novareads.musicJazz

Clifford Brown

1930–1956

Recordings left in less than 4 years by a twenty-five-year-old trumpeter who kept away from both alcohol and drugs.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. RootsBorn in Wilmington, USAHis father's trumpetStudies with Lowery2. ApprenticeshipMathematics majorNavarro's encouragement1950 car accident3. BreakthroughR&B band debutDameron and GolsonBlue Note recordings4. EuropeHampton's bandSecret Paris recordingsLive at Birdland5. QuintetMax Roach“Joy Spring”With Sarah Vaughan6. The endRollins joins1956 turnpikeGolson's elegyBrown1930–1956The hard bop trumpeter who forged a new way of…
A journey on stage 🧭🗺️
NUnited States of AmericaWilmington1930–1954Dover1948–1949Princess Anne1949–1950Los Angeles1954–1955

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

People along the way ⏳🌊

  • TeacherRobert Lowery

    In Wilmington he taught him harmony and theory, laying the foundation for his precise playing.

  • InfluenceFats Navarro

    He encouraged him in Philadelphia and became his model for a round tone and long melodic lines.

  • InfluenceDizzy Gillespie

    He is said to have visited him in the hospital after the accident and urged him to keep making music.

  • FriendshipBenny Golson

    A friend he met in Dameron's band, who wrote “I Remember Clifford” after his death.

  • ColleagueMax Roach

    Co-leader and drummer of the Brown–Roach Quintet.

  • ColleagueRichie Powell

    Bud Powell's younger brother, the quintet's pianist and arranger, killed in the same crash.

I. The boy from Wilmington · 1930–1948 (age 0–18)

(Wilmington) He was born on October 30, 1930, in Wilmington, Delaware. He is said to have been one of eight children of Joseph Brown and Estelle Brown. His father, apart from his day job, was an amateur musician who took up the trumpet, the violin and the piano, and there were always instruments in the house. Delaware at the time was a state whose schools were segregated by race. He went on to Howard High School, which served Black students. (Trumpet) His father bought him a trumpet when he was about thirteen (some accounts say fifteen). The boy soon threw himself into the instrument. He began playing in the school band, and family and friends remembered that he practiced far more than anyone else. (Lowery) The decisive encounter was with Robert 'Boysie' Lowery, a Wilmington music teacher and bandleader. Lowery taught the neighborhood children to read music, along with harmony (the fabric of several notes sounding together) and music theory, and had them try not only the trumpet but also the piano, the vibraphone and the bass. Biographers agree that the systematic study of these years lay beneath Brown's later ability to pinpoint the tones of each chord even at the fastest tempos. (Mathematics) He was a quiet, diligent student with a gift for mathematics. Wilmington was not far from Philadelphia. In his late teens he began taking in the new jazz, bebop, that drifted out of that city's clubs.

II. Between mathematics and music · 1948–1951 (age 18–21)

(College) After finishing high school in 1948, he enrolled at Delaware State College in Dover as a mathematics major. The choice reportedly reflected his sense that music was too unstable a living. The next year he transferred to Maryland State College in Princess Anne, Maryland (today the University of Maryland Eastern Shore), where he played trumpet in the jazz band and wrote arrangements as well. Both schools had been founded for Black students. (Navarro) On weekends he went to jam sessions in Philadelphia. There he met Fats Navarro, the leading bebop trumpeter, who is said to have taken a liking to the young man and encouraged him. Critics broadly agree that Brown's round, full tone and his way of spinning long lines without a break came from Navarro. Navarro died in July 1950, at twenty-six, after years of tuberculosis and heroin addiction. Around the same time, Dizzy Gillespie is said to have heard him play and urged him to become a professional musician. (Accident) In June 1950, on the way home from a gig, he was in a car accident. His injuries were so severe that he spent nearly a year in a hospital bed. The story of Gillespie visiting him in the hospital and urging him not to give up music appears in every account of his life. Unable to play the trumpet, he is said to have studied harmony at the piano. (Parker) Recovered by around 1951, he returned to the bandstand. He played with Charlie Parker in Philadelphia, and Parker is said to have thought highly of his talent. He had not yet made a single record, but his name was already circulating among East Coast musicians.

