The Carpenters
The voice that sounded closest from the very lowest notes, and the harmonies her brother built up for that one voice alone.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
The people around them ⏳🌊
- FamilyAgnes Carpenter
The siblings' mother, she led the family's move for the sake of Richard's musical career, and biographers record that Karen long craved her approval.
- PatronageHerb Alpert
Co-founder of A&M Records and a trumpeter, he was drawn to Karen's voice on a demo tape, signed the duo, and handed them “Close to You.”
- InfluenceBurt Bacharach
The composer who wrote “Close to You” with Hal David, his sophisticated harmonies and arrangements became a major model for Richard's musical sensibility.
- ColleagueJohn Bettis
A lyricist who had been with them since the Spectrum days, he wrote a number of songs with Richard, including "Goodbye to Love."
- ColleaguePaul Williams
A songwriter who, with Roger Nichols, wrote "We've Only Just Begun" and "Rainy Days and Mondays," shaping the duo's early mood.
- ColleaguePhil Ramone
A producer known for Billy Joel's records, he worked with Karen on her solo album in New York in 1979–80.
I. The siblings of Downey · 1946–1968
(Formation) In April 1969, a brother and sister raised in Downey, California, signed with A&M Records and became the duo Carpenters. Yet the story of Richard, the older brother, and Karen, his younger sister, began far to the east, in New Haven, Connecticut. (New Haven) Richard was born in New Haven in October 1946, Karen in March 1950. Their father, Harold, worked in the printing trade and was an avid record collector. Richard grew up amid his father's stacks of records, listening to swing bands and to the multitrack recordings of Les Paul and Mary Ford, and he took to the piano early. Karen was an ordinary girl who tagged along after her brother and loved baseball. (The move) In 1963 the family moved to Downey, southeast of Los Angeles, reportedly in large part for the sake of Richard's musical prospects. It was a decision that placed the weight of the household behind the son's talent. Their mother, Agnes, tended Richard's path more zealously than anyone, and biographers would later record that Karen long craved her mother's approval. (Drums) Karen is said to have joined the band at Downey High School to get out of gym class. The first instrument she was handed was the glockenspiel, but she soon switched to drums, and within a few months she had improved enough to astonish her brother. (The trio) In 1965 Richard formed a jazz trio with Karen and his friend Wes Jacobs, who played tuba and bass. The following year they won a battle of the bands at the Hollywood Bowl and signed with RCA, but no record was ever released. Around the same time, Karen recorded her first solo single in session bassist Joe Osborn's garage studio. In 1967 they played in a band called Spectrum with the lyricist John Bettis, among others.
II. The doors of A&M · 1969–1970
(The demo) The siblings took the demo tape they had made in Osborn's garage and knocked on the doors of one label after another. The tape eventually reached Herb Alpert, the trumpeter and co-founder of A&M Records, and Alpert, drawn above all to Karen's voice, decided to sign them. That was in April 1969. (Offering) Their debut album, Offering, released that fall, passed by quietly. The most it managed was a single that turned the Beatles' "Ticket to Ride" into a slow ballad and lingered briefly in the middle of the charts. Still, Alpert did not cast them aside. (Bacharach) Alpert handed Richard the sheet music for "Close to You," written by Burt Bacharach and Hal David. Several singers had already recorded it without success. Richard reworked its tempo and texture and layered Karen's voice with his own, many times over. In the summer of 1970 the song reached No. 1 on the Billboard singles chart and held the spot for four weeks. (The bank commercial) That same year, Richard's ears pricked up while he was watching a bank's wedding-themed commercial on television. The jingle had been written by Paul Williams and Roger Nichols. Richard tracked down whether a full version of the song existed, and the result, "We've Only Just Begun," climbed to No. 2 and became a fixture at American weddings. (Behind the drums) On stage, Karen at first sang from behind her drum kit. Audiences could barely see the singer, and many of the drum parts on the records were played by session musicians such as Hal Blaine. Karen, who thought of herself as a drummer, gradually had to step out front to the microphone, a change she is said to have regretted for a long time.
