The Velvet Underground
They brought the darkest streets of 1960s New York and its most experimental music rooms together on a single record.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
Members and associates ⏳🌊
- MemberLou Reed
He handled vocals, guitar and songwriting, singing the stories of the street in the language of literature; he left the band in 1970, went solo, and died in 2013.
- MemberJohn Cale
A classically trained musician from Wales, he brought in electric viola and drones to shape the early sound, and after leaving the band worked as a producer and solo artist.
- MemberSterling Morrison
He played guitar interlocking with Reed's, as well as bass, and after leaving the band earned a doctorate in medieval English literature.
- MemberMaureen Tucker
Playing standing up, with a bass drum turned on its side and mallets, she laid down an unadorned beat that drove the band's signature hypnotic rhythm.
- ManagerAndy Warhol
He backed the band in 1966–1967, brought Nico into the fold and created the banana cover of the debut album, and after his death became the occasion that reunited Reed and Cale.
- InfluenceDavid Bowie
Bowie performed Velvet Underground songs onstage, openly declaring the band's influence, and in 1972 co-produced Reed's solo album “Transformer.”
I. Brooklyn and Wales · 1942–1964
(Formation) The band was formed in New York in 1964. Its two pillars were born in the same year but grew up in entirely different worlds. Lou Reed was born in March 1942 in Brooklyn, New York, to Sidney, an accountant, and Toby, and was raised in Freeport, a suburban town on Long Island. As a teenager Reed fell for songs sung in harmony by Black vocal groups (doo-wop) and for rock and roll, and at sixteen even released a single with a high school band, the Jades. (Treatment) At around seventeen, Reed underwent electroconvulsive therapy with parental consent. Reed later claimed it had been meant to cure homosexual tendencies; the family gave a different account. Either way, the experience left a deep distrust of family and of suburban order, and for the rest of a lifetime Reed would sing of people living outside the line that society calls normal. (Syracuse) At Syracuse University Reed found a mentor in the poet Delmore Schwartz and learned the power of short, precise sentences, and opened up to Ornette Coleman, who played jazz improvised freely without set chord progressions (free jazz). In this period Reed also got to know Sterling Morrison, a guitarist from Long Island. After graduating, Reed worked as a staff songwriter at Pickwick Records, which churned out cheap imitations of popular songs. (Wales) John Cale was born in March 1942 in Garnant, a mining village in Wales, to a miner father and a schoolteacher mother, and grew up speaking Welsh. Cale studied viola, passed through Goldsmiths College in London, and in 1963 crossed to Tanglewood in the United States on a scholarship. Settling in New York, Cale played in composer La Monte Young's group, laying down single notes sustained for hours on end (drone). This music of very few materials repeated at great length (minimalism) would later become the foundation of the band's sound.
II. Ludlow Street · 1964–1965
(Tuning) In late 1964 Pickwick hastily assembled musicians to sell “The Ostrich,” a dance song Reed had written, and Cale and Tony Conrad were called in. Reed used a strange tuning with all six strings set to the same note (an altered tuning), and Cale was startled by how closely it resembled the experiments in La Monte Young's group. In this way the rock-and-roll songwriter and the musician from experimental art that deliberately breaks established forms (the avant-garde) recognized each other. (Ludlow) The two lived together in a shabby apartment at 56 Ludlow Street on Manhattan's Lower East Side, honing songs. “Heroin” and “I'm Waiting for the Man,” which Reed brought in, depicted drugs and street life with neither praise nor condemnation, and Cale laid the scrape of an electric viola over them. In 1965 Morrison, whom Reed had run into again by chance on the subway, joined on guitar, and the drums went to Angus MacLise, a poet and percussionist who lived in the same building. (Name) After passing through names like the Warlocks and the Falling Spikes, they took as the band's name the title of a paperback on sexual mores that Conrad had found. MacLise left in late 1965, unwilling to accept a show that paid money and had to start and end at a set time. (Tucker) The empty seat was filled by Maureen Tucker, younger sister of Jim Tucker, Morrison's college friend. Raised in Levittown on Long Island, and self-taught on drums while listening devotedly to the African percussionist Olatunji, Tucker played standing up, turned the bass drum on its side and struck it with round-headed sticks (mallets), and hardly used cymbals at all. After a first paid show in December 1965 in the auditorium of Summit High School in New Jersey, the band took up a residency at the Café Bizarre in Greenwich Village. Reed handled vocals, guitar and songwriting; Cale viola·bass·keyboards; Morrison guitar and bass; Tucker drums.
