novareads.musicPop

Donny Hathaway

1945–1979

A singer and arranger who held a church's piano and a university's harmony in a single voice.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. RootsBorn in Chicago, IllinoisGrandmother's gospelRaised in St. Louis2. HowardMusic scholarshipMeeting Roberta FlackLeroy Hutson3. ChicagoCurtom arrangerPicked by King Curtis“This Christmas”4. Peak“A Song for You”Grammy for duet1972 live album5. ShadowSchizophrenia diagnosisA song of freedomLong silence6. Final years1978 reunion hitDeath at thirty-threeLegacy through Alicia KeysHathaway1945–1979A thirty-three-year life that deepened soul wi…
Stages of the journey 🧭🗺️
NUnited States of AmericaChicago1945St. Louis1945–1963Washington, D.C.1963–1967Chicago1967–1979

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

The people beside him ⏳🌊

  • FamilyMartha Pitts

    The grandmother who raised him and a gospel singer, she set her three-year-old grandson on the church stage.

  • FriendshipLeroy Hutson

    His roommate at Howard University and a lifelong musical companion, with whom he co-wrote “The Ghetto.”

  • PatronCurtis Mayfield

    At his own label, Curtom, he entrusted him with arranging and producing, giving him a foothold in the industry.

  • PatronKing Curtis

    A saxophonist and producer who heard him play and brought about his contract with Atco.

  • ColleagueRoberta Flack

    An older schoolmate he had known since Howard, she was his duet partner on “Where Is the Love” and “The Closer I Get to You.”

  • ColleagueArif Mardin

    An Atlantic producer, he made the duet album and “Extension of a Man” with him.

Play all 2 on YouTube ↗

I. The boy from St. Louis · 1945–1963

(Birth) He was born on October 1, 1945, in Chicago, Illinois. His name was Donny Edward Hathaway. His mother was Drusella Huntley; of his father almost nothing is known. While still very young he moved to St. Louis, Missouri, where he was raised by his grandmother, Martha Pitts. Few records describe in any detail the time he spent with his mother or the relationship between them. (Grandmother) Martha Pitts was a professional gospel singer. From around the age of three, her grandson followed her onto the stages of churches and revival meetings, billed under her surname as “Donny Pitts, the nation's youngest gospel singer.” It was during these years that he learned the piano. The harmonies of hymns, the call and response in which the congregation answers the leader, and a way of singing that stretches and bends a melody as feeling swells settled into his body before language did. The church harmonies and improvisation heard throughout his later recordings have their roots in this period. (Neighborhood) The family lived in Carr Square Village, a public housing project in St. Louis. They were not well off. In a city where blues, jazz and gospel ran together, he grew up hearing the music outside the church as well. The ghetto scenes he would later sing about were not imagined; they were memories of the neighborhood where he grew up. (Schooling) He attended Vashon High School, where he kept up his piano and music studies, and graduated in 1963. That achievement earned him an arts scholarship to Howard University in Washington, D.C. The music he had learned by ear and by hand in church, he would now learn again through scores and theory.

II. The Howard years · 1963–1967

(Howard) Howard University had long nurtured Black American intellectuals and artists. There he studied music theory, composition and piano. Discovering that textbook harmony and the chords he had absorbed in church explained each other was the experience that defined his music. He is said to have been a student who read scores quickly and could reharmonize someone else's song on the spot. (Friendship) His dormitory roommate, Leroy Hutson, became a lifelong musical companion. The two wrote songs and sang together, and later cowrote his first single, “The Ghetto.” Hutson would go on to succeed Curtis Mayfield as lead vocalist of The Impressions. Hathaway also played keyboards in drummer Ric Powell's trio on the Washington club scene. Powell later coproduced his first album. (Connection) During this period he came to know Roberta Flack, an older musician who had also come out of Howard. Flack was teaching music in Washington schools and singing in clubs at night. Having both studied classical music at the same school, the two approached music in a similar spirit, and a few years later that friendship grew into one of the most celebrated duos in American soul. (Marriage) At Howard he met Eulaulah Vann, a fellow music student, and they married in 1967. They had two daughters; the elder, Lalah Hathaway, later became a Grammy-winning singer. (Leaving school) In 1967 he left before finishing his degree. Offers from the record industry to work as an arranger and keyboardist had arrived before graduation could. He took his family to Chicago, the city where he had been born.