Their first No. 1, the song that changed the duo's fate after Richard reworked the sheet music Herb Alpert had handed him. A song that several singers had passed over finally found its place when it met Karen's voice.
- Karen begins the first line in a range low for a woman (alto), almost in a whisper. Her breath, pressed close to the microphone, makes it sound as though she is singing right beside the listener.
- A piano accompaniment that rolls each beat into three (triplets) sets the unhurried gait of the whole song. It is known to be the result of Richard tidying the tempo and texture of the original.
- The short trumpet interlude in the middle (flugelhorn) recalls the soft brass color characteristic of the A&M that Alpert led.
- At the end, a wordless harmony of the siblings' voices, overdubbed dozens of times (overdubbing), slowly fades away. This choir-like wall the two built became the signature of the Carpenters sound.
A short jingle from a bank commercial caught in Richard's ear and was completed as a proper song. Capturing the first steps of a newly married couple, it cemented the siblings' wholesome image.
- In the opening, Karen's voice lies low and level, then brightens little by little toward the chorus. A manner of quiet resolve, rather than open emotion, gives the song its feeling.
- In the chorus the layered background harmonies suddenly spread wide, an effect Richard created by overlaying the two voices again and again.
- Woodwinds and soft strings carry color rather than rhythm, laying down a warm air like that of a wedding hall.
- The songs of Paul Williams and Roger Nichols, who wrote it, became most widely known through Carpenters' recordings.
III. The peak · 1971–1973
(The Grammys) In 1971 Carpenters won both Best New Artist and the award for vocal performance by a duo or group at the Grammys. That summer they even hosted a television variety show bearing their name. Just two years after their debut, theirs had become the busiest name around. (The workshop) The work was done entirely by the siblings' own hands. Richard chose the songs, arranged them, and directed the recordings, while Karen sang mostly in her low range, close enough that even her breathing could be heard. The two overdubbed the same harmonies countless times to build a choir-like backdrop. Karen is said to have often delivered a fine vocal from the very first take. (The writers) They had a gift for making other people's songs their own. Leon Russell's "Superstar" and Williams and Nichols's "Rainy Days and Mondays" were hits in quick succession, and the 1972 album A Song for You included "It's Going to Take Some Time," reportedly written by Carole King with Toni Stern. At the same time, Richard teamed up with John Bettis to put out originals such as "Goodbye to Love." (The White House) In May 1973 the siblings performed at the White House for President Richard Nixon. Nixon praised them as the very best of young America. Yet that wholesome image also made them a target of ridicule as square among critics, in whom the spirit of the counterculture still lingered. (Weight) That same year, a trade paper's concert review made a careless remark about Karen's figure, and biographers record that it was around this time that she began strict dieting. In the year her songs climbed highest, the shadow of what was to come also began to fall.
Richard happened to hear Leon Russell's song on television and chose it. Of all their recordings, it shows most vividly, in their peak year, their knack for making someone else's song their own.
- Karen's vocal is known to be the practice take she sang to find her way before the real recording (guide vocal), used as it was. That unpolished first feeling only heightened the song's resigned loneliness.
- The opening begins with a sound like a slender woodwind melody, and throughout the first verse the accompaniment pulls back to a minimum, leaving only the voice.
- When the chorus arrives, brass and strings swell all at once. The contrast between hushed verse and bursting chorus forms the song's architecture.
- Telling the story of a woman waiting for a musician who has left her in a far more restrained voice than the original, it turned the original's abandon into a song of solitude.
Written by Richard with John Bettis, it was inspired by a fictional song whose title is only mentioned in an old film. It was an experiment in which the most wholesome of duos brought in the roughest of guitar sounds.
- The guitar solo that tears through the latter part of the song was played through a device that deliberately distorts the sound (fuzz). Session guitarist Tony Peluso played it; Richard is said to have written the opening melody and left the rest to improvisation.