A song honed since the Ludlow Street days, it is where Reed's rock and roll and Cale's drone music first locked together.
- The note that rings like grinding metal from beginning to end is Cale's electric viola. Cale restrung and amplified the viola and scraped it with a bow to lay down one long sustained note (drone) — follow whether that sound stays underneath for the whole song.
- Reed's guitar is said to have been played in the so-called Ostrich tuning, with the strings set to the same note. So even as the fingers move, the same notes pile up in a droning hum.
- Tucker's drums mark only slow, solid beats, like a funeral procession. Stripped of ornament, this beat draws the song along like a trance.
- Reed sings with almost no change in pitch, as if reading a novel aloud. The title and subject come from Leopold von Sacher-Masoch's novel of the same name.
- Compare it with the 1965 Ludlow Street demo on the 1995 box set “Peel Slowly and See,” and you can hear that the song set out as something close to a folk ballad.
III. The Factory's banana · 1965–1967
(Warhol) Among those who saw them at the Café Bizarre in late 1965 were the filmmaker Paul Morrissey and Andy Warhol. The band was reportedly fired for playing “The Black Angel's Death Song” after being warned not to play songs that drove customers away, and around that time Warhol became their manager. Warhol is said to have offered the Factory studio as rehearsal space and supplied equipment in return for a share of the earnings, and demanded that they put Nico, a German-born model and actress, onstage with them. (Nico) Born Christa Päffgen in Cologne in 1938, Nico was an actress who had appeared in Fellini's “La Dolce Vita.” Reed wrote “Femme Fatale” and “I'll Be Your Mirror” for Nico, and the two are said to have been lovers for a time. Yet Reed never came to welcome handing songs over to Nico, and this tension lingered in the band for a long time. (Shows) In the spring of 1966 Warhol staged a multimedia show called “Exploding Plastic Inevitable” at the Dom, a dance hall in the East Village. Warhol's films were projected over the band as it played, lights flashed, and the poet Gerard Malanga danced with a whip. Taking the show on a West Coast tour, the band ran head-on into the California hippie scene, with its songs of love and peace. (Banana) Recorded in a matter of days in April 1966 at Scepter Studios in Manhattan, the debut album was turned down by several labels before coming out on Verve Records in March 1967, through the efforts of producer Tom Wilson. Warhol's banana cover was a device: peel off the skin sticker and pink flesh was revealed. Radio shunned songs that calmly took up drugs, sadomasochism and urban loneliness, and the album stalled at number 171 on the Billboard album chart.
A debut album that gathers Warhol's patronage, Nico's voice and the stories of New York's streets in one place. It barely sold on release, but has become one of the most often cited debuts in rock.
- The card's video is “I'm Waiting for the Man.” Cale pounds the piano keys on the same beat without pause while the guitar and drums drive that beat forward, turning into rhythm the impatience of a person waiting for someone on the street.
- The opening track, “Sunday Morning,” was the last on the album to be recorded, in November 1966, with Tom Wilson producing. The keyboard that rings out clear as a bell in the introduction is a celesta played by Cale.
- In “Femme Fatale,” “All Tomorrow's Parties” and “I'll Be Your Mirror,” sung by Nico, listen to that low, singularly inflected voice side by side with Reed's singing.
- The closing track, “European Son,” is dedicated to Reed's mentor Delmore Schwartz. Once the early vocals end, the sound of something shattering serves as a signal, and the song collapses into noise-laced improvisation.
A song Reed had been writing since college, it renders drugs from inside one person's consciousness, neither praising nor condemning them. It was also a major reason radio shunned the debut album.
- The song shuttles between just two chords for more than 7 minutes. It begins slowly, speeds up, then slows down again, and this rise and fall in tempo stands in for a plot.
