novareads.musicClassical

Dmitri Shostakovich

1906–1975

One man who survived an age of terror left in notes what could never be said in words.

At a glance 🔭💭

1. RootsBorn in Saint Petersburg, Ru…A father's death and povertySymphony No. 12. ExperimentSollertinsky and MahlerThe opera The NoseLady Macbeth3. Terror“Muddle Instead of Music”The Great Purge and silenceSymphony No. 54. WarFirefighterLeningrad SymphonyPiano Trio No. 25. The desk drawerZhdanov decreeBach and the preludes·fuguesDSCH signature6. Final yearsString Quartet No. 8Britten·Symphony No. 14Viola SonataShostakovich1906–1975A Soviet composer who endured the terror of th…
A life's journey 🧭🗺️
NRussiaSaint Petersburg (Leningrad)1906–1941Kuibyshev (today Samara)1941–1943Moscow1943–1975

Some coordinates adapted from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0) · Pleiades (CC BY 3.0)

Those close to him ⏳🌊

  • FamilySofya Shostakovich

    His first piano teacher, and the mother who, after losing her husband, kept the family afloat and safeguarded her son's musical education.

  • PatronageAlexander Glazunov

    As director of the Petrograd Conservatory, he secured rations and a stipend for the boy during the starving years of the Civil War.

  • FriendshipIvan Sollertinsky

    A lifelong friend who introduced him to Mahler's music; his sudden death gave rise to the Piano Trio No. 2.

  • FamilyNina Varzar

    His first wife and the companion who endured the years of terror at his side; Lady Macbeth was dedicated to her.

  • RivalrySergei Prokofiev

    The two pillars of Soviet music, they were keenly aware of each other; both were condemned in 1948, and Prokofiev died on the same day as Stalin.

  • FriendshipBenjamin Britten

    An English composer with whom he exchanged dedications; Shostakovich dedicated his Symphony No. 14 to him.

Play all 7 on YouTube ↗

I. The boy from Petrograd · 1906–1926 (age 0–20)

(Birth) He was born in September 1906 in Saint Petersburg, in the Russian Empire (today Russia). His father, Dmitri Boleslavovich, was a chemical engineer from a family of Polish descent that had been exiled to Siberia, and he worked at the Bureau of Weights and Measures headed by Mendeleev. His mother, Sofiya Vasilyevna, had studied piano at the conservatory. He had an older sister, Mariya, and a younger sister, Zoya. (Piano) He did not begin piano lessons with his mother until 1915, at the age of nine, but his progress was astonishing. In 1919, at thirteen, he entered the Petrograd Conservatory, studying piano with Leonid Nikolayev and composition with Maximilian Steinberg. Steinberg was Rimsky-Korsakov’s son-in-law, and the director, Alexander Glazunov, worked to ensure that the boy received rations and a scholarship amid the hunger of the Civil War years. (Hardship) When his father died of pneumonia in February 1922, the family soon fell into poverty. His mother worked as a clerk, and the seventeen-year-old Shostakovich helped cover expenses by playing accompaniment for silent films in movie theaters. In 1923 he convalesced in Crimea from tuberculosis of the lymph glands, and there he met his first love, Tatyana Glivenko. The graduation piece he wrote between theater work and illness was the Symphony No. 1. Premiered in May 1926 under Nikolai Malko, it was taken up within a few years by Bruno Walter and Toscanini, carrying the nineteen-year-old composer onto the international stage.

♪Symphony No. 1 in F minor, Op. 101924–1925 (age 18–19)Live: Seoul Philharmonic Orchestra · Wilson Ng, conductor

The graduation piece of a nineteen-year-old student who had lost his father and was playing accompaniment in movie theaters. It holds both the wit of a silent-film pianist and the shadows of youth.

