novareads.musicClassical

Robert Schumann

1810–1856

"Hats off, gentlemen — a genius!" — the words he left in a journal on first recognizing the still-unknown Chopin.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. RootsBorn in Zwickau, GermanyA bookseller's sonEarly loss of his father2. WanderingFrom law to musicTraining under WieckHand injury3. CriticFounds the Neue Zeitschrift …Recognizes ChopinFlorestan and Eusebius4. LoveCourt battle over ClaraMarriage in 1840The year of song5. ZenithThe year of the symphonyEight childrenDresden revolution6. Final yearsDiscovers BrahmsLeap into the RhineDies in EndenichSchumann1810–1856A law student turned composer and critic who s…
Life's journey 🧭🗺️
NGermanyZwickau1810–1828Leipzig1828–1844Dresden1844–1850Düsseldorf1850–1854Bonn (Endenich)1854–1856

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

Those close to him ⏳🌊

  • FamilyAugust Schumann

    A bookseller and publisher, he passed on to his son a literary cultivation and an early taste of publishing.

  • TeacherFriedrich Wieck

    He was the teacher who taught him piano, yet he later opposed his marriage to his daughter Clara, going so far as to fight it in court.

  • FamilyClara Schumann

    As his wife and the foremost pianist of her day, she championed his works on the concert stage throughout her life.

  • FriendshipFelix Mendelssohn

    Close companions in Leipzig, they respected each other's music, and he conducted the premiere of the Symphony No. 1.

  • InfluenceFrédéric Chopin

    Hearing the work of a near-unknown, he introduced it to the world through his criticism and made it known across European musical life.

  • FriendshipJohannes Brahms

    A young composer who came to him in his final years; his essay 'New Paths' announced the young man's gift to the world.

Play all 7 on YouTube ↗

I. The boy from Zwickau · 1810–1828 (age 0–18)

(Birth) He was born in June 1810 in Zwickau, in the Kingdom of Saxony (today's Germany). His father, August Schumann, was a bookseller and publisher, so steeped in literature that he translated Byron and Walter Scott into German. His mother, Johanna Christiane, was a surgeon's daughter. Robert was the youngest of five children, and the house was always piled with books and printed matter. (Literature) From childhood he was drawn to literature before music. By about the age of six he was writing poems and plays in imitation of what he read, and with his classmates he formed a literary circle that held readings. His father eagerly encouraged this talent, at times even printing what his son had written. He began piano lessons around the age of seven with a local organist, but at the time it was merely one hobby among many. (Loss) In 1826, when he was sixteen, his father died. The death shook the family's finances, and his mother, wanting him in a steadier profession than music, urged him to study law. Robert tried not to defy her wishes, yet his diaries from this period already mingle a longing for music with indifference to law. The inheritance his father left would later become the means that funded his musical studies.

II. Leipzig and Wieck · 1828–1830 (age 18–20)

(Enrollment) In 1828 he entered the University of Leipzig as a law student. But he frequented taverns, concerts and the library more often than lectures, and his letters to his mother voiced his discontent with law ever more openly. Lodging in Leipzig during this period, he sought out the piano teacher Friedrich Wieck and began private lessons. (Wieck) Wieck was a strict and ambitious teacher who had been rigorously training his daughter Clara from an early age to become a prodigy pianist. When Robert began frequenting the Wieck household, Clara was still a girl of nine. Their bond began then, though no one at the time could have guessed it would one day lead to a decade-long battle in the courts. (Turning point) In 1829 he moved to Heidelberg and went on pretending to study law, but his heart was already set on music. In 1830, after hearing Paganini play in person, his resolve hardened. He wrote to his mother begging to be allowed to give up law and follow the path of a musician, and asked Wieck to take him on. Wieck agreed on conditions, and Robert returned to Leipzig, moved into the Wieck house, and began a life of pounding the keys for hours each day.

III. The wounded finger · 1830–1834 (age 20–24)

(Injury) Living in Wieck's house, he threw himself into training, driven by the ambition to become the greatest of virtuosos. But from around 1831, a paralysis began to appear in his right hand, especially in the fourth finger. A long-told story holds that he injured it using a mechanical device he had devised to strengthen his fingers independently, but the exact cause remains unclear even today. What is clear is that the injury closed off his future as a performer forever. (A new direction) With his dream of becoming a pianist crushed, he turned to composition and criticism. In 1834 he co-founded the music journal 'Neue Zeitschrift für Musik' with colleagues and took on its editorship. In its pages he wrote under the imaginary pen names Florestan and Eusebius, the former speaking for his impulsive, passionate self, the latter for his contemplative, introspective self. This double personality was etched just as deeply into his music. (Chopin) Earlier, in 1831, he had heard the variations on a theme from 'Don Giovanni' by Frédéric Chopin, a young Pole then nearly unknown, and wrote a tribute in Leipzig's 'Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung' that opened with the line "Hats off, gentlemen, a genius!" That single sentence not only helped introduce Chopin to the musical world of Europe but also marked the moment Schumann established himself as a critic who heard new voices rather than outworn forms. Around 1834 he was briefly engaged to his pupil Ernestine von Fricken, but the engagement was soon broken off.