- Setting a fuzz guitar solo on a ballad was a rare combination at the time. Richard recalled receiving letters from fans accusing them of selling out because of this song.
- Karen sings low and calm from beginning to end. The more composed the voice of the narrator giving up on love, the more the guitar behind her weeps in her place.
- At the end, the siblings' layered humming harmonies and the guitar fade out together (bringing the sound down gradually to a close), vanishing slowly.
A song that longs for a childhood spent listening to oldies on the radio, it is steeped in the memories of Richard, who grew up among his father's piles of records. On the album “Now & Then,” it flowed into a medley of old hits.
- After an introduction that opens on piano chords, Karen sings the first verse in a very low register. Her voice is subdued, like someone reminiscing aloud to herself.
- By the chorus, the siblings' layered background harmonies grow steadily thicker, and the longing sways between joy and sorrow.
- The song itself was built with simple harmonies and a clear-cut chorus, consciously modeled on the structure of early 1960s pop. Richard's reverence for the music of that era is written into the song's very form.
- On the album, the song leads into a medley of 1960s hits, linked by patter imitating a real radio DJ. It has long been cherished as the Carpenters' signature song, especially in Japan and Korea.
IV. Cracks · 1974–1977
(Touring) The price of the peak was an endless schedule. Year after year the siblings crisscrossed the United States, Japan and Europe, playing close to several hundred shows, and on days without a stage they were in the studio. The 1974 Japan tour was especially rapturous, and Japan remained ever after one of the countries that loved the Carpenters the longest. (Decline) In the fall of 1975, Karen's weight dropped to just over 40 kilograms. Tours of Britain and Japan were canceled, and Karen went on rest. At the time the name anorexia nervosa was unfamiliar to the public, and neither her family nor those around her knew exactly what it was. (Horizon) The album “Horizon,” released the same year, was praised for the precision of its recording, but its singles no longer charted as they once had. When the Marvelettes' old song “Please Mr. Postman” reached No. 1, it turned out to be their last No. 1. (Change) As disco and punk shook up the charts, the Carpenters' place narrowed. After “A Kind of Hush” in 1976, Richard tried to change direction on 1977's “Passage,” including a spacey Klaatu song and a number from the musical “Evita.” The results were mixed. (Independence) Around this time Karen left her parents' house and moved into an apartment in Century City, Los Angeles. At twenty-six, it was the first home she had ever had of her own. Karen collected Mickey Mouse memorabilia and loved having friends over for dinner. “I Need to Be in Love” is the song Karen said, in those years, was her favorite of all her own recordings.
From the years when their popularity was slipping and her body was wasting away, this is the song Karen called her favorite of all her own recordings. Richard and Bettis wrote it together with Albert Hammond.
- It is a song in which a narrator worn out from chasing perfection confesses a wish to find love. Karen's careful, confessional voice seems to echo her own circumstances at the time.
- Rather than surging up into the high notes, Karen traces the rise and fall of emotion through subtle shifts of tone within her low-to-middle range.
- Strings and a soft electric piano fill in the background without pushing the rhythm forward. It showcases the sleek production of 1970s adult pop.
- Richard handled the production and arrangement himself. A brief layered harmony in the final chorus quietly closes the song.
V. A voice standing alone · 1978–1981
(Christmas) In 1978 the siblings released “Christmas Portrait.” An album of carols marshaling orchestra and choir, it has outlived its chart showing as a record people take out again every winter. (Hiatus) As Richard himself later revealed in interviews, he struggled with a dependence on sleeping pills and entered treatment in early 1979, and the duo's work came to a temporary halt. For the first time, the two had time to themselves. (New York) Karen used the break to go to New York and make her first solo album. The producer was Phil Ramone, who had been making Billy Joel's records, and members of Joel's band are known to have played on the sessions. Rod Temperton, who would go on to write Michael Jackson's “Thriller,” also contributed songs. Outside her brother's arrangements, Karen sang rhythm and blues and adult pop in a higher, breathier voice. (Shelved) After hearing the finished album in 1980, A&M shelved its release. Those close to Karen say she was deeply crushed. The record finally came out in 1996, 13 years after her death, under the title “Karen Carpenter.” (Marriage) In August 1980 Karen married real estate developer Tom Burris in Beverly Hills. (Return) In 1981 the siblings joined forces again and released “Made in America.” “Touch Me When We're Dancing” was well loved on adult contemporary radio, but Karen had once again grown visibly thin.
