Donna Summer
She wore the crown of the Queen of Disco, yet to the end she wished to remain the girl who first sang in a small church in Boston.
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
The people around her ⏳🌊
- InfluenceMahalia Jackson
Hers was the gospel voice that the young singer sang along with in church as a child, longing to sound like her.
- ColleagueGiorgio Moroder
The producer she met in Munich, with whom she made “Love to Love You Baby” and “I Feel Love,” and with whom, twenty years later, she shared a Grammy for “Carry On.”
- ColleaguePete Bellotte
The English-born lyricist·producer who, with Moroder, made most of her 1970s albums.
- PatronNeil Bogart
As head of Casablanca Records he made her an American star; they parted in 1980 over a royalty lawsuit.
- FamilyBruce Sudano
Her husband, married in 1980, and a songwriting partner from Brooklyn Dreams.
- ColleagueQuincy Jones
He produced the 1982 album “Donna Summer,” then went straight on to work on Michael Jackson's “Thriller.”
I. The girl from Mission Hill · 1948–1968
(Birth) She was born in December 1948 in Boston, Massachusetts. Her birthday was December 31, and her given name was LaDonna Adrian Gaines. Her father, Andrew, made a living as a butcher, an electrician and a building custodian, and her mother, Mary, was a schoolteacher. The third of seven children, she grew up around Mission Hill, where Boston's Black working-class families lived side by side. (Church) Her singing began at Grant AME Church, where the family worshipped. Around the age of ten, when the scheduled soloist failed to appear, she stood up in her place and sang; she later recalled that, hearing her own voice, she wept, and the congregation wept with her. She remembered that moment as the first time she understood the work God had entrusted to her. The first voice she sang along with and longed to emulate was that of the gospel singer Mahalia Jackson. (Rock) In her late teens, unexpectedly, she took to the stages of Boston clubs as lead singer of the psychedelic rock band Crow. It was a time when she absorbed both the power of gospel and the raw energy of rock, and here lay the roots of how a singer later remembered only for disco would one day win a rock vocal award. (Departure) In 1968, a few weeks before graduating from high school, she left for New York. At an audition for the musical “Hair” she won a role in the Munich production, and, leaving her worried parents behind, she crossed the Atlantic. She was nineteen. That decision would keep her in Europe for seven years.
II. The Munich stage · 1968–1975
(Hair) In Munich she appeared in the German-language production of “Hair” and learned German. She went on to spend several years as an actress and singer, moving between stages in Germany and Austria, including musical productions at the Vienna Volksoper. In 1971 she released her first single under the name Donna Gaines, but it drew little response. (Marriage) In 1973 she married the Austrian actor Helmuth Sommer, and that same year gave birth to her first daughter. The marriage did not last many years, but her husband's surname remained. Somewhere in the printing of a record credit, the spelling Sommer became Summer, and she kept the altered name as her own. (Musicland) Working as a backing session singer at Musicland Studios in Munich to make ends meet, she met the Italian-born producer Giorgio Moroder and the English lyricist·producer Pete Bellotte. In 1974, from the first album the three made together, “Lady of the Night,” the track “The Hostage” became a hit in the Netherlands and a few other European countries, and her name slowly began to spread. (Whisper) In 1975 she pitched Moroder the idea of a sensual song along the lines of Jane Birkin and Serge Gainsbourg's “Je t'aime… moi non plus.” At first, it is said, she thought of it as a demo for another singer. She recalled that she dimmed the lights, lay on the floor and recorded it imagining how Marilyn Monroe would sing it. This voice, played like a role by a young mother who had learned to sing in church, would turn her whole life around.
A voice performed lying on the floor, imagining Marilyn Monroe, lifted an unknown singer from Munich to No. 2 on the American charts. The nearly 17-minute version that came to fill an entire side of the record at Neil Bogart's request is the song's true face.
- She barely uses a chest-driven voice, singing almost in a whisper in a high, half-breathy head resonance (head voice). It is a voice that deliberately hides the power honed in church in order to play a role.
- Over a bass drum stamping evenly on every beat (four-on-the-floor), a bass riff circling in the low register holds up the backbone of the groove for all 17 minutes.
- Again and again the singing stops and long instrumental stretches of only strings, guitar and percussion return. This structure, drawn out so that dancers would never have to stop, later became the model for the long club version (extended mix).
- Rather than delivering the lyrics clearly, the voice builds atmosphere out of sighs and gasps. This boldness made some broadcasters reluctant to air it.