III. The Chicago arranger · 1967–1970

(Curtom) In Chicago he joined Curtom, the label Curtis Mayfield had founded. Handling arranging, keyboards and production, he wrote the harmonies and led the band on recordings by singers in Mayfield's circle. Mayfield was a writer who sang head-on about Black community pride and social issues. At his side, Hathaway learned up close how a song can speak to its times. In 1969 he released a duet with the singer June Conquest, “I Thank You Baby,” on Curtom. (Sessions) By then he was a session player and arranger moving among Chicago's recording studios. Finishing other people's records was how he made a living, but it was also a time of learning with his own hands how strings, brass and rhythm section must be layered for the sound to come alive. This is why, on his albums, the arrangements matter as much as the singing. (Discovery) In 1969 King Curtis, a saxophonist and Atlantic Records producer, heard him play at a music industry event. Through Curtis he signed with Atco, an Atlantic subsidiary. It was a chance for a man who had stood behind other people's records to put out one under his own name. (Debut) His first single, “The Ghetto,” came out that same year, followed in 1970 by his first album, “Everything Is Everything.” Made with Ric Powell, the album sang of the neighborhood he grew up in and of pride in being Black. His cover of Nina Simone's “To Be Young, Gifted and Black” belonged to the same current. Gospel fervor, jazz harmony and street rhythm lived side by side on a single album. (Christmas) In the winter of 1970 he released “This Christmas,” written with Nadine McKinnor, as a single. It was a Christmas song written not as a church hymn but in the grammar of soul.

♪The Ghetto1969Live by Donny Hathaway · 1970

Written with Leroy Hutson, his first single paints the neighborhood where he grew up in rhythm rather than words. The arranging instincts he honed in his Chicago session days come through intact.

  • A bass riff repeating the same figure in the low register and an electric piano form the backbone of the track, while percussion such as congas rolls on above them without pause.
  • The playing runs far longer than the singing. The voice recedes to short shouts and the refrain, and the rest is filled by keyboard improvisation and repeating rhythm.
  • The pattern never changes, yet it never grows dull, because instruments enter and drop out one by one to adjust the density. This is where the arranger's hand shows most clearly.
  • The version on 1972's “Live” stretches to nearly 12 minutes, and the audience joins the rhythm with clapping and shouts until the hall sounds like a single percussion instrument.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪This Christmas1970Official MV — Donny Hathaway·Lalah Hathaway

A Christmas song written with Nadine McKinnor, it passed quietly at first, but over the years it became his most widely sung song.

  • In the opening, the brass (the horn section) throws open the giddy holiday mood at once with a short fanfare.
  • The rhythm is closer to soul than to a carol. Drums that strike the second·fourth beats hard (the backbeat) and a thick, moving bass make it a Christmas song you can dance to.
  • The voice never hurries, leaning slightly behind the beat, and that ease sounds like a warm room on a winter night.
  • At the end, repeating the same phrase, he piles up improvised lines (ad-libs), lifting the mood like a church's closing hymn.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. Two voices · 1971–1972