Written by Rod Temperton, this song is from the solo album Karen made with Phil Ramone in New York in 1980. A version reworked by Richard first appeared on the 1989 Carpenters album “Lovelines,” while the original recording saw the light of day on the 1996 solo album, after Karen's death.
- She sings in a noticeably higher range than in her Carpenters days, in a soft, very breathy tone. Here you can hear the other voice Karen was searching for outside her brother's arrangements.
- The rhythm (groove) laid down by a lightly bouncing electric piano and bass comes to the fore. It is a passage steeped in Temperton's signature rhythm-and-blues sensibility.
- Instead of the Carpenters' method of stacking harmonies layer upon layer, what stands out is Ramone's recording approach, which sets a single lead vocal out in open space.
- Its mood is an invitation to revive a relationship between lovers, and you can sense Karen's intent to make it sound like the voice of a grown woman.
VI. The last song · 1982–1983
(Treatment) In 1982 Karen acknowledged her illness and went to New York, where she was treated by psychotherapist Steven Levenkron for nearly a year. She regained a little weight, and when she returned to Los Angeles at year's end, Karen talked of plans to work again. (Now) In April of that year, during a brief return home from treatment, she recorded “Now.” It was the last recording of Karen's life. Karen reportedly intended to sing it again later, but the chance never came. (Farewell) On February 4, 1983, Karen collapsed at her parents' home in Downey and died at thirty-two. The autopsy found the cause of death to be heart failure brought on by anorexia, and recorded that long-term use of a drug to induce vomiting had damaged her heart. Dionne Warwick, Olivia Newton-John and Petula Clark were among those at the funeral. (Awakening) That one of America's most famous voices had been lost to an eating disorder brought the illness into public discussion. The family established a foundation in Karen's name to support eating disorder research. That same year “Voice of the Heart,” a collection of her remaining recordings, was released. (Afterward) Richard married in 1984 and started a family; in 1987 he released the solo album “Time,” while devoting long years to refining and reissuing the Carpenters' recordings. In 1994 young alternative rock musicians released the tribute album “If I Were a Carpenter,” and the siblings' music, once called corny, was reappraised as a model of sophisticated pop. Richard still guards that legacy today.
Recorded in April 1982 during a brief return home while she was in treatment in New York, this was the last recording of Karen's life. After she was gone, it appeared on the album “Voice of the Heart.”
- Karen reportedly regarded this recording as provisional and intended to sing it again later. That is why what remains is a plainer, almost raw voice.
- The center of her voice still lies in the low register, but there are passages where her breath sounds a little short. That faint tremor only draws the song closer.
- Richard is known to have polished this recording after Karen's death and included it on the album. Striking is the arrangement, which holds back the layered harmonies and leaves space so a single voice comes through clearly.
- A song of confession to the person by one's side in this very moment, its meaning weighs newly heavy when you listen knowing it was her last recording.