III. The first lady of love · 1975–1978
(Bogart) Neil Bogart, head of America's Casablanca Records, is said to have played the demo at a party; when his guests kept asking to hear it again, he ordered a long version to fill an entire side of the record. Stretched to nearly 17 minutes, “Love to Love You Baby” reached No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 in early 1976. Some broadcasters, including Britain's BBC, shied away from airing it as too explicit. (Label) Her label promoted her as the first lady of love. She said she was merely playing that image like a role, but for someone raised in church, the tag weighed on her for a long time. Returning to America and settling in Los Angeles, she released an album every year, moving back and forth between Europe and America. (Future) Her 1977 “I Remember Yesterday” was a concept album that passed through the eras one by one, from the 1940s to the future, and the closing track that stood for that future was “I Feel Love.” Moroder built nearly the entire backing on a Moog synthesizer, and the song went to No. 1 on the British chart. The story that Brian Eno told David Bowie in Berlin that this song would change the sound of club music for years to come survives through Bowie's own recollection. That same year she also released “Once Upon a Time,” a double album that retold the Cinderella story as disco. (Last dance) In 1978 she appeared as a singer in the film “Thank God It's Friday.” Paul Jabara's “Last Dance” won the Academy Award for Best Original Song the following year, and with it she won the Grammy for Best Female R&B Vocal Performance. That same year her cover of Jimmy Webb's “MacArthur Park” became her first No. 1 on the Hot 100.
It was the closing track of a concept album that crossed the eras, the one that stood for the future. A recording whose backing was made almost entirely by machines, it is regarded as the starting point of electronic dance music.
- The heart of the song is a bassline in which a Moog synthesizer repeats the same figure like a machine. A short echo (delay) on the sound fills the gaps between the notes, creating a tight, galloping pulse.
- Though almost all the backing was made on synthesizers, the story goes that the bass drum pounding underneath was the one sound actually played, by the drummer Keith Forsey.
- The vocal floats lightly in the high register, stacked in several layers. A human voice laid dreamlike over cold machine sound creates a mood closer to ecstasy than to sensuality.
- Instead of the traditional verse-chorus build, it piles up tension by gradually opening and closing the timbre of the sound and adding new layers. That is why it never grows dull, even though the song never takes a dramatic turn.
The theme of a film in which she appeared as a singer, it brought her both the Academy Award for Best Original Song and her first Grammy. It became a byword for the last song played before disco-era clubs closed their doors.
- For nearly the first 2 minutes it is a slow ballad supported by piano and strings. The heart of the song is the moment when, after she has sung low and soft, the tempo suddenly doubles and it flips into disco.
- The voice that husbanded its breath in the slow section turns, once the fast section begins, into a powerful, chest-ringing sound (belting). Here the strength she learned in gospel truly shows itself for the first time.
- Midway through, the song slows down once more and then builds back up, giving dancers both a moment to catch their breath and a final explosion.
- In the closing stretch, a modulation up a step heightens the climb toward the end.
IV. The shadow of the peak · 1978–1980
(Peak) Her 1979 “Bad Girls” was her peak. “Hot Stuff” and “Bad Girls” went to No. 1 on the Hot 100, and “Dim All the Lights,” which she wrote herself, reached No. 2. With “Hot Stuff” she won the Grammy for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance, created that very year. Three double albums in succession, “Live and More,” “Bad Girls” and the hits collection “On the Radio,” reached No. 1 on the Billboard album chart, a feat recorded as a first. (The street) “Bad Girls” is said to have grown out of an incident in which her secretary was mistaken for a prostitute on a Hollywood street. There is also a story that when Bogart suggested giving the song to Cher, she put it away in a drawer for a while before bringing it back out. Those who helped her refine it were members of the vocal group Brooklyn Dreams. (Duet) That same year “No More Tears (Enough Is Enough),” sung with Barbra Streisand, also went to No. 1. This recording, in which the diva of Broadway and the queen of disco squared off in a single song, showed that her voice transcended genre. (Darkness) Yet in her autobiography she confessed that during this period she suffered from severe depression and insomnia, and that she once tried to throw herself from a hotel window. Around that time she became a born-again Christian, and faith became the center of the rest of her life. (Parting) In 1980, after a dispute over royalties and contract terms, she parted ways with Casablanca and became the first artist signed to the newly launched Geffen Records. In July of that year she married Bruce Sudano, a singer-songwriter from Brooklyn Dreams. With this marriage she had two more daughters, becoming the mother of three.
The first No. 1 from her peak album “Bad Girls,” it won her the Grammy for female rock vocal, created that very year. It is the point where her roots in a Boston rock band met disco.
- Over disco's steady beat, an electric guitar lays down a sharp riff. The guitar solo midway through was played by Jeff “Skunk” Baxter, the guitarist from Steely Dan and the Doobie Brothers.
- Her voice, the very opposite of the whisper in “Love to Love You Baby,” drives forward in a rough, forceful chest voice. Its grain is so different that it is hard to believe it is the same singer.
- An interlocking, repeating rhythm of bass and synthesizer sustains the tension throughout, and on every chorus the backing vocals chase after her as if in reply, holding the ear fast.