- The drone of Cale's viola, scraping sharply at a single note, grows fiercer as the song goes on, until in the accelerating passages it sounds like a scream.
- Tucker recalled stopping for a while during the recording because the other instruments were hard to hear. Listen for the passage late in the song where the drums drop out and then return.
- Reed's voice appeals to no one, flowing on like a person talking alone. Beginning quietly, as if speaking, it comes close to a shout in the accelerating passages, so that the listener seems to be inside the singer's head.
IV. White noise · 1967–1968
(Split) In 1967 Nico left for a solo career, and that same year Reed also broke with Warhol and brought in Steve Sesnick as the new manager. Reed regarded Warhol as a mentor for life, but wanted a rock band that stood on its own rather than one sheltering under an artist's patronage. (Noise) The second album, “White Light/White Heat,” recorded in September 1967 with Tom Wilson producing, carried the roar of the concert hall straight onto record. Everyone turned their amps all the way up, and the studio filled with tones deliberately torn and warped (distortion) and with speaker sound sucked back into the guitars to ring out shrilly (feedback). The more than 17-minute “Sister Ray” was recorded in a single take, and the story goes that the engineer walked out, telling them to call when it was over. Released in January 1968, the album stalled at number 199 on the chart. (Tension) Cale, pushing sonic experiment, and Reed, wanting song and story at the center, drifted steadily apart. In September 1968 Reed summoned Morrison and Tucker and said that unless Cale left, the band was finished; in the end it was Morrison who conveyed the message to Cale. Morrison, saddled with pushing out a longtime comrade, is said to have been reluctant about the decision. (Cale) After leaving the band, Cale soon became established as a producer, producing Nico's “The Marble Index” (1968) and the Stooges' debut album (1969). The person who made the Velvet Underground's roughest sounds became the bridge that passed those very sounds on to the next generation of bands.
The peak of the second album, which used the studio like a concert hall, and the final chapter of the noise experiments Reed and Cale made together.
- For more than 17 minutes a short repeated phrase of only a few chords (riff) cycles almost without pause. The members recalled agreeing not to stop no matter who made a mistake, and recording it in one take.
- The keyboard snarling in the background is Cale's Vox organ, its sound deliberately warped (distortion). From the middle onward, listen for the passages where the organ and Reed's guitar fight to drown each other out.
- With every instrument blaring in one room, each microphone picked up the others, so the sound comes across as a single mass with its edges smeared. That smearing is itself the song's texture.
- Reed lays out a scene of a debauched party in the voice of an indifferent storyteller. That emotionless delivery stands in strange contrast to the noise.
- Joy Division's recording of this song, played live, appears on their album “Still,” so you can compare it with the original.
V. The quiet room · 1968–1970
(Yule) Cale's place was filled by twenty-one-year-old Doug Yule, from the Boston band the Grass Menagerie. Yule took bass and organ and sang several songs in a clear voice. With Yule, the band's sound grew abruptly quieter. There is also a story that the third album, recorded in late 1968 at TTG Studios in Hollywood, sounds different because it was cut with new amps bought after the band's equipment was stolen at an airport. (Confession) Released in March 1969, the album “The Velvet Underground” was filled with songs that quietly confess love, guilt and faith. “Candy Says,” a portrait of the Factory actress Candy Darling, was sung by Yule, and the closing track, “After Hours,” was sung by Tucker in a shy voice. Reed personally redid the work of setting the levels and placement of the separately recorded vocals and instruments (mix), producing a version with the vocals pulled forward; this later came to be known as the closet mix. (Touring) In 1969 the band played relentlessly across Texas, California and Canada, and recordings from this period came out in 1974 as the live album “1969.” That year the relationship with MGM ended, and the newly recorded songs never became an official album, lying in the vaults for years. (Loaded) In 1970 the band signed with Cotillion, an Atlantic imprint, and was pressed for hits. Because Tucker could not take part in the recording, Yule and session players played drums, and “Sweet Jane” and “Rock & Roll” were born at this time. But in August, before the album came out, Reed left the band after the last night of a residency at Max's Kansas City in New York. Reed went back to the family home on Long Island and worked as a typist in Reed's father's accounting office.