III. From rhythm and blues to Blue Note · 1952–1953 (age 22–23)

(Powell) In 1952 he joined the Blue Flames, a rhythm-and-blues band led by Chris Powell. Playing for dancers paid more reliably than the bebop clubs. The band's sides, cut in Chicago that March for the Okeh label, became his first studio recordings. Even within his short solos, each crisply articulated note already catches the ear. (Dameron) In the summer of 1953 he joined composer Tadd Dameron's band, playing a club in Atlantic City. In this band he met tenor saxophonist Benny Golson and alto saxophonist Gigi Gryce. In June he took part in Dameron's Prestige recording “A Study in Dameronia.” Dameron's songlike, flowing compositions suited Brown's melody-minded temperament. (Blue Note) Between June and August of the same year, Alfred Lion of Blue Note called him into the studio three times: a quintet with Lou Donaldson, a sextet with trombonist J. J. Johnson, and a sextet under his own name. These recordings won the critics' attention, and the following year he took the New Star award in the “DownBeat” critics' poll. His colleagues called him Brownie. (Restraint) Heroin was spreading among bebop musicians at the time. He kept away from alcohol and drugs, and enjoyed chess. Golson later remembered him as a modest man who always looked after others first. Some suggest that losing Navarro shaped that outlook.

♪Memorial Album1953 (age 23)

Compiled from two 1953 Blue Note sessions, this record was issued as a memorial album in 1956, the year he died. Already, at the time of his first recordings, you can hear his fully formed voice.

  • In “Brownie Speaks,” you can hear the technique of crisply separating each note with the tongue (tonguing), even at fast tempos. Notes that roll out like beads instead of blurring together are his first hallmark.
  • In the slow ballad “Easy Living,” listen for the round, warm tone of his long notes, and the restraint with which he rations the technique of gently trembling a note (vibrato).
  • The sextet (six-piece) ensemble, three horns stacking harmonies to sing the theme, gives way to the solos. The contrast between arranged ensemble and improvised solo is the architecture of Blue Note recordings from this period.
  • The drums on the two sessions were played by Philly Joe Jones and Art Blakey respectively. It is worth comparing how each drummer drives the same trumpeter from behind.

IV. Hampton's band and Paris · 1953–1954 (age 23–24)

(Hampton) In the fall of 1953 he joined Lionel Hampton's big band and set off on a European tour. With him were Art Farmer on trumpet, Quincy Jones on trumpet and arrangements, Gigi Gryce, and Jimmy Cleveland on trombone. Hampton's wife Gladys, who managed the band's affairs, forbade the musicians to make other recordings while on tour. (Paris) The young musicians ignored the ban. Brown recorded several times for local labels in Stockholm and Paris, with Gryce and Jones writing the arrangements. They are said to have slipped out of their lodgings after the night's concert and headed for the studio. From big band to small combo, these recordings carry the exuberance of players set free from band life, where solos came short and in a fixed order. Some recall that the meager pay was also a motive. (Homecoming) After the return to America, Hampton reportedly dismissed the musicians who had taken part. Brown, too, left the band. (Birdland) On the night of February 21, 1954, he took the stage at the New York club Birdland with drummer Art Blakey, pianist Horace Silver, alto saxophonist Lou Donaldson and bassist Curly Russell. Blue Note sent engineer Rudy Van Gelder to record the performance live. The record of that night is regarded as a herald of the movement later called hard bop, and of Blakey's Jazz Messengers. Playing Gillespie's “A Night in Tunisia” and tunes by Parker, he recast his elders' language in his own voice.

♪A Night at Birdland1954 (age 24)

A live set from a New York club, played with abandon a few months after he was freed from the Hampton band's recording ban. It is regarded as the starting point of hard bop and of the Jazz Messengers.

  • The opening introduction by emcee Pee Wee Marquette and the murmur of the crowd — the atmosphere of a live recording Rudy Van Gelder made in the club itself survives intact.
  • Horace Silver's “Split Kick” alternates between a Latin rhythm and swing that rolls four even beats (the push-and-pull feel of lightly dragging the back half of each beat). Listen to how Blakey's drums change the whole game the moment the rhythm shifts.
  • “Once in a While” is a ballad in which Brown stands alone out front. The passage where, within the slow tempo, he suddenly drives the line at twice the speed (double time) is often cited as the high point of the record.
  • In Dizzy Gillespie's “A Night in Tunisia” and Parker's “Confirmation,” you can hear Brown reworking his bebop elders' tunes in his own voice.
  • Blakey's rapid snare-drum roll that pushes the soloist from behind (press roll) sounds like a signal marking the turn of each chorus.