  • Listen to the brief dialogue at the opening of the first movement between the trumpet, played with a mute (a stopper that softens the sound), and the bassoon. Mocking and playful, like a puppet show on a stage, its tone announces the character of the whole work.
  • In the second-movement scherzo, the piano enters not as a concerto soloist but as one more instrument of the orchestra, hammering out rapidly rising and falling scales and forceful chords.
  • The oboe solo of the third movement begins as a slow, lonely melody and gradually swells into something heavier. Listen with the thought that it was written just after he lost his father, and its weight feels different.
  • The passage at the heart of the fourth movement where the timpani pounds out a loud solo on its own is the most talked-about moment in the work. It is also counted among the classic showpieces for comparing timpanists’ skill.
Listen on YouTube ↗

II. Years of experiment · 1926–1935 (age 20–29)

(Competition) In January 1927 he entered the first International Chopin Piano Competition in Warsaw; he did not place, but received an honorable diploma. Torn between the paths of pianist and composer, he gradually leaned toward composition. That same year, when Alban Berg’s opera Wozzeck was staged in Leningrad, he met Berg in person, and the experience left a lasting mark on his music for the stage. (Sollertinsky) Ivan Sollertinsky, a linguist and critic he met in 1927, became a lifelong friend. Erudite and outspoken, he opened up Gustav Mahler’s symphonies to Shostakovich. In these years Shostakovich worked as a pianist at the director Meyerhold’s theater and, writing in quick succession the opera The Nose after Gogol, the ballet The Golden Age and film scores, gave free rein to his satirical, experimental temperament. He had also been an ardent football fan since childhood. (Marriage) In 1932 he married Nina Varzar, who had studied physics. The marriage came after several years of hesitation and had its ups and downs afterward, but Nina was the companion he relied on most. He dedicated to her the opera he completed around this time, Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District — the story of Katerina, a woman trapped in a stifling merchant household, who drives her father-in-law and her husband to their deaths. Premiered in January 1934, the opera was staged again and again in Leningrad and Moscow over two years and was performed in Europe and America as well.

III. Muddle instead of music · 1936–1941 (age 30–35)

(Editorial) In January 1936 Stalin attended a performance of Lady Macbeth and left before it was over. Two days later Pravda ran an unsigned editorial, “Muddle Instead of Music.” It assailed the opera as chaotic and vulgar and warned that such games could end very badly. The production soon vanished, and many who had praised him turned their backs. (Silence) That May his daughter was born. He completed his Fourth Symphony, deep in Mahler’s shadow, and took it as far as rehearsals, but in December he withdrew it himself. It was not premiered until 1961, 25 years later. The following year the Great Purge reached its height. His patron, Marshal Tukhachevsky, was executed; his sister Mariya’s husband was arrested, and Mariya herself was exiled. Recollections of family and friends tell of him keeping a suitcase packed, braced for arrest. (Comeback) In 1937 he began teaching at the Leningrad Conservatory, and in November his Fifth Symphony was premiered under Yevgeny Mravinsky. The applause went on for more than 30 minutes, and many listeners recalled weeping during the slow third movement. He publicly accepted the phrase a journalist attached to the work, ‘a Soviet artist’s creative response to just criticism.’ In 1938 his son Maxim was born, and he wrote his first string quartet. Around this time he also began reorchestrating Mussorgsky’s Boris Godunov in a form closer to the original.

♪Symphony No. 5 in D minor, Op. 471937 (age 31)

The comeback symphony, written in the thick of the Great Purge after “Muddle Instead of Music.” Officially it was a ‘response to just criticism,’ but audiences heard something else in it.

  • At the opening of the first movement, the strings take up in turn a melody that jumps widely between high and low notes (wide leaps). From the very first sound, a sharp, uneasy tension is laid down.
  • The third-movement Largo leaves out the brass entirely and divides the strings into many finely split parts. Accounts survive of many listeners weeping during this movement at the premiere.
  • In the closing pages of the finale, the note la (A) is repeated endlessly while the timpani and bass drum pound. Whether this is genuine triumph or forced rejoicing is still debated today.
  • Because readings of the score’s tempo marking differ, that same ending of the finale is played slow and heavy by some conductors, fast and brilliant by others. Compare several recordings and the work leaves a very different impression.
Listen on YouTube ↗

