Gustav Mahler
“My time will come.”
At a glance 🔭💭
Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)
Those close to him ⏳🌊
- FamilyMarie Mahler
His mother, who walked with a limp and had a weak heart; Mahler felt a deep compassion for her all his life.
- TeacherAnton Bruckner
Mahler followed him while attending his lectures at the University of Vienna, and later championed his symphonies by arranging and conducting them.
- RivalryRichard Strauss
The leading composer-conductors of the German-speaking world in the same era, they were rivals who nonetheless helped bring each other's works to their premieres.
- ProtégéBruno Walter
A young assistant he met in Hamburg, Walter gave the premieres of 〈Das Lied von der Erde〉 and the Ninth Symphony after Mahler's death.
- FamilyAlma Mahler
His wife, whom he married in 1902, received the dedication of the Eighth Symphony, and her memoirs did much to shape the image of Mahler.
- FriendshipArnold Schoenberg
Though he struggled to understand it, Mahler publicly championed the young Schoenberg's music and quietly helped support him.
I. The boy from Iglau · 1860–1875 (age 0–15)
(Birth) He was born in July 1860 in Kaliště, a small village in Bohemia in the Austrian Empire (today the Czech Republic). His father, Bernhard Mahler, was a Jewish tradesman who had started out as a peddler before distilling spirits and running a tavern; his mother, Marie Hermann, was the daughter of a soap maker. That December the family moved to the nearby town of Iglau (today Jihlava in the Czech Republic), and it was there that Gustav grew up. (Siblings) The couple had fourteen children, but nearly half died young. The father was rough and stubborn, and the mother, who walked with a limp and had a weak heart, endured life at his side. Mahler pitied his mother deeply all his life. In 1875 his favorite brother, Ernst, died of illness at thirteen. Mahler is said to have kept watch at his bedside through the long sickness, telling him stories. (Bugles) A garrison was stationed in Iglau, so marches and bugle calls ran through daily life, and the Bohemian folk songs sung by maids and neighbors stayed in the child's ear. One story has him picking out songs he had heard on an accordion, and it was around this time that he found a piano in his grandmother's attic and began to play it. In 1870, at ten, he gave his first public performance at the Iglau municipal theater. (Soundscape) That the military bugles, folk songs and funeral marches would later tumble together in his symphonies owed much to this childhood soundscape. His father decided to bet on the boy's talent. In 1875 he took the fifteen-year-old Mahler to Vienna to play for the pianist Julius Epstein, who declared the boy a born musician and urged him to enter the conservatory.
II. The conservatory and the wandering conductor · 1875–1888 (age 15–28)
(Conservatory) In the autumn of 1875 he entered the Vienna Conservatory, studying piano with Epstein, harmony with Robert Fuchs and composition with Franz Krenn. He won prizes in piano and composition, but tuition was a constant worry—he had to petition for reduced fees—and he earned his living by giving private lessons. (Bruckner) He was close to his classmates Hugo Wolf and Hans Rott, and at the University of Vienna he attended Anton Bruckner's lectures. When the premiere of Bruckner's Third Symphony failed in 1877 as the audience streamed out, Mahler and a fellow student arranged the work for piano four-hands, two players sharing one keyboard, helping it into print in 1880. The old composer was fond of the young man. (Rejection) He submitted his first large-scale work, the cantata 〈Das klagende Lied〉, for the Beethoven Prize in 1881, but it failed with a jury that included Johannes Brahms and the critic Eduard Hanslick. His friend Hans Rott, after Brahms coldly dismissed his symphony in 1880, suffered a mental collapse and died in 1884. Mahler later remembered Rott as the one who had first glimpsed the path of a new kind of symphony. (Wandering) Unable to live by composing, he took up the baton. Beginning in 1880 with a summer theater in the spa town of Bad Hall, he moved almost every year—to Laibach (today Ljubljana in Slovenia), Olmütz, Kassel, Prague and Leipzig. In 1883 he heard Richard Wagner's 〈Parsifal〉 at Bayreuth and was profoundly shaken. In Kassel he fell in love with the soprano Johanna Richter and was rejected, pouring the wound into the song cycle 〈Songs of a Wayfarer〉, setting words he wrote himself. (Leipzig) In Leipzig, working as second conductor under Arthur Nikisch, he completed Weber's unfinished opera 〈Die drei Pintos〉 and premiered it in 1888, and this success first made his name known. Around this time he also first met the young Richard Strauss.