V. The quintet in the West · 1954 (age 24)

(Roach) That spring, drummer Max Roach called him to California. Roach had played alongside Parker and Gillespie in the days when bebop was born, and was then working at the Lighthouse, a club in Hermosa Beach outside Los Angeles. The two formed a quintet that carried both their names side by side. (Lineup) At first the group included Teddy Edwards on tenor saxophone, Carl Perkins on piano and George Bledsoe on bass. By summer the lineup had settled with Harold Land on tenor, Richie Powell on piano and George Morrow on bass. Richie Powell was the younger brother of bebop pianist Bud Powell. EmArcy, Mercury Records' jazz label, signed the group, and producer Bob Shad took charge of the recordings. In August they recorded their first album in Los Angeles. It included Bud Powell's “Parisian Thoroughfare.” (Marriage) In Los Angeles he met LaRue Anderson, and they married that year. “Joy Spring,” which became the quintet's signature tune, took its title from his pet name for his wife. Its brightly soaring melody seems to hold the whole of his fresh start in the West. (Collaborations) Shad kept him busy outside the quintet as well. In August he joined Dinah Washington on “Dinah Jams,” a studio recording made before an audience, and in December in New York he took part in albums by Sarah Vaughan and by Helen Merrill, the latter arranged by Quincy Jones. Beside a singer, rather than stepping forward, he filled the gaps in the song with brief answering phrases.

♪Clifford Brown & Max Roach1954 (age 24)

His first album, recorded in Los Angeles in the year he formed the quintet in the West and married. It includes “Joy Spring,” named for his pet name for his wife.

  • “Joy Spring” is in a form that states an eight-bar strain twice, passes through a different strain, and returns to the first (32-bar AABA). The second A moves into a key a half step higher to sing the same melody again, and the heart of it is the way Brown's solo glides across that modulation.
  • “Daahoud” is a tune whose chords change very quickly. The precision of the theme ensemble, with trumpet and tenor locked together as one body, shows what defined this quintet.
  • In the latter part of the 12-bar blues “Blues Walk,” Brown, Land and Roach exchange short solos a few bars at a time (trading). Listen to the conversational breath of it, like remarks passed back and forth.
  • Roach's drums do more than keep time; they converse like a melody through cymbals and snare. In the introduction to Bud Powell's “Parisian Thoroughfare,” there is even a passage that seems to imitate the noise of city streets.
♪Sarah Vaughan with Clifford Brown1954 (age 24)

The most celebrated of the collaborations Shad arranged outside the quintet. It was first issued under the title “Sarah Vaughan,” and Vaughan is said to have held this record especially dear.

  • In “Lullaby of Birdland,” Vaughan uses the vocal technique of improvising like an instrument on meaningless syllables (scat). The passages where trumpet·flute·tenor and voice trade back and forth are the center of the song.
  • On a slow number like “April in Paris,” Brown slips short answering phrases (obbligato) in behind the vocal. Listen to the restraint: he fills only the places where the singer's breath runs out, and never covers the song.
  • The band is a small combo, and every track is given generous length. The easy flow laid down by Jimmy Jones on piano and Roy Haynes on drums gives the date the loose, free air of a jam session.
  • Vaughan's wide range and dark timbre are so close to Brown's round trumpet tone that there are moments when the two sounds blend into a single mass.

VI. A year of hard bop · 1955 (age 25)

(Strings) In January 1955, in New York, he recorded twelve ballads with a string orchestra arranged by Neal Hefti. It was an album devoted less to improvisation than to singing the melody, and EmArcy conceived it as a record aimed at a wide audience. Here his other face, the lyrical tone behind the man known for blazing technique, comes through whole. (Hard bop) In February he returned to the studio with the quintet to record “Study in Brown.” It held a breakneck “Cherokee,” “Take the ‘A’ Train,” the signature tune of Duke Ellington's orchestra, wrapped in the sounds of a train, and “Sandu,” a blues of his own. This quintet's way of working, with five players locking precisely into worked-out introductions and ensemble passages, was different from the improvisation-first jam session. Together with Miles Davis's quintet, formed the same year, they are often set side by side as the bands that defined hard bop, the jazz of the generation after bebop. (Family) In 1955 a son was born. The quintet toured the clubs of the East and the Midwest, and his colleagues recalled that even in life on the road he never skipped practice. Few records survive of his earnings or the terms of his contracts. What is clear is that he and Roach, as co-leaders, shared the burden of dealing with the label and the club bookings. (Rollins) At the end of that year Harold Land left the quintet, returning to Los Angeles for family reasons. The empty chair was filled by Sonny Rollins, a tenor saxophonist then staying in Chicago. On a single stage, Brown's smooth, exact lines met Rollins's playing, which split a theme and twisted it from unexpected angles.