The ballad that best represents the band in its quieter days after Cale's departure, a lonely confession to a love that can never be.
- Reed's voice is close, almost a whisper, and unfolds in the second person, as if confiding directly in someone. It is nothing like the detached storyteller of the previous album.
- With no loud drums, light percussion like a tambourine and soft keyboards carry the beat. The pared-down arrangement pushes the song's confession to the front.
- The guitar solo in the middle flows briefly in a clean, undistorted tone, almost as if singing. Heard right after the roar of "Sister Ray," it is hard to believe this is the same band.
- The label engineer's mix and Reed's own "closet mix" place the vocals and instruments at different distances. The two mixes can be compared on releases such as the 2014 expanded reissue.
- R.E.M. put this song on the B-side of their 1984 single "South Central Rain."
Their most accessible album, made under the label's demands for a hit; Reed left the band before it came out.
- The video on the card is "Sweet Jane." The opening guitar riff is a simple one that moves between a few chords, yet it became a textbook of rock guitar that countless bands would later play.
- On the album version, the slow passage (the bridge) that shifts the mood midway through was edited out, and Reed voiced his displeasure. The original form can be heard on the 1997 expanded edition "Fully Loaded."
- "Rock & Roll" tells of a suburban kid whose life is changed by rock and roll coming over the radio; Reed later said it was his own story.
- Yule and session players took the drums in place of Tucker, so the beat is neat and polished. Compare it with Tucker's standing-up drumming on the earlier albums.
VI. The ones who remained · 1970–2013
(Breakup) After Reed left, Yule took over the vocals, and Morrison returned to graduate school after a final show in Texas in 1971. Tucker soon left the band as well. "Squeeze," recorded in England in 1973 at the urging of manager Steve Sesnick, was an album on which Yule played most of the instruments, and with this record, featuring not a single original member, the band's name faded away. (Legacy) Their influence spread only afterward. David Bowie played their songs on stage, and in 1972 he produced Reed's solo album "Transformer" with Mick Ronson. Cale produced Patti Smith's "Horses" in 1975. Joy Division played or recorded "Sister Ray," R.E.M. "Pale Blue Eyes," and Nirvana "Here She Comes Now," while Sonic Youth inherited their noise and alternate tunings. In a 1982 interview, Brian Eno remarked, to the effect, that few people bought the first album, but every one of them started a band. (Reunion) When Warhol died in 1987, Reed and Cale joined forces again after some twenty years to make "Songs for Drella" (1990), an album in his memory. In 1993 the four original members reunited to tour Europe, and at several shows they opened for U2's Zoo TV Tour. The Paris Olympia concert survives as a live album, but plans for an American tour fell through as Reed and Cale drifted apart once more. (Farewell) In August 1995, Morrison died of lymphoma. When the band was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame the following year, Patti Smith gave the induction speech, and Reed, Cale and Tucker played together a new song written for Morrison. Reed died of liver disease in October 2013.
Lesser-known stories
After leaving the band, Sterling Morrison studied medieval English literature at the University of Texas at Austin and earned his doctorate in 1986. Alongside teaching, he also worked as a tugboat captain in the Port of Houston. Overshadowed by the story of Reed and Cale, this history has remained a footnote in biographies, but the guitarist who took the stage at the 1993 reunion was both a scholar and a sailor. Just as the debut album was beginning to sell, Eric Emerson, a figure from the Factory circle, objected that his image had appeared without permission in a concert photo on the back cover. The label recalled the album and reprinted it with that portion covered or removed, and in the meantime its sales momentum was lost. Though rarely mentioned in the shadow of the banana-cover myth, researchers such as Richie Unterberger, working from day-by-day records, point to this incident as one cause of the album's poor performance. David Bowie recalled that around 1971 he saw the Velvet Underground play in New York, went backstage and talked at length with the man he took to be Reed, only to learn later that it had been Doug Yule. So scarce are the records of this period that even devoted fans did not know the band had carried on under the same name after Reed left. In September 1963, Cale was one of the pianists in John Cage's eighteen-hour continuous performance of Erik Satie's "Vexations" in New York, and that same year he appeared on the TV program "I've Got a Secret" to describe the experience. It is a primary record showing that, before he ever joined a rock band, he was already at the heart of New York's experimental music.