A cycle of four songs Mahler composed, writing even the words himself, after Johanna Richter rejected him in Kassel. The melodies he made here soon migrate into the First Symphony.
- In the first song, ‘Wenn mein Schatz Hochzeit macht’, the merry strains of a distant wedding feast alternate with the grief of the one left behind. Listen for the passage where the woodwinds' dance rhythm crosses the heavy breathing of the voice.
- The bright melody of the second song, ‘Ging heut’ morgen übers Feld’, was used almost unchanged as the theme of the First Symphony's first movement. Hear the two back to back and you can witness a song becoming a symphony.
- The third song, ‘Ich hab’ ein glühend Messer’, is an eruption of rage, with brass and percussion roughly depicting a pain that pierces the heart.
- The fourth song, ‘Die zwei blauen Augen von meinem Schatz’, begins at the pace of a slow funeral march and fades away as the wanderer falls asleep beneath a linden tree. The melody of this closing section returns in the middle of the First Symphony's third movement.
III. Budapest and Hamburg · 1888–1897 (age 28–37)
(Budapest) In 1888, at twenty-eight, he became artistic director of the Royal Hungarian Opera. He rebuilt the house, pushing for performances in Hungarian rather than German, and Brahms, hearing the 〈Don Giovanni〉 he conducted in 1890, was deeply impressed. By contrast, the symphonic poem (later the First Symphony) that he premiered himself in November 1889 bewildered the audience with, among other things, a funeral march that twists the nursery round ‘Bruder Martin’ into the minor, and the reception was cold. (Loss) That same year his father died in February, his sister Leopoldine in September and his mother in October. Now the eldest surviving son, the twenty-nine-year-old Mahler took on the support of his siblings Alois, Otto, Justine and Emma, a burden that weighed on him for years. In 1895 his musically gifted brother Otto took his own life. (Hamburg) In 1891 he became principal conductor of the Hamburg Stadttheater. Pyotr Tchaikovsky, visiting the theater in 1892, entrusted Mahler with the German premiere of 〈Eugene Onegin〉 and called him a genius in a letter. Hans von Bülow thought highly of Mahler the conductor, but when Mahler played him 〈Totenfeier〉, the prototype of the Second Symphony's first movement, at the piano, Bülow covered his ears—or so Mahler reported. In 1894, when Klopstock's hymn ‘Die Auferstehung’ rang out at Bülow's funeral, Mahler found the thread for the Second Symphony's finale, which had been blocked for several years. (Hut) In summer he shut himself away in a small hut at Steinbach on the shore of the Attersee, composing in the mornings and walking and swimming in the afternoons. Here he finished the Second Symphony and wrote the Third. Walter's memoirs preserve the story that when the young Bruno Walter, visiting, gazed at the mountains, Mahler told him, “No need to look—I've already composed all that.” (Conversion) The summit post of the Vienna Court Opera was closed to Jews. In February 1897 he was baptized a Catholic; that spring he was appointed conductor of the Vienna Court Opera, and in the autumn its director.
This was the work spurned at its Budapest premiere. The songs of a wayfarer, military bugles, the raucous sound of Bohemian bands—the sounds of the life Mahler had lived are all gathered within it.
- At the opening of the first movement, while the strings hold a very high, faint note, the clarinet sounds a cuckoo's call with two falling notes. The score is marked ‘like a sound of nature’.
- In the third movement a solo double bass brings out the nursery round ‘Bruder Martin (Frère Jacques)’ turned into a dark minor key, and the other instruments follow with the same tune in turn, building up a round (canon). Whether this solo—deliberately made to sound awkward in a high register—is given to a single player or the whole section varies with the edition and the conductor.
- In the middle of the same third movement, oboes and cymbals break in with a raucous tune like a village wedding band. Like a popular song heard beside a funeral procession, tragedy and the everyday sound on top of each other.
- At the end of the fourth movement, Mahler instructed the horn players to rise from their seats and play. The moment the row of horns stands up in the concert hall is counted among the work's great scenes.