♪Study in Brown1955 (age 25)

This is the album on which the quintet, its lineup now settled, plays its tightest ensemble. Worked-out arrangements and incendiary improvisation coexist on a single record.

  • After the quintet's arranged introduction, “Cherokee” tears off at a blistering tempo. Brown's solo is widely used as a study piece that trumpeters transcribe and practice.
  • “Take the ‘A’ Train” (composed by Billy Strayhorn), the signature tune of Duke Ellington's orchestra, is framed by an opening and an ending in which the instruments mimic a train pulling out and coming to a stop.
  • Brown's own “Sandu” is a blues at a relaxed medium tempo. Listen to how he chooses the dark notes of the blues over the unhurried push and pull (groove) of the rhythm section.
  • Brown's tune “George's Dilemma” is built to alternate Latin rhythm and swing, and each time the rhythm shifts, Roach's drums change color.
♪Clifford Brown with Strings1955 (age 25)“Memories of You” and other live recordings, Clifford Brown

This is a ballad album on which a man who made his name with speed and technique stakes everything on melody alone. It belongs to the meeting of jazz and string orchestra that followed Parker's recordings with strings.

  • Improvisation is pared to a minimum, and the melody is sung almost as written. Listen for the way he interprets each tune through nothing more than tone and the small ornaments that lightly color the ends of his notes.
  • Neal Hefti's string arrangements never step forward; they lay down a backdrop. Beneath them, Richie Powell, George Morrow, Max Roach, and Barry Galbraith on guitar hold the beat.
  • On “Yesterdays” and “Stardust,” what stands out is the full tone of his middle register and the breath that carries long notes without a waver.
  • All twelve tracks are slow standards. Their consistent mood comes alive when you listen to the album straight through rather than one track at a time.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. The Pennsylvania Turnpike · 1956 (age 26)

(Arrangement) In January and February 1956, the quintet, now with Rollins, recorded “Clifford Brown and Max Roach at Basin Street” in New York. The title came from the club where they were playing, but it was a studio recording. Richie Powell's arrangements had grown bolder, wrapping familiar standards in new harmonies. In March the same five men recorded “Sonny Rollins Plus 4” for Prestige under Rollins's name. (Turnpike) On the night of June 25, he is said to have dropped in and played at a jam session at Music City, a record store in Philadelphia. Afterward he set out on the night road toward a gig in Chicago with Richie Powell and Richie's wife, Nancy, who was driving. In the rain near Bedford on the Pennsylvania Turnpike the car left the road, and on June 26 all three were killed. Brown was twenty-five. (Funeral) He was buried in his hometown of Wilmington. Roach, who had been traveling separately, is said to have struggled for a long time with the shock of losing his colleague and friend. Bud Powell lost his younger brother in the crash. (Legacy) The following year Benny Golson wrote “I Remember Clifford,” a ballad in his memory, and it became a jazz standard. Trumpeters of the next generation, such as Lee Morgan, Freddie Hubbard, and Booker Little, grew up using his recordings as their textbook. Since 1989 Wilmington has held a jazz festival that bears his name. Every recording he left behind comes from a span of little more than 4 years.

♪Clifford Brown and Max Roach at Basin Street1956 (age 26)

This is the signature record of the quintet with Rollins, and a document made only months before Brown and Richie Powell died.

  • “What Is This Thing Called Love” opens with Richie Powell's arrangement. The technique of dressing a familiar tune's chords in different harmonies (reharmonization) makes the song strange and new.
  • The contrast between Brown and Rollins is the heart of it. The trumpet's smooth, precise line and the tenor's way of splitting a theme, twisting it, and building it back up come one after the other.
  • On the up-tempo “I'll Remember April,” Roach's drum solo splits the beat apart and gathers it back together, shaped like a single story.
  • Richie Powell's own “Powell's Prances” and “Gertrude's Bounce” show that he was growing, at this time, into the quintet's composer and arranger.