(Second album) In 1971 his second album, “Donny Hathaway,” opened with Van McCoy's “Giving Up,” followed by Leon Russell's “A Song for You.” Most of the songs were by others, but he rebuilt the tempo and harmony of each, and his singing grew slower and deeper than the originals. With this album he made his name as an interpreter before he did as a songwriter. (Duets) That same year Atlantic's Jerry Wexler and Arif Mardin put him in a studio with Roberta Flack, whom he had known since Howard. Their first single was Carole King's “You've Got a Friend.” Released in 1971, the duet reached No. 29 on the Billboard Hot 100. “Where Is the Love,” from the 1972 album “Roberta Flack & Donny Hathaway,” climbed to No. 5 on the Hot 100 and the following year won the Grammy in the duo·group pop vocal category. (Loss) Meanwhile, in August 1971, King Curtis, who had discovered him, was stabbed to death after a quarrel outside his home in New York. Hathaway had lost the patron who opened the door to his career. (Live) Released in 1972, “Live” captured performances at the Troubadour in Los Angeles and the Bitter End in New York. He sang Marvin Gaye's “What's Going On,” John Lennon's “Jealous Guy” and, once again, Carole King's “You've Got a Friend.” On that last song the audience sings along from the very first line, preserving a scene in which he leads the crowd like a church congregation. Willie Weeks on bass, Phil Upchurch and Cornell Dupree on guitar, and drummer Fred White, who would later join Earth, Wind & Fire, the band led by his brother Maurice White, held up the stage. The album is regarded as a model of the live soul record. (Film) That same year he scored the film “Come Back, Charleston Blue.” It was a period when the work of singer, arranger and composer all came at once.

♪A Song for You1971

He placed Leon Russell's song at the head of his second album and made it entirely his own. It is the recording that best shows him as an interpreter.

  • Before the singing begins, a solo piano passage runs on at some length. Jazzy chords mingle with classical ornaments, and the Howard-trained player shows his face first.
  • He slowed the tempo from the original and made the harmony more complex. That is why the same melody sounds like a far deeper confession.
  • The first line begins so low and quiet you can hear his breath, and as the song goes on the voice climbs into the high register and breaks out raw.
  • At the climax comes a singing technique that winds a single syllable through many notes (melisma), used not for display but to carry the weight of feeling.
  • Strings support him very carefully from behind, so the intimacy, as if only piano and voice were in the room, is never broken.
♪Where Is the Love1972

A duet with Roberta Flack, whom he had known since Howard, it reached No. 5 on the Hot 100 and won a Grammy. It was the song in which their two voices first met at the height of popular success.

  • The two trade lines back and forth before merging into one on the chorus. It is worth following the moment the conversation turns into a duet.
  • Flack's clear, restrained voice and Hathaway's warm, slightly rough one form a contrast, yet their timbres never push each other away.
  • Light Latin-style percussion and soft strings run underneath, so although it is a song asking the questions of a parting, it never sinks into heaviness.
  • A short track, just under 3 minutes. An arrangement that ends without a wasted note leaves, if anything, a longer afterglow.
♪What's Going On1972

The opening track of the album 「Live」, in which he reworked Marvin Gaye's socially conscious soul through his own keyboards and voice.

  • In place of the original's saxophone, it opens on the chords of an electric piano. From the very start, the same song comes through in a different color.
  • The keyboard improvisation that unfolds midway blends the idioms of jazz and gospel, showing that he was as much a player as a singer.
  • The rhythm section holds the tempo firmly while rolling a short repeated figure (a riff), so the long improvisation never comes apart.
  • The audience's applause and cheers are recorded as though they were part of the song. On the same album, Willie Weeks's bass solo in 「Voices Inside」 is also worth a listen.

V. A mind coming apart · 1973–1976

(Third album) In 1973, 「Extension of a Man」 was the album in which his ambition showed most fully. Made with Arif Mardin, it opened with an orchestral overture he wrote, 「I Love the Lord; He Heard My Cry」, and moved freely among soul, jazz and classical arranging. It brought together his composition studies at Howard and his memories of the church, but its sales fell short of the albums before it. (Lyrics) The album's second track, 「Someday We'll All Be Free」, was composed by him with lyrics by Edward Howard. Howard is said to have later explained that he wrote the words with the anguish Hathaway was going through in mind. A song usually heard as a civil-rights anthem thus carries within it a wish for a friend's well-being. (Illness) Around this time he was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. Those close to him said his moods swung sharply and that he was tormented by the belief that someone wanted to harm him or steal his music. He was hospitalized several times, and there were stretches when he could not keep taking his medication. It was an era when mental illness was understood far less than it is now. (Silence) His partnership with Roberta Flack also broke off around this time. How the two drifted apart is not clearly documented. For several years after 1973 he released no new studio album. He lived with his family in Chicago, taking the stage now and then and returning to the studio, but by the mid-1970s he had all but vanished from public view. The name he had built in just a few years after his debut was fast becoming a thing of the past.

