scene of punk sharing a stage with the very generation it had set out to pull down. The tour ended in Toronto in December. (Reunion) The breakup did not last long. In July 1985 they played again with Kenny Jones at Live Aid at Wembley in London, where the BBC broadcast signal cut out in the middle of “My Generation.” On the 1989 tour marking their 25th anniversary, they revived Tommy with a large ensemble complete with horns and backing singers. The financial straits of Entwistle, a lavish spender, are also cited as one reason for the reunion. In 1990 the band was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
VII. A band of two · 1990–2025
(Revival) In 1996 the Who staged Quadrophenia in its entirety at a charity concert in London's Hyde Park, and began working as a regular band again. Zak Starkey, Ringo Starr's son, took the drums. As a child, he is said to have received a drum kit from his godfather, Keith Moon. (Charity) From 2000 Daltrey led the Royal Albert Hall concerts of the Teenage Cancer Trust, a charity that supports teenagers with cancer. The shows became an annual gathering of fellow musicians. (Loss) On June 27, 2002, the day before an American tour was to open, Entwistle died of a heart attack in a Las Vegas hotel room. He was fifty-seven. The autopsy found that cocaine had aggravated an existing heart condition. After much deliberation, the remaining two brought in Pino Palladino on bass and carried on with the tour. (Legacy) Endless Wire, in 2006, was their first new studio album in 24 years. The band played the Super Bowl halftime show in 2010 and the closing ceremony of the London Olympics in 2012, and in 2019 released the album Who. The admiration of later generations continued as well. Pearl Jam rerecorded “Love, Reign o'er Me” for a film in 2007, and Eddie Vedder has long delighted in singing the Who's songs on stage. (Farewell) In the summer of 2025 the two set out on a North American farewell tour, “The Song Is Over,” named after a song from the Who's Next era. Of the four young men from Shepherd's Bush in the 1960s, two remained, having kept the same name alive for more than 60 years.
Lesser-known stories
(Stack) The tower of amplifiers that became an emblem of the rock stage, the so-called Marshall stack, is said to have grown out of the Who's demands. In the mid-1960s Townshend and Entwistle pressed the London music-shop owner Jim Marshall for more volume, and Marshall built a huge cabinet holding eight speakers. When it proved too heavy to move, it was split into two four-speaker cabinets stacked one atop the other. The story is told both in the Marshall company's records and in Townshend's recollections, but because the equipment came to be remembered more widely through the images of Hendrix and Led Zeppelin, the Who's part in it has faded. (Film) When Lambert and Stamp found the Who, they had not set out to become managers. The two, both assistant film directors, meant to make a documentary about an unknown band's rise to success, and the black-and-white footage they shot at the Railway Hotel in 1964 survives as a trace of that plan. The film was never finished, and management became their real work. The story only became widely known with the 2014 documentary Lambert & Stamp. (Hull) Live at Leeds was originally to be recorded alongside the next night's concert in Hull, with one of the two to be chosen. But on the early songs of the Hull recording, Entwistle's bass dropped out because of a technical problem, so the Leeds show was chosen. The Hull concert was released for the first time only in a 2010 anniversary edition, 40 years later. Townshend also recalled having earlier burned many of the tapes from the band's 1969 American tour to keep them from leaking out as bootlegs.
Notes on terms 📚🔎
Feedback
(Meaning) The English word feedback joins 'to give food' (feed) and 'returning' (back), meaning that what is sent out comes back in again. (In rock) It is the long howl that arises when a guitar's pickup takes in the sound coming from the amp and that sound goes back out through the amp, round and round. Originally it was an accident to be avoided, but guitarists like Townshend tilted their guitars toward the amp to summon the sound on purpose and used it in their playing. The ear-splitting squeal you hear in a gym or auditorium when a microphone is held close to a speaker, that is feedback. (Elsewhere) In everyday life it is more often used to mean giving comments back on homework or work.
Power chord
(In rock) A chord in which a guitarist strikes only two notes, the root and the note a fifth above it. Leaving out the middle note, which decides whether a chord sounds bright or dark, makes the sound hard and thick, and it doesn't turn to mush even when heavily distorted. Townshend played these chords with his windmill, swinging his arm in a wide arc to strike down on the strings. In cooking terms, it is like stripping away all the seasoning and bringing out the ingredients boldly with nothing but salt and pepper.
Rock opera
(Meaning) The word opera comes from the plural of the Latin opus, meaning a work or a labor, and carries the sense of a large work in which song, acting and staging come together. (In rock) A rock album or performance that links several songs to tell a single story. It has characters, and melodies heard early on return later to bind the story together. The Who's Tommy and Quadrophenia are the classic examples. If a single song is one episode of a webtoon, a rock opera is the whole series, which you must follow from start to finish for the story to be complete.
Synthesizer
(Meaning) Synthesizer comes from synthesize, meaning to combine, and refers to building sound by combining it electrically. (In rock) An instrument that creates and shapes sound from electrical signals. With devices such as filters that cut a sound's brightness, it sculpts tones that never existed before. On Who's Next, Townshend ran organ sounds through a synthesizer to make them throb like a pulse. It is like mixing a few paints in art class to produce countless colors. (Elsewhere) In chemistry and biology, synthesis refers to combining several substances to make a new one.
Overdubbing
(Meaning) Over means on top, and dub means to record sound onto something, so the word means laying sound over what has already been recorded. (In rock) A technique for recording a new performance on top of one already recorded. It lets one person sound as though they were playing several instruments at once. On Quadrophenia, Entwistle recorded the brass again and again in layers to create an orchestral sound. It is like laying transparent sheets over a drawing one at a time and drawing on each in turn. (Elsewhere) Dubbing often refers to replacing a film's foreign-language dialogue with Korean voices.
Mod
(Meaning) A shortening of the English word modernist. (In rock) A culture that arose among working-class young people in London in the early 1960s. Tailored suits and scooters, American soul and R&B, and clubs where they danced all night were their badges, and they faced off against the rockers, who favored leather jackets and motorcycles. The Who were the mods' most beloved band, and Quadrophenia is a portrait of that world. It is like a crowd at school who wear the same brand of sneakers and love the same singer, and can recognize one another by their clothes alone. (Elsewhere) In gaming, a mod, short for modification, is an expanded version of a game reworked by its users.
Distortion
(Meaning) The English word distortion means twisting something out of shape. (In rock) A tone made by deliberately driving the guitar signal hard into the amp so the sound tears and sizzles. In the 1960s players got this sound by turning the amp all the way up, and later it was also produced with a foot-operated device (a pedal). Shout too loudly into a megaphone and your voice cracks; distortion takes that cracked sound and uses it on purpose as an instrument's color. (Elsewhere) It also refers to the warping of shapes seen in a photograph or a mirror.