♪Papillons Op. 21831 (age 21)Live: Vladimir Ashkenazy (piano) · 1985

An early work that sets to music the masked ball in a novel by Jean Paul, it is something like a preview of the dual self that would later split into Florestan and Eusebius.

  • In the final piece, a clock strikes six and the music fades away as if candles were going out one by one — a passage known to depict the end of the masked ball and the coming of dawn.
  • The moment when the tune of the old German folk dance 'Grandfather's Dance' (Grossvatertanz) slips in — a clash of old and new that returns later in 'Carnaval'.
  • Twelve short scenes follow one another like the pages of a picture book flipped in quick succession — listen for the points where the mood shifts abruptly the moment one piece ends.
  • The opening theme, which begins in the manner of a slow waltz, returns transformed at the end, framing the whole work like the door that opens and closes the ball.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Carnaval Op. 91834–1835 (age 24–25)Live: Boris Giltburg (piano) · 2011 Rubinstein Competition

A masked-ball suite that sets portraits of himself, his friends, Chopin and Paganini side by side over a cipher hiding the musical letters in the name of his fiancée Ernestine's hometown and in the composer's own name.

  • The short piece titled 'Chopin' is a portrait imitating Chopin's signature singing left-hand accompaniment and ornaments — worth comparing to hear how precisely Schumann captured Chopin's idiom.
  • 'Paganini' runs through passages in which the fingers cross rapidly and spring off the keys (staccato), sounding as if the violin's dazzling virtuosity had been carried over to the piano.
  • The two pieces 'Florestan' and 'Eusebius' are self-portraits of the passionate self and the dreaming self respectively; heard side by side, the contrast is striking.
  • A short figure made of the four notes A, E-flat (Es), C and B (H) recurs throughout many of the pieces — a cipher drawn from the name of his fiancée's hometown and the spelling of Schumann's own name.
  • The finale, 'March of the League of David against the Philistines', is an imagined march in which a league of progressive artists routs the conservative philistines, a grand conclusion in which the piano drives forward with weighty chords and marching rhythms.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. The struggle for Clara · 1835–1840 (age 25–30)

(Love) From around 1835, his feelings for Clara Wieck, now grown to sixteen, began to move beyond friendship. Clara was already renowned as a prodigy pianist touring Europe, and her father had staked his own life on managing his daughter's career. When Wieck discovered their relationship he opposed it fiercely, declaring that he could not give his daughter to a poor and unstable musician, and he forbade their meetings and correspondence. (The lawsuit) The two kept up their relationship by exchanging letters behind Wieck's back, and finally, in 1839, they filed suit in a Leipzig court seeking permission to marry. In court Wieck argued that he could not hand over his daughter, taking issue with Robert's character and habits, but his case was rejected. In August 1840 the court granted permission for the marriage, and on September 12, the day before Clara turned twenty-one, the two were quietly married in a church outside Leipzig. (Songs) The year 1840 brought such an explosion of song that it would later be called the 'year of song'. In that single year he composed more than a hundred songs, the feelings of a love fulfilled after long waiting flowing out through the poems of Heine and Chamisso. Having written almost nothing but solo piano music until then, he threw himself into song as though, on the eve of his marriage, he had suddenly found his voice.

♪Kinderszenen Op. 151838 (age 28)Performed by Lang Lang (piano)

Written while he was separated from Clara in the years before their marriage, the work looks back on childhood. These are not pieces for a child to play but pieces written by an adult looking back on youth.

  • The seventh piece, 'Träumerei' (Dreaming), is the most famous of the set; its simple, singing melody is often played as an encore.
  • Throughout, it is steeped not in bright nursery-song cheer but in a wistful, longing mood — it is best heard through the eyes of an adult yearning for childhood.
  • The final piece, 'The Poet Speaks', ends quietly, leaving a lingering resonance like a question left unanswered.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Dichterliebe, Op. 481840 (age 30)Sung by Jonas Kaufmann (tenor) · Helmut Deutsch (piano)

Written in the 'year of song' that finally brought his marriage, this cycle on poems by Heine holds both the joy that crowns a long wait and the bitterness hidden beneath it.