Lesser-known stories

His first studio recordings were not bebop but rhythm and blues: the sides he cut for the Okeh label in Chicago in March 1952 with Chris Powell and the Blue Flames. These recordings lay buried for years until they resurfaced on “The Beginning and the End,” released by Columbia in 1973. That record put his first recordings on a single disc with a tape said to have been made at the jam session at Philadelphia's Music City on his last night. Only 17 years after he was gone were his beginning and his end set side by side. The Stockholm·Paris recordings he made on the sly during the Hampton tour are musically important, but they first came out scattered across local European labels under various names, among them Gigi Gryce and Quincy Jones. Only later, as reissues were sorted out, could they be heard gathered together under Brown's name. That is why, even today, few people know how many recordings those few weeks produced in his short career. The “Dinah Jams” session in Los Angeles in August 1954 is remembered as a Dinah Washington record, but at that same session Brown stood shoulder to shoulder with Clark Terry and Maynard Ferguson, three trumpets trading solos in turn. Shad seated an invited audience in the studio to create a club-like atmosphere, and the same players' performances were also issued as a separate jam session album. It is a rare document in which three trumpeters of entirely different grain can be heard and compared in one place.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Bebop

(The word) Bebop is not a word with a meaning; the name is thought to come from vocal imitations of this music's short, clipped phrases. (In jazz) The jazz created in 1940s New York by players such as Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie. Tempos are very fast, the chords change densely, and the music moved closer to something to be listened to than something to dance to. It is like someone who has mastered the basic jump rope step mixing in double-unders and criss-crosses to invent tricks of their own — you have to get the rules into your body before you can play freely on top of them.

Hard bop

(The word) Hard means firm and forceful. The name says that a thicker, more powerful feel was added to bop. (In jazz) Jazz of the mid-1950s that took bebop as its base, added the earthy feel of the blues and church music (gospel), and polished worked-out introductions and ensemble passages. Art Blakey's Jazz Messengers and the Brown–Roach quintet are its leading examples. It is like soccer, where set pieces such as corner kicks follow a plan agreed in advance while open play runs free — the arranged and the improvised share a single tune.

Jam session

(In jazz) A gathering where, instead of a fixed band, whoever turns up picks a tune everyone knows and plays it together on the spot. It works like a school where young players show their skills before their elders and learn from them; it was at a Philadelphia jam session that Brown met Fats Navarro. It resembles kids meeting for the first time on a playground after school, choosing sides, and starting a pickup soccer game — everyone knows the rules, so even strangers can join in at once. (Elsewhere) Jam can also mean the fruit preserve you spread on bread, or a snarled traffic jam.

Chorus

(The word) It comes from choros, the chorus that sang and danced in ancient Greek drama. (In jazz) The unit of one complete pass through a tune's form from beginning to end. In a 32-bar tune, 32 bars make one chorus, and a solo of three choruses means the player improvised over three passes through the form. It is like counting laps on a running track — the shape of the track is the same every time, but your speed and stride can change from lap to lap. (Elsewhere) In popular songs, chorus usually means the refrain, and in general use it means a choir or choral singing.

Trading fours

(The word) Trade means to exchange, and fours means four bars at a time. (In jazz) A practice in which players take turns exchanging short solos of four bars (sometimes eight or two). Most often a horn player trades with the drummer, so the drums end up speaking like a melodic instrument. Like a table tennis rally, one player hits and the other returns the ball, and my answer changes with the direction and force of the ball you send me. (Elsewhere) In economics, trading means the buying and selling of stocks or goods.

32-bar AABA form

(In jazz) The most common frame for a jazz standard. An 8-bar strain, A, is played twice, then comes an 8-bar B of a different mood (called the bridge because it acts as one), and then a return to A, for 32 bars in all. It is like a cheer routine that repeats one move twice, inserts a new move once, and closes by returning to the first — familiar, familiar, new, familiar again. “Joy Spring” twists this frame with a variation that plays the second A a half step higher.

Ballad

(The word) It comes from the Latin ballare, to dance, and originally meant a song sung to accompany dancing. (In jazz) A slow, lyrical piece. Because the player cannot pour out notes as in a fast tune, their tone and breath are laid bare, which actually makes it harder. It is like the way your posture shows more when you walk slowly than when you run. “Clifford Brown with Strings” is an album made up entirely of ballads. (Elsewhere) In literature it means a narrative poem handed down among the people, and in Korean pop music a slow love song is commonly called a ballad.