Glossary notes 📚🔎
Drone
(Meaning) The English word drone originally means a male bee, and the low buzzing sound it makes. The name holds the quality of sounding on and on without a break. (In rock) A sound in which one note or a few notes are held long and laid continuously beneath a song. Even as the voice and other instruments move above it, the drone stays in place. Picture choir practice, when one group holds a single note—mmm— while another group sings the song. In the Velvet Underground, John Cale's electric viola played this role. (Elsewhere) Today the word drone usually means an unmanned aircraft flown by remote control, and that name, too, comes from the buzzing it makes in flight.
Minimalism
(Meaning) The English word minimal means least or smallest. The idea of reducing materials to a minimum is built into the name. (In rock) Music that repeats very little material — a single note, a short melody, two or three chords — for a long time, inviting the listener to hear the small changes within it. It was led in 1960s New York by composers such as La Monte Young, and it flowed into the Velvet Underground through John Cale, who played in his group. It is like a jump-rope chant: keep repeating the same rhythm, and at some point the repetition itself settles into your body. (Elsewhere) In everyday life it refers to a way of living that keeps only what is truly needed, or to design stripped of ornament.
Alternate tuning
(In rock) A guitar's six strings are normally tuned to set, different notes (standard tuning); tuning them differently on purpose is called alternate tuning. Lou Reed tuned all six strings to the same note, so that wherever he pressed, the same notes stacked up into a droning hum; after one of his songs, this is also called Ostrich tuning. It is like retuning every bar of a xylophone to the same note, so that striking anywhere makes the same sound ring out in layers. Bands such as Sonic Youth later explored the technique more deeply.
Avant-garde
(Meaning) The French avant-garde originally meant, in the military, a unit that moves ahead of the main force — the vanguard (前衛). The sense of people who set foot on unfamiliar ground before anyone else was carried over into art. (In rock) Art that deliberately breaks familiar forms and rules to try out new sounds and methods. Through John Cale, who came from experimental music, and Andy Warhol of Pop Art, the Velvet Underground brought such experiments into rock and roll. If, when everyone presents a project the same way, one friend presents it alone as a play or through sound, that friend is the class's avant-garde. (Elsewhere) In fashion it is commonly used for experimental, distinctive designs that break the mold of ordinary clothing.
Distortion
(Meaning) The English word distortion comes from distort, meaning to twist or warp. It means warping the shape of a sound. (In rock) A tone made by boosting a guitar or organ signal excessively through an amplifier or device until the sound turns rough and torn. It sounds thicker and more aggressive than a clean tone. Think of a phone speaker playing music at full volume, the sound crackling and breaking apart — distortion is that same thing, shaped deliberately into something useful. (Elsewhere) In photographs or maps, shapes that appear bent away from reality because of a lens or a projection are also called distortion (warping).
Feedback
(Meaning) The English feed back means to feed something back in. The principle of a sound going out and coming back in to be fed again is right there in the name. (In rock) A phenomenon in which sound from a speaker re-enters a guitar's sound-catching device (the pickup) or a microphone, circling around and growing louder until it rings out shrilly. Originally regarded as an accident, it was treated deliberately as an instrument by rock players in the 1960s. When someone in a school auditorium brings a microphone close to a speaker and an ear-splitting eee— rings out, that is feedback. (Elsewhere) In everyday life, feedback means giving evaluation and advice back to someone about their work or opinions.
Mix
(In rock) The studio process of blending separately recorded voices and instruments into one, setting each one's volume, left·right position and reverberation. Even with the same recording, depending on the mix, the voice may step forward or hide behind the instruments. It is just like bibimbap: the ingredients may be the same, but the taste changes with how much gochujang and greens you add. The Velvet Underground's third album survives in two versions, the engineer's mix and the "closet mix" Lou Reed made himself.