♪Someday We'll All Be Free1973

A song from the period when his illness was deepening; a friend is said to have written the lyrics with his suffering in mind. Personal consolation and communal hope overlap in a single song.

  • It begins with calm piano, like a church accompaniment, at a slow tempo, and moves forward one unhurried step at a time.
  • He wrote the strings and brass himself; they start out far away and draw closer as the song goes on, swelling it.
  • The voice moves from a soft midrange early on to a high, cracking sound toward the end. That crack sounds less like technique than like sincerity.
  • The lyrics speak in a soothing tone, and the song's power lies in a two-layered address that can be heard as spoken to one person or to an entire community.

VI. Together again · 1977–1979

(Reunion) Around 1977, Roberta Flack called him back into the studio. 「The Closer I Get to You」, written by James Mtume and Reggie Lucas, appeared on Flack's 1978 album 「Blue Lights in the Basement」 and reached No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 1 on the R&B chart. It was the highest-charting record of his career. Returning after years away, his voice sounded noticeably more subdued than in his younger days. (Recording) Buoyed by that success, the two began work on a second duet album. But his illness did not improve. People who were in the studio with him on January 13, 1979, said he seemed anxious and confused. (Death) That night he fell from the window of his 15th-floor room at the Essex House hotel in Manhattan, New York, and died. He was thirty-three. Finding no sign of a struggle in the room, the police concluded that he had taken his own life. It had been less than 6 years since he won a Grammy for 「Where Is the Love」. (Posthumous work) In 1980 came Flack's album 「Roberta Flack Featuring Donny Hathaway」, built on the recordings he left behind. It included 「Back Together Again」 and 「You Are My Heaven」, co-written by Stevie Wonder. The same year also saw 「In Performance」, a collection of unreleased live recordings. (Legacy) He left only a handful of studio albums, but those songs became a textbook for the singers who followed. In 2001, just after the 9·11 attacks, Alicia Keys sang 「Someday We'll All Be Free」 on the memorial broadcast 「America: A Tribute to Heroes」. Amy Winehouse's recording of 「A Song for You」, made during her lifetime, appeared on the posthumous album 「Lioness: Hidden Treasures」 (2011). 「This Christmas」 has become a holiday standard that rings out again every winter.

♪The Closer I Get to You1978

The song that reunited him with Flack after a long silence and reached No. 2 on the Hot 100, the highest chart position of his career. It was the last great success he enjoyed in his lifetime.

  • Soft synthesizer and electric piano spread out wide, while a slow-tempo bass quietly supports them from below. It is the smooth ballad sound of the late 1970s.
  • Flack sings first, Hathaway follows, and then the two voices merge in harmony. The song's theme of closing the distance between two people is built into its very texture.
  • His voice sounds noticeably more subdued and gentler than around his debut. The passages he sings with a relaxed touch carry, if anything, more weight.
  • At the song's end, the two trade improvised lines (ad-libs) and slowly fade away.

Lesser-known stories

He was the one who sang the theme song of 「Maude」, the sitcom that began airing on CBS in the United States in 1972. Written by the husband-and-wife team Alan·Marilyn Bergman with Dave Grusin, the gospel-tinged theme played throughout the show's run from 1972 to 1978. Fred White, one of the drummers on the 「Live」 album, was a teenager at the time; soon after, he joined his older brother Maurice White's Earth, Wind & Fire and became the drummer of the group's heyday. The link between the two names survives only in the album's personnel list and is rarely mentioned. 「This Christmas」 was not a big hit when it first came out in 1970. It became a holiday standard only after reissues, repeated radio play and covers by later singers had piled up. That he never lived to see the song's stature is often overlooked. The four-disc set 「Never My Love: The Anthology」, released in 2013, included unreleased studio recordings made in the 1970s and left in a drawer. Decades after his death, it came to light that he had kept recording even during the years when his official albums stopped.