- This crossover, binding disco and rock in a single song, is cited as the reason she survived on rock radio too in 1979, as the backlash against disco grew.
When this duet with Barbra Streisand rose to No. 1, it proved that her voice could reach beyond disco and stand beside the great traditional vocalists.
- Over a slow piano-accompanied opening, the two singers trade the song line by line. Streisand's clear, rounded tone stands in contrast to her deeply gospel-hued voice.
- Its structure, a ballad that suddenly shifts tempo into disco, resembles “Last Dance.” It was co-written by the same songwriter, Paul Jabara.
- The final passage, in which the two hold a single note together for as long as they can, is the song's most famous moment. It sounds like a contest to see who can last longer.
- In the club version, which runs more than 11 minutes, the dance-rhythm sections stretch out far longer.
V. Outside the label · 1980–1989
(Wanderer) Her first album for Geffen, “The Wanderer” (1980), turned away from disco toward new wave and rock, and its title track reached No. 3 on the Hot 100. The album also included “I Believe in Jesus,” a confession of faith. But the double album she completed the following year, “I'm a Rainbow,” was shelved by the label and buried in a drawer. (Quincy) In 1982 she made the album “Donna Summer” with Quincy Jones. “Love Is in Control (Finger on the Trigger)” reached No. 10, and the chorus of “State of Independence” featured the voices of Michael Jackson, Stevie Wonder, Lionel Richie, Dionne Warwick and others. Bruce Springsteen wrote “Protection” for the album. Soon after finishing this project, Quincy Jones began work on Michael Jackson's “Thriller.” (Labor) In settling her lawsuit with Casablanca, she agreed to deliver one more album to her former label. The result, 1983's “She Works Hard for the Money,” was a song she wrote after seeing a restroom attendant dozing from exhaustion at an awards-show after-party. The music video, which depicted a working woman's day, aired often on MTV, and the song reached No. 3 on the Hot 100. In 1984 and 1985 she won back-to-back Grammys for Best Inspirational Performance for gospel songs. (Rift) In the mid-1980s, a story spread that she had made remarks onstage condemning gay people in connection with AIDS. She repeatedly denied ever saying such things, and in 1989 she wrote to the AIDS activist group ACT UP to apologize for the hurt it had caused. Even so, her relationship with the gay fans who had supported her since the disco years took a long time to heal. (Comeback) In 1989, with “This Time I Know It's for Real” from “Another Place and Time,” made with the British production team Stock Aitken Waterman, reaching No. 3 in the UK and No. 7 in the US, she returned to the charts.
She wrote it after seeing a restroom attendant dozing from exhaustion at an awards-show after-party. Instead of the “First Lady of Love” label, it became her signature song of the 1980s, singing of the weariness of working women.
- From the opening, a sturdy riff of interlocking synthesizer and guitar repeats like a march. It is the tight 1980s pop sound crafted by producer Michael Omartian.
- She sings neither in a whisper nor in exaggerated high notes, but in a firm, clear middle register. Fitting the subject, it is a delivery that sounds like a work song.
- The music video, telling the story of a working woman's day, aired often on MTV. It is frequently cited because videos by Black female singers were rare on MTV at the time.
- The chorus trades short chants with the backing singers, built so that concert audiences can easily sing along.
After a hiatus in the late 1980s, this was the song that brought her back to the charts in partnership with a British production team. She also took a songwriting credit herself.
- Stock Aitken Waterman's trademark bright synthesizers and drum machines race on without pause. It is as if the mechanical pulse of the Munich years had been reborn, some 10 years later, as British dance pop.
- The vocal opens in a light, buoyant tone with less force than in her prime, then soars freely by the time it reaches the chorus.
- A short, repeating chorus appears early in the song, built to lodge in the ear on first listen. It was the formula with which this team swept the British charts at the time.
VI. The Nashville studio · 1990–2012
(Nashville) In the mid-1990s she moved with her family to Nashville, Tennessee. Stepping back from the chart race, she devoted herself to painting, which she had long pursued, and even exhibited and sold her work. “I'm a Rainbow,” which had sat in a drawer, was finally released in 1996. (Return) “Carry On,” her 1997 reunion with Moroder, won the following year's newly created Grammy for Best Dance Recording. It was an award she shared with the producer who had built disco alongside her, the two reunited after 20 years. In 1999 her VH1 concert “Live & More Encore” showed that her voice onstage was as strong as ever, and in 2003 she published her autobiography, “Ordinary Girl: The Journey.” As the title suggests, she wanted to be understood as an ordinary woman. (Crayons) 2008's “Crayons” was her first new studio album in 17 years, since 1991, and its tracks reached No. 1 on Billboard's dance chart. In 2009 she performed at the Nobel Peace Prize Concert in Oslo, Norway. (Illness) She died of lung cancer on May 17, 2012, in Naples, Florida, at the age of 63. A nonsmoker, she reportedly believed that the dust she inhaled in New York on September 11, 2001, had caused her illness. (Legacy) A few days after her death, “I Feel Love” was added to the Library of Congress's National Recording Registry, and the following year she was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Beyoncé borrowed the melody of “Love to Love You Baby” for “Naughty Girl” in 2003, and in 2022 summoned “I Feel Love” once more in “Summer Renaissance.” In 2023 the documentary “Love to Love You, Donna Summer,” co-directed by her daughter, was released.