This is the work he completed in his Hamburg years after finding its thread at Bülow's funeral. Its arc, beginning in death and ending in a chorus of resurrection, holds the religious questioning of Mahler at the time.
- At the opening of the first movement, cellos and double basses spew out a fiercely surging figure above roughly trembling strings (tremolo). Originally the stand-alone symphonic poem 〈Totenfeier〉, the movement depicts a hero's funeral.
- In the fourth movement, ‘Urlicht’, the solo alto sings very quietly, “Man lies in greatest need.” These few minutes of stillness, set between the colossal movements on either side, are the heart of the work.
- In the fifth movement, horns and trumpets hidden offstage sound from afar, and a flute imitates birdsong. This is the ‘great summons’ that calls forth the Last Judgment—listen for which direction the sounds are coming from.
- The chorus begins unaccompanied, singing ‘Aufersteh’n’ so softly it can barely be heard. Mahler directed the chorus to begin singing while still seated.
IV. The Vienna Court Opera · 1897–1901 (age 37–41)
(Reform) As director, Mahler transformed the house from the roots up. He darkened the auditorium during performances, kept latecomers out until the act was over and drove out the hired applause squads (the claque) that singers paid to cheer for them. He restored passages customarily cut from Wagner's works, and demanded acting from the singers and from the orchestra exactly what was written in the score. (Stage) Many names from this series appear among the works he staged. In 1897 he introduced Smetana's 〈Dalibor〉 and Tchaikovsky's 〈Eugene Onegin〉 to Vienna, and in 1898 he chose to premiere Ruggero Leoncavallo's opera of the same title instead of Giacomo Puccini's 〈La bohème〉. Taking charge of the Vienna Philharmonic concerts, in 1899 he conducted Bruckner's Sixth Symphony—which the composer never heard complete in his lifetime—albeit in an abridged form. (Hostility) His rigor made enemies. Players and singers wearied of his sharp tongue and endless demands, and the antisemitic press relentlessly attacked the converted Jewish director. What he could least abide was complacency. The saying “Tradition is laziness” is attributed to him. (Summer) Unable to compose during the season, he called himself a ‘summer composer’. When the generous salary of the court director at last eased his finances, in 1899 he bought land at Maiernigg on the Wörthersee and built a villa and a composing hut in the woods. Drawing on his settings from the folk-poetry collection 『Des Knaben Wunderhorn』, he finished the Fourth Symphony in 1900. (Hemorrhage) In February 1901, on the night of a day when he had conducted twice, he collapsed with a severe hemorrhage and nearly died. That summer, after surgery and recovery, he set Rückert's poems to song in the voice of a man who had seen death up close, and began writing the Fifth Symphony. It was no accident that the Fifth opens with a funeral march.
V. Alma · 1901–1907 (age 41–47)
(Meeting) In November 1901, at a salon, he met Alma, daughter of the painter Emil Schindler. Nineteen years his junior, Alma was studying composition and was a celebrated beauty of Viennese society. A few weeks later Mahler sent her a long letter demanding that, if they married, she give up composing and shape her life around his music. Alma accepted, and the two married in March 1902. A day later his sister Justine married Arnold Rosé, concertmaster of the Vienna Philharmonic. (Daughters) Their first daughter, Maria Anna, was born in November 1902, and their second, Anna Justine, in June 1904. Mahler was a father who rolled about playing with his children. Anna later became a sculptor and died in 1988. (Confession) The Adagietto of the Fifth Symphony was a declaration of love to Alma—so the conductor Willem Mengelberg noted in his own score. Yet in the summer of 1904, when his second daughter was born, he completed 〈Kindertotenlieder〉 to Rückert's poems of a father's grief over his lost children. Alma recalled finding it ominous, asking why he would write such songs in a happy home. The Sixth Symphony of the same period ends in tragedy with colossal hammer blows. (Strauss) With Richard Strauss he had a relationship in which neither fully understood the other's music, yet each pushed the other forward. At the festival of the General German Music Association, which Strauss led, the Third Symphony received its first complete performance in 1902 to great success, and in 1905 Mahler tried to bring Strauss's 〈Salome〉 to the Viennese stage but was blocked by the censors. (Hymn) In the summer of 1906 he wrote the Eighth Symphony, joining the Latin hymn ‘Veni, creator spiritus’ to the final scene of Goethe's 『Faust』, in little more than two months. The work's conclusion, that love redeems, was the closest he came to putting his own faith into words.