Glossary 📚🔎

Gospel

(Meaning) The English gospel comes from Old English godspel, that is, good (gōd) news (spel), and refers to the Christian evangel (福音), the glad tidings. (In pop) It refers to the religious music that grew up in Black churches in America. A leader sings a line and the congregation answers, and as feeling swells, handclaps and shouts join in. Picture a school choir where the director sings a line first and everyone sings it back, growing louder and more excited with each round. Much of the singing style of soul and R&B came from gospel. (Elsewhere) In English, gospel truth means a fact beyond any doubt.

Soul

(Meaning) The English soul means spirit, or heart. The name carries the idea of putting your whole heart into a song. (In pop) Popular music created from the 1950s to the 70s by Black American musicians, who carried gospel's fervent singing over into stories of love, life and society. The vocal style and harmonies of the church merged with the beat of rhythm and blues. Sometimes a classmate singing at a talent show goes beyond simply singing well, and listeners come to feel even what that friend holds inside; soul is music that aims for exactly that kind of connection. (Elsewhere) Soul food refers to the traditional cooking of Black families in the American South, and a soulmate is a partner whose heart matches yours perfectly.

Arrangement

(Meaning) The word pyeongok (編曲) combines pyeon (編), 'to weave', and gok (曲), 'song', and means to weave an existing piece together anew. (In pop) It is the work of leaving the melody and lyrics as they are while deciding which instruments come in when, which harmonies to use and what the tempo should be. Depending on the arrangement, the same song can become an upbeat dance number or a quiet ballad. It is like instant ramen: one person adds egg and scallions, another adds cheese, and the same noodles taste completely different. Donny Hathaway was a superb arranger before he was a singer. (Elsewhere) It is rarely used in everyday speech, but it sometimes serves as a metaphor for adapting an existing story anew.

Session musician

(Meaning) The English session comes from Latin sessio, 'a sitting', and means a single stretch of time in which people gather to work. (In pop) A musician who is not a full member of any band but is called in whenever there is a recording, to play on other artists' records. Their names appear in small print on album sleeves, yet they often determine how a song sounds. Think of a talented friend who isn't the lead in the school play but gets called to one class's production after another to handle the lights or sound. (Elsewhere) A sitting of the National Assembly, a meeting period, and the record of a single login on a computer are also called sessions.

Melisma

(Meaning) The Greek melisma comes from a word meaning 'song' or 'tune'. (In pop) A singing technique in which one syllable of the lyric is stretched across many notes in a winding line. For example, instead of finishing the 'sa' of sarang ('love') on a single note, the singer rolls up and down through several notes like a wave. It's like calling a friend's name across the playground, drawing out the last syllable as your voice rises and falls. Born in gospel, it became a signature technique of soul and R&B singers. (Elsewhere) The same word is used in the study of medieval chant, where it refers to a melodic style in which many notes are set to a single syllable.

Riff

(In pop) A short figure repeated over and over to form the backbone of a song. It is often carried by guitar, bass or keyboards, and the repetition makes the song easy to remember. When you jump rope at a steady beat, your body falls into the rhythm on its own; a riff plays the role of that jump-rope beat within a song. The low, repeating bass in 「The Ghetto」 is a fine example.

Ad-lib

(Meaning) A shortening of the Latin ad libitum, meaning 'at one's pleasure'. (In pop) A line that a singer adds on the spot, not found in the score or the set melody. It usually comes at the end of a song or as the chorus repeats, and it is the moment when a singer's personality and skill show most clearly. When friends are singing 'Happy Birthday' and someone playfully changes the notes and stretches out the last phrase, that is a small ad-lib. (Elsewhere) In theater or broadcasting, saying something on the spot that isn't in the script is also called an ad-lib.