Lesser-known stories
(Rainbow) “I'm a Rainbow,” the double album Geffen Records shelved in 1981, lay buried in a drawer for 15 years before its official release in 1996. In the meantime, some of its tracks found their way into the world by other routes: “Romeo” appeared on the soundtrack of the 1983 film “Flashdance.” Because the album itself went so long unreleased, the fact that the song had originally belonged to an abandoned album became a story passed around only among devoted fans and collectors. (Country) She wrote “Starting Over Again” with her husband, Bruce Sudano, and in 1980 Dolly Parton's recording of it reached No. 1 on Billboard's country chart. That the Queen of Disco wrote a country chart-topper remains little known, since songwriting credits tend to be overshadowed by the singer's name. (Painter) She painted seriously from the 1980s on, and in her later years even held exhibitions and sold her work. Unlike her glamorous image onstage, she reportedly often said that she felt most like herself with a brush in hand. Because it was regarded as a sideline next to her musical career, it is a chapter given only brief treatment even in her biographies.
Notes on terms 📚🔎
Disco
(Meaning) Disco is short for the French discothèque. Meaning a place (-thèque) where records (disque) are kept, the word once referred to clubs where people danced to records instead of a live band, and it became the name of the music that flourished there. (In pop) Dance music that was hugely popular in American and European clubs in the mid-to-late 1970s. Its beat is steady and fast, lavishly layered with strings and horns, and later synthesizers. Like a whole gym class jumping rope in step, it is music that makes everyone move to the same beat. (Elsewhere) In everyday use, it can also refer to glittering 1970s-style fashion or to the dancing itself.
Four-on-the-floor
(Meaning) In English, it means four on the floor: all four beats of a bar are struck on the big drum played with a foot pedal (the bass drum). (In pop) The basic beat of disco and of the dance music that followed, such as house · techno. Boom, boom, boom, boom — the bass drum sounds the same on every beat, so even a first-time listener can easily catch the rhythm and dance. It is like stamping your feet on the playground to a count of one, two, three, four.
Synthesizer
(Meaning) The English synthesize means to make something by combining (synthesizing) several elements. A synthesizer is an instrument that produces sound by combining electrical signals. (In pop) It often looks like a keyboard, but rather than striking strings like a piano, it shapes sound from scratch with electrical circuits. Its sound can be made sharp, round, or even like a spaceship. The Moog synthesizer used on “I Feel Love” was a leading example of such instruments. It is like mixing a few paints in art class to create a new color you want.
Sequencer
(Meaning) A sequence means an order or succession. A sequencer is a device that automatically plays notes in a set order. (In pop) Without anyone playing by hand, the machine endlessly repeats a pre-entered series of notes in perfect time. The relentless bass of “I Feel Love” was made this way. It is like entering a combo move in a video game in advance so that the character repeats the same move exactly. (Elsewhere) In biology, a machine that reads the order of bases in DNA is called a sequencer.
Extended mix
(Meaning) Extended means lengthened. It is a version made by stretching out the original song and mixing it again (the mix). (In pop) A version in which a 3–4-minute song made for radio has its instrumental sections stretched to 10 or 15 minutes for people dancing in clubs. The nearly 17-minute version of “Love to Love You Baby” is an early example. It is like replaying the instrumental break a few more times at a school festival because everyone wants to keep dancing to the class talent-show song.
Concept album
(Meaning) A concept means an idea or theme. It refers to an album bound together by a single theme or story. (In pop) Rather than a collection of separate songs, it is an album built to follow a single thread of story or idea from beginning to end. Examples include “I Remember Yesterday,” which travels through the eras one by one, and “Once Upon a Time,” which retells the Cinderella story. It is like a single novel whose chapters flow into one another, not a book of collected short stories.
Crossover
(Meaning) The English cross over means to go across. It refers to music of one genre crossing over to the audience of another. (In pop) For instance, a disco singer finding popularity on the rock charts, or an R&B song reaching No. 1 on the pop charts. “Hot Stuff,” which layered rock guitar over a disco track, is one example. It is like a friend from the soccer team entering a basketball tournament and doing well. (Elsewhere) In basketball, a dribbling move that switches the ball quickly from side to side to get past a defender is called a crossover.