Begun after the hemorrhage of 1901 that nearly killed him, it was completed in the period when he met and married Alma. It opens with a funeral march, passes through the Adagietto of love, and arrives at a bright finale.
- The first movement opens with a solo trumpet sounding, all alone, a fanfare of three short notes and a long one. It is a funeral march that recalls the military bugles of Iglau.
- The third movement is a fast, playful dance movement (scherzo) in which a solo horn shines as if in a concerto. Some performances even call the horn player to stand at the front of the stage.
- The fourth movement, the Adagietto, is played by strings and harp alone. Mengelberg wrote that it was a love letter to Alma. Its length varies widely from conductor to conductor, from just over 7 minutes to more than 12, so there is real pleasure in comparing fast and slow performances.
- Through its use in Luchino Visconti's film Death in Venice (1971), the Adagietto became the piece that brought Mahler to a wide public.
In a happy time when his two daughters were born and growing up, he wrote songs of a father who has lost a child. When his elder daughter Maria died three years later, the work came to be remembered as a prophecy.
- The first song, ‘Now the sun will rise as brightly,’ opens with two slender lines in oboe and horn intertwining like threads. It paints in sound the cruel composure of the text: though misfortune came in the night, the sun rises as if nothing had happened.
- Its orchestration is distinctive: rather than using the orchestra at full force, it treats it with the transparency of chamber music. Listen closely to a sound so thin that each instrument can be heard on its own.
- The fifth song, ‘In this weather, in this storm,’ begins with a storm raging through the orchestra, then, at the end, as the celesta (a keyboard instrument with a bell-like sound) enters, it settles into a lullaby. It is a consoling close: the children rest peacefully, as if in their mother's house.
- Both male and female singers perform it; compare a baritone, which sounds like the father's own voice, with a mezzo-soprano, which sounds like a wider grief, and the same work comes across differently.
VI. After 1907 · 1907–1910 (age 47–50)
(Collapse) 1907 was the year everything fell apart at once. Worn down by Vienna's hostility, Mahler decided to leave the Court Opera. In July, at Maiernigg, four-year-old Maria died of scarlet fever and diphtheria, and a few days later the doctor who examined him found a defect in his heart valves. A man who had loved walking, swimming and mountain climbing now had to live guarding his strength. (New York) In January 1908 he made his debut at the Metropolitan Opera in New York with Tristan und Isolde. The terms paid him far more for a season of a few months than he had earned in his Vienna years, and there was also a calculation to save money for his family's future. From 1909 he led the New York Philharmonic. In summer he returned to his hut at Toblach in South Tyrol (today Dobbiaco, Italy). (Earth) In this hut he wrote Das Lied von der Erde, based on Tang-dynasty poems translated by Hans Bethge. He gave no number to this symphony, which sings of parting and transience in the Eastern colors of the pentatonic scale. Alma relates that this was out of fear, born of the fact that both Beethoven and Bruckner had died after their ninth symphonies. He then completed Symphony No. 9. (Paris) When he conducted Symphony No. 2 in Paris in April 1910, according to Alma's recollection, Claude Debussy walked out during the second movement. It was a scene that revealed French musicians' distance from the German symphonic tradition. (Crisis) That summer it came to light that Alma had fallen in love with the young architect Walter Gropius. Deeply shaken, Mahler met Sigmund Freud in Leiden in the Netherlands in August, and the two walked and talked together for several hours. Afterward he brought out Alma's long-buried songs and hurried them into print, and he dedicated Symphony No. 8 to her. In September in Munich he premiered the Eighth with nearly a thousand performers and received the greatest ovation of his life.
Written at Toblach after he had lost his daughter and been diagnosed with heart disease. Leaning on Tang poetry, it sings of a farewell to life, and it avoided the name of a ninth symphony.
- In the first song, ‘The drinking song of the earth's sorrow,’ the refrain “Dark is life, dark is death” comes three times, each time a semitone higher and more desperate. The tenor part, which must cut through a dense orchestra, is notoriously difficult.