  • The first song, 'Im wunderschönen Monat Mai,' opens on harmonies that never quite settle but waver unresolved — painting at once the thrill and the unease of a new love not yet sure of itself.
  • The postludes in which the piano carries on alone after the voice has fallen silent, above all the long piano postlude of the final song, sound as though they were finishing the feelings the singer could not bring to an end.
  • The moments where Heine's peculiar bittersweet irony overlaps with gentle melody — listen for the difference in temperature between words and music, and the songs reach far deeper.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. The composer at his peak · 1841–1849 (age 31–39)

(Symphonies) 1841, the year after the wedding, came to be called the 'year of the symphony.' Beginning with the First Symphony, said to have been sketched in just four days, the frameworks of the period's major orchestral works took shape. The symphony was premiered at the Leipzig Gewandhaus under the baton of his close friend Felix Mendelssohn. Clara, a brilliant pianist, often placed her husband's works on her concert programs to make them known, and the two shared a diary in which they recorded their feelings and their work day by day. (Family) Beginning with the birth of their first daughter, Marie, in 1841, the couple had eight children. Clara kept performing through pregnancy after pregnancy, while Robert took an active part in running the household and educating the children. Yet two musicians under one roof always meant a taut strain. When Clara left home on concert tours, Robert complained of isolation; when he was absorbed in composing, Clara had to endure seeing her own performing career pushed aside. (Dresden) In 1844 they left Leipzig for Dresden, having judged that his worsening nervous exhaustion and insomnia called for rest. When an uprising broke out in Dresden in May 1849 and barricades went up in the streets, the couple took refuge in the nearby village of Maxen. Even amid this political upheaval he pressed on with the monumental task of setting Goethe's 'Faust' to music, and in this city he completed the opera 'Genoveva' and a number of chamber works.

♪Symphony No. 1 'Spring', Op. 381841 (age 31)Live: Philharmonie Südwestfalen · Gerard Oskamp, conductor

Said to have been sketched in just four days in the year after his marriage, this symphony lets newfound happiness and hope overflow through the entire orchestra.

  • The rising signal (fanfare) the brass cry out at the very opening — a passage said to have been inspired by a line from a poem in praise of spring.
  • Throughout the first movement the rhythm quickens and gathers vigor — worth hearing for its sense of momentum, as if moving from winter into spring.
  • Warmly received at its premiere under his friend Mendelssohn, the symphony is marked by the bright, confident tone the whole orchestra sustains.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪Piano Concerto in A minor, Op. 541841/1845 (age 31–35)Performed by Martha Argerich (piano) · Chailly, conductor

Begun as a single-movement fantasy for Clara, it was completed a few years later as a full concerto, and Clara herself gave the premiere.

  • The opening, where the piano plunges headlong the instant the orchestra strikes a short chord — counted among the most famous beginnings in the history of the concerto.
  • The slow second movement is full of passages where piano and orchestra seem to trade remarks, which is why it is often called 'the conversing movement.'
  • As the music passes into the third movement, a rhythm with subtly displaced beats (syncopation) appears — a passage that sounds jaunty yet slightly off balance.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. Düsseldorf and Brahms · 1850–1854 (age 40–44)

(Appointment) In 1850 he took up the post of municipal music director in Düsseldorf. The position meant conducting the choir and orchestra, but he was clumsy with the baton, and his reticence in rehearsal made it hard to communicate with the players. According to contemporaries, he would often lose the beat while conducting, as if he had sunk into a world of his own. Even so, in these years he produced one mature orchestral work after another, including the Third Symphony, the 'Rhenish,' and the Cello Concerto. (Brahms) In September 1853, Johannes Brahms, an unknown twenty-year-old composer, called on the Schumanns with a letter of introduction. Hearing Brahms play, Schumann recognized his gift at once and introduced the young man to the musical world of Europe in an essay titled 'New Paths,' published in his own journal. This piece of criticism, for which he took up the pen again after years of silence, became the last major writing of his life. Around this time he also grew close to the violinist Joseph Joachim and composed a violin concerto for him. (Unrest) Yet his days in Düsseldorf were bound up with failing health. His auditory hallucinations and anxiety grew steadily worse, until the city's music society finally asked him to lay down the baton. The family came to depend more and more on Clara's earnings as a performer. From this time on, Brahms stayed close to the Schumann family and helped them endure the hard years.

♪Symphony No. 3 'Rhenish', Op. 971850 (age 40)Live: Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra · Paavo Järvi, conductor

Written soon after he took up his post in Düsseldorf and settled in the Rhine valley, this symphony absorbs the flow of the river and the impressions left by Cologne Cathedral.