Lesser-known stories
The public remembers Karen as a singer, but she thought of herself first as a drummer. On early stages she sang while playing the drums, and biographies tell of her placing near the top of a magazine readers' poll in the mid-1970s, ahead of famous rock drummers. But session players handled the drums on many of the hits, and as she was increasingly called out to the front of the stage in concert, this side of her was eclipsed by her singing. Karen's first record came out before the Carpenters'. Around 1966, at sixteen, she released a solo single on a small label started by session bassist Joe Osborn, but it barely sold, as the label soon folded. Osborn's garage studio later became the place where the siblings made their demos, and Osborn went on to play bass on Carpenters records. It was the real stage of their beginnings, hidden behind the glamorous story of the record deal. Richard first made a name for himself not in pop but in jazz. The Richard Carpenter Trio, which won a 1966 Hollywood Bowl competition, had an unusual lineup that used a tuba as its bass. Critics believe that the jazz harmonic sense hidden behind the Carpenters' sleek pop was honed in those years. Karen's solo album, not released until 1996, long circulated only as rumor among fans. After the decision to shelve it, the recordings were buried in the vaults, and until its release only a few tracks were scattered across other records. Because the album came out so late, Karen's attempt to become a different singer outside her brother's shadow remains less known even today.
Glossary notes 📚🔎
Overdubbing
(Word origin) A combination of the English over (on top of) and dub (to add sound), meaning to lay new sound on top of sound already recorded. (In pop) A method of recording additional sounds layer by layer while listening to a performance or vocal recorded earlier. The Carpenters overdubbed the voices of just two people, Karen and Richard, dozens of times to create harmonies that sounded like a large choir singing. It is like art class, when stacking several sheets of transparent colored paper makes the color deeper and richer than a single sheet. (Elsewhere) In film, it often refers to dubbing, rerecording the dialogue of a foreign film in Korean voices.
Alto
(Word origin) From the Italian alto, meaning 'high.' The name comes from the part sung above the men's voices in old choirs, so today, paradoxically, it has come to mean the lower range of women's voices. (In pop) A female singer's voice that sings comfortably in the low range. Karen could hit high notes, but she produced her warmest, most intimate sound in the low register, and Richard set the keys of songs to make the most of that range. In a school choir, when the sopranos sing the melody, the part supporting the harmony beneath them is the alto.
Fuzz
(Word origin) The English fuzz means something fluffy and raised, like lint or down. The name captures the feeling of sound swelling up roughly. (In pop) A device that deliberately distorts the sound of an electric guitar to make it sizzling and thick, or the sound itself. It was used mainly in rock music, and the Carpenters surprised many people by putting it into a quiet ballad, “Goodbye to Love.” If you turn a speaker's volume up too high, the sound cracks as if tearing, and you can think of fuzz as that cracking refined for musical use.
Guide vocal
(In pop) A provisional vocal sung in advance before the real recording, so the players can follow the flow of the song. Normally it is erased later and sung again. But Karen's “Superstar” is known to have gone onto the record as is, because this provisional vocal was so good. It is like warming up with a ball before the game in gym class, and that warm-up shot turning out to be your best one. (Elsewhere) In everyday life, a guide is a person who shows you around a travel destination.
Cover
(In pop) Newly recording and singing a song that another artist released first. The Carpenters often sang songs by the Beatles, Burt Bacharach, Leon Russell, Carole King and others in their own way, making them more famous than the originals. It is like following a friend's recipe but changing the seasoning to suit your own taste, creating a new flavor. (Elsewhere) In books it means the cover, and in sports it means defense that fills in for a teammate's empty spot.
Medley
(Word origin) The English medley means a mixture of various things, and comes from an Old French word meaning 'to mix.' (In pop) Playing several songs strung together without a break, as if they were one song. On the album “Now & Then,” the Carpenters followed “Yesterday Once More” with 1960s hits linked together like a radio broadcast. A talent-show act that picks out just the choruses of several songs and sings them back to back without stopping is exactly a medley.
Fade-out
(Word origin) A combination of the English fade (to grow faint) and out (outward), meaning to grow gradually fainter and disappear. (In pop) A way of ending a song not by cutting it off abruptly but by lowering the sound little by little so it fades away naturally. It leaves a lingering sense that the song hasn't ended but carries on into the distance. It is like your friends' voices on the playground growing quieter and quieter as you walk away. (Elsewhere) In film and video, it refers to a scene ending as the screen slowly goes dark.