- The third song, ‘Of youth,’ uses a scale of only five notes (the pentatonic scale) to paint young people gathered in a porcelain pavilion, like an East Asian painting. The light sounds of piccolo and triangle are its hallmark.
- The sixth song, ‘The farewell,’ is as long as the five preceding songs combined. Amid low tam-tam strokes and birdsong-like ornaments in the flute, the soloist sings of parting alone.
- At the end the soloist repeats ‘forever (ewig)’ as the sound fades away, and over celesta and mandolin the final chord hangs in the air, never fully coming to rest.
VII. The last winter · 1910–1911 (age 50–51)
(Unfinished) In the margins of the score of Symphony No. 10, which he worked on that summer, are cries such as “To live for you! To die for you! Almschi!” Of its five movements, only the first, the Adagio, was nearly complete; the rest remained as a skeleton. The shaken marriage and the premonition of approaching death are etched directly into the score. (Pressing on) In the 1910–11 season he gave dozens of concerts with the New York Philharmonic. He was full of ambition, arranging Bach's orchestral suites himself and playing the keyboard part, but he clashed with the board of patrons over programming and management. (Illness) In February 1911, though suffering from a high fever, he conducted his last concert at Carnegie Hall on the 21st. The diagnosis was bacterial endocarditis, and in an age without antibiotics nothing could be done. In April he returned to Europe and underwent serum treatment in Paris, but there was no improvement, and in May he was taken to Vienna. (Death) On the night of May 18, 1911, he died in a Vienna sanatorium at the age of fifty. Alma wrote that at the end he kept murmuring “Mozartl” (an affectionate name for Mozart). As he had wished, he was buried beside his daughter Maria in Grinzing Cemetery, with only his name carved on the stone. Those who come looking for me will know who I was, he had said, and the rest need not know. (Legacy) Das Lied von der Erde was premiered that November and Symphony No. 9 the following June, both under Bruno Walter. In the Nazi era his music was banned as Jewish, but half a century later, with the arrival of the recording age, it became central to the repertoire of orchestras around the world. And so his words “My time will come” came true.
The last symphony Mahler completed; he did not live to see its premiere. It is often heard as the farewell of a man facing death.
- The first movement opens with cellos and horns in a rhythm that halts unevenly. Leonard Bernstein heard it as Mahler's irregular heartbeat, a widely known reading but not a proven one.
- At the climax of the first movement, trombones and trumpets hammer out that rhythm with full force. The score bears the instruction ‘like a heavy funeral procession.’
- The third movement, ‘Rondo-Burleske,’ is marked ‘very defiantly.’ Its counterpoint, weaving several melodies together at once, drives on breathlessly, and it is counted the most demanding movement for the players.
- In the last few minutes of the fourth movement, the Adagio, the strings grow ever softer, ‘dying away,’ until they vanish. This ending quietly quotes a melody from the fourth song of Kindertotenlieder. How long the audience stays silent after the last note fades is also part of what sets a great performance apart.
Lesser-known stories
When he met Freud in Leiden in 1910, Mahler confided a childhood memory: fleeing the house to escape a violent quarrel between his parents, he heard a street barrel organ playing the popular tune ‘Ach, du lieber Augustin.’ That, he said, was where the constant pairing of tragedy and triviality in his music came from. The story is secondhand, told by Freud to a disciple years later and written down by Ernest Jones in his biography of Freud, so Mahler biographies often leave it in a footnote. No recordings of Mahler conducting survive. The only way to hear him play is through four pieces he recorded on Welte-Mignon reproducing piano rolls in November 1905: piano arrangements of the first movement of Symphony No. 5 and the finale of No. 4, and two songs. Because of the nature of roll playback, how far the tempos and dynamics can be trusted is disputed, so they are discussed actively only among scholars. The story that the hammer blows of Symphony No. 6 foretold three blows of fate that would strike him, and the story that he feared a ninth symphony, come mostly from Alma's memoirs. Mahler himself removed the third hammer blow in revision. When Henry-Louis de La Grange and others compared the original letters, they also confirmed that Alma, in publishing her husband's letters, had cut or altered passages unflattering to herself. In 1910, through his brother-in-law Carl Moll, Mahler anonymously bought paintings by Schoenberg to help the struggling young composer. There is also a record that he worried about who would look after Schoenberg once he was gone. For a long time Alma refused to allow the unfinished Symphony No. 10 to be completed, but in 1924 she made a facsimile of the score public. She at first opposed the performing version prepared by the English musicologist Deryck Cooke as well, but after hearing a 1963 recording she allowed it to be performed.