  • The fourth movement is said to capture his impressions of a solemn ceremony in Cologne Cathedral — listen for the majestic, chant-like brass chords that unfold like a procession.
  • Many have heard in the broadly unfolding string themes of the first and fifth movements the unhurried flow of the Rhine.
  • The orchestration throughout is dense and sonorous, bearing traces of the large choral and orchestral stages he handled as a conductor in his Düsseldorf years.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. Endenich · 1854–1856 (age 44–46)

(The leap) In February 1854, his hallucinations having grown unbearable, he left the house in the middle of the night and threw himself into the Rhine. Rescued by fishermen, he survived, but after the incident he himself asked to be admitted to the asylum at Endenich, near Bonn. On the doctors' advice Clara was not allowed to visit for nearly two years, and it was Brahms who went to the asylum often in her place and reported Schumann's condition back to her. (Family) Even in the asylum he never wholly let go of music, leaving letters and brief musical sketches. But his illness did not lift, and he died at Endenich on July 29, 1856. Clara was permitted to see him only a few days before the end, and she was at her husband's side in his last moments. Of their eight children, several died young, and some of those who survived went on to paths connected with music. (Legacy) For nearly forty years afterward Clara continued to perform, bringing her husband's works to stages across Europe and keeping up deep friendships with younger musicians, Brahms among them. The songs, piano pieces and symphonies Schumann left behind became part of the core vocabulary of Romantic music, and his spirit, which loved literature and music alike, left its mark on many composers who followed.

Lesser-known stories

From the early days of their marriage the couple took turns writing in a shared notebook, the 'marriage diary.' Alongside grand artistic resolutions, it preserves small records such as quarrels over who would practice when, since the house had only one piano. Such textures of daily life survive because the diary was long kept within the family before being opened to later scholars. In 'Carnaval,' four notes drawn from the spelling of the hometown of his former fiancée, Ernestine, and from the letters of his own name lie hidden throughout like a cipher. Schumann himself revealed the code in the subtitle 'Little scenes on four notes' and in the 'Sphinxes' printed in the score, so it was known from his own day. The exact cause of the paralysis in his right hand has still not been fully established. The story that it came from a mechanical device meant to strengthen individual fingers long circulated as accepted fact, but later biographers have also weighed the possibility that it was a side effect of a treatment prescribed at the time. With no decisive evidence either way, accounts differ slightly from one biography to the next.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Art song

(Literal meaning) Gagok ('sung piece') joins ga (歌), 'song,' and gok (曲), 'tune' — literally, 'a piece that is sung.' The German Lied, too, was once just an ordinary word for 'song,' but through Schubert and Schumann it settled into the name of an art genre in which poem and piano accompaniment meet as equals. (In music) A short vocal piece that sets a single poem to music. The piano is not merely an accompaniment holding up the voice but a second voice that helps paint the poem's mood and feeling. Just as you shift pitch and pace to bring out the emotion when reading a poem aloud, an art song can be thought of as that recitation clothed in melody and harmony.

Song cycle

(Literal meaning) Yeongagok ('linked songs') joins yeon (連), 'to link,' ga (歌), 'song,' and gok (曲), 'tune,' to mean 'songs that follow one another.' (In music) A set of art songs woven around a single story or theme and meant to be sung in order. It is a bit like a series of comic strips that can each be read alone but complete a single story when read in sequence. In Schumann's 'Dichterliebe,' sixteen songs follow a single emotional thread, from the first stirrings of a love gone wrong to resignation.

Symphony

(Literal meaning) Gyohyanggok ('resounding together') is written with Chinese characters meaning to resound (響) together — a piece in which many instruments sound together in harmony. (In music) A large-scale instrumental work played by the full orchestra, usually in four movements of contrasting character. Just as a series of events makes up a single sports meet, a fast movement, a slow movement, a dance-like movement and a lively finale follow one another to form one great work.

Concerto

(Literal meaning) Hyeopjugok (協奏曲) means a piece played (奏) together (協). The Latin root of its Western name, concertare, also means 'to contend,' so the character of this music, in which soloist and orchestra trade phrases as if in contest, is already present in the name. (In music) A piece in which a single solo instrument, such as a piano or violin, plays in exchange with the whole orchestra. It resembles one person stepping forward to sing while the others support them with harmony, except that in a concerto the soloist and the orchestra take turns as the protagonist.

Variations

(Literal meaning) Byeonjugok ('changed playing') joins byeon (變), 'to change,' ju (奏), 'to play,' and gok (曲), 'tune,' to mean 'a piece that keeps transforming its theme.' (In music) A piece that sets out a single theme and then presents it again and again in altered forms, changing its rhythm, harmony or tempo. It is like retelling the same story in a different voice, at a different pace, and sometimes as a joke.

Romanticism

(In music) The movement of the nineteenth century that sought to express individual feeling, imagination and literary fancy in music, rather than a balance of reason and form. Think of it as closer to a diary or a novel in which you freely set down your own thoughts than to a math problem with a fixed answer. Schumann stood at the very heart of this movement, a composer who carried his love of poetry and fiction straight into his music. (Elsewhere) Romanticism also names the same spirit in literature and the visual arts of the same period, and in everyday speech the word 'romantic' is used more lightly to mean an air of love or sentiment.