Notes on terms 📚🔎
Symphony
(Literal meaning) Gyohyanggok (交響曲) means a piece in which sounds resound (響) together (交). The Western name, symphony, likewise comes from the Greek for ‘sounding together.’ (In music) A large work written for the full orchestra, usually in about four movements. In Haydn's and Mozart's day a symphony lasted around 30 minutes, but Mahler's run well over an hour and even include song and chorus. Mahler left words to the effect that “a symphony must be like the world; it must embrace everything.” Just as a novel is divided into many chapters yet tells a single story, the movements of a symphony stand apart yet form one great current. (Elsewhere) ‘Symphony’ is also used figuratively for a grand achievement in which many elements blend, as in the expression ‘a symphony of color.’
Song cycle
(Literal meaning) Yeongagok (連歌曲) means linked (連) songs (歌曲). (In music) A work that gathers several songs together so that, sung in order, they carry one person's story or the flow of a single emotion. Schubert's Winterreise is the classic example, and Mahler's Songs of a Wayfarer and Kindertotenlieder are song cycles too. Think of a ‘concept album,’ whose songs, heard in order, add up to a single story.
Canon
(Literal meaning) The Greek kanon means ‘measuring rod’ or ‘rule.’ The name comes from the way a later singer follows, exactly and by a fixed rule, the melody sung by the one before. (In music) A compositional method in which a melody begun by one part is imitated exactly by another part a little later, the two overlapping as they go. When a class sings the round ‘Let's all go round the neighborhood’ in groups, each starting one bar later, that is a canon. In the third movement of Symphony No. 1, Mahler shifted the round ‘Frère Jacques’ into the minor and made it into a canon like a funeral march. (Elsewhere) ‘Canon’ also refers, in religion, to the canon (the recognized scriptures), and in literature and film to the official continuity of the original work.
Orchestration
(Word meaning) Gwanhyeonak (管絃樂) is music made with gwan (管, wind instruments) and hyeon (絃, string instruments), that is, orchestral music. Gwanhyeonakbeop means the method of handling those instruments. (In music) Even the same melody and harmony can sound completely different depending on which instruments carry it and how they are blended. The craft of deciding this is orchestration. Mahler, even while writing for a gigantic orchestra, excelled at leaving just one or two instruments to ring out as transparently as chamber music. It is much like how the same ingredients become an entirely different dish depending on whether you bake or steam them, and which seasonings you add.
Adagietto
(Word meaning) The Italian adagio ('slowly') with the suffix -etto, meaning 'a little, small,' attached to it; it means 'somewhat slowly' or 'a little adagio.' (In music) The term refers to a tempo slightly less slow than adagio, and it is also used as the name of a short movement in that tempo. The most famous is the Adagietto, the 4th movement of Mahler's Symphony No. 5. Yet conductors interpret the same 'somewhat slowly' so differently that performances range from 7 minutes to more than 12. It is like a teacher saying 'let's read slowly,' and every student reading at a different pace.
Hired applauders (claque)
(Word meaning) The French claque comes from the 'smack' of palms striking together, that is, from clapping. (In music) In the opera houses of 19th-century Europe, this was a band of people who took money from singers or composers and sat in the audience, deliberately applauding and cheering for them. Conversely, they would shower singers who did not pay with boos. When Mahler became director of the Vienna Court Opera, he drove them out. Think of a sports team paying for a cheering squad to whip up the atmosphere.
5-note scale
(In music) A scale that uses only five notes within an octave. Press only the five black keys of a piano and you have a 5-note scale at once; however you play them, they never clash, and they give off an Eastern or folk-song feeling. It is widely used in Korean folk songs, in Chinese and Japanese music, and in Scottish folk songs. Mahler used this scale in Das Lied von der Erde to evoke the mood of Tang dynasty poetry. If in music class you ever found that striking only the black keys at random still produced a plausible tune, that was a 5-note scale. (Elsewhere) In English it is called the pentatonic scale, and it is also the scale most used in rock and blues guitar solos.