IV. The besieged city · 1941–1947 (age 35–41)

(Fire brigade) When Germany invaded in June 1941 he volunteered for the army but was turned down, and instead joined the conservatory’s fire brigade, keeping watch for fires from the rooftops. A photograph of him in a firefighter’s helmet appeared on the cover of America’s Time magazine the following year. He began his Seventh Symphony in Leningrad as the siege set in, and in October evacuated with his family to Kuibyshev on the Volga, where he finished it in December. (Leningrad) Premiered in Kuibyshev in March 1942, the Seventh soon became known as the ‘Leningrad’ Symphony. The score, on microfilm, traveled via Tehran and Cairo to the United States, where Toscanini conducted it on the radio; in August, in besieged Leningrad, a starving radio orchestra performed it under Karl Eliasberg. The work won him a Stalin Prize that came with a large sum of money. Meanwhile Béla Bartók, then in America, quoted its march theme mockingly in the fourth movement of his Concerto for Orchestra. (Loss) In 1943 he moved to Moscow, became a professor at the Moscow Conservatory, and wrote his Eighth Symphony, which confronts the horrors of war head-on. When Sollertinsky died suddenly in February 1944 at forty-one, he wrote the Piano Trio No. 2 in his memory. Its finale, in the style of a Jewish folk dance, is widely heard as echoing the news then emerging of massacres in the Nazi camps. In 1945, before authorities who expected a monumental ‘Ninth’ to celebrate victory, he set a short, lighthearted Ninth Symphony, and it soon brought him trouble.

♪Symphony No. 7 in C major, “Leningrad,” Op. 601941 (age 35)Live: Mariinsky Theatre

Begun in besieged Leningrad and completed in Kuibyshev, where he had been evacuated. When starving musicians performed it in the besieged city, it became a symbol of the war.

  • In the so-called ‘invasion episode’ at the heart of the first movement, while the snare drum repeats the same rhythm to the very end, a simple march tune is repeated more than eleven times, growing steadily louder. The passage is often compared to Maurice Ravel’s Boléro.
  • The march tune begins light and comical, but as the brass join in it turns into a huge, merciless sound. This is the very tune Bartók quoted mockingly in his Concerto for Orchestra.
  • The third-movement Adagio opens with a passage in which the woodwinds sing in harmony like a church hymn (chorale). The composer once said he had captured scenes of his home city in this movement.
  • At the end of the finale, the first theme of the first movement returns loudly in the brass. Listen for the moment when, after long darkness, it ends on a bright C major chord.
Listen on YouTube ↗

V. Music in the drawer · 1948–1953 (age 42–47)

(Resolution) In February 1948 the Party Central Committee, led by the ideology chief Zhdanov, issued a resolution condemning ‘formalism.’ Shostakovich was singled out along with Sergei Prokofiev, Khachaturian, Myaskovsky and others, and lost his professorships at both the Moscow and Leningrad conservatories. His income came from film scores and works glorifying the regime, such as the oratorio Song of the Forests. Meanwhile he wrote the Violin Concerto No. 1 and the song cycle From Jewish Folk Poetry and put them away in a drawer, unperformed. (New York) In 1949 Stalin telephoned him personally to tell him to join the delegation to a peace conference in New York. There he had to read out a prepared speech, and when the émigré composer Nicolas Nabokov asked whether he agreed with Pravda’s condemnation of Igor Stravinsky, he had no choice but to say that he did. Contemporaries remembered him as shy and intensely nervous, punctual to a fault, and a chain smoker. (Bach) In 1950, for the 200th anniversary of Bach’s death, he went to Leipzig as a juror for the Bach Competition; stirred by the playing of the winner, Tatiana Nikolayeva, he wrote his 24 Preludes and Fugues as soon as he returned. On March 5, 1953, Stalin and Prokofiev died on the same day. His Tenth Symphony, premiered that winter, is stamped throughout with the D–E♭–C–B (DSCH) motif, his initials rendered as German note names.

♪Violin Concerto No. 1 in A minor, Op. 77 (Op. 99)1947–1948 (age 41–42)Performance: Augustin Hadelich (violin) · WDR

Written in the year of the Zhdanov resolution and kept in a drawer for 7 years. Only after Stalin’s death did it come before the world, with Oistrakh as soloist.

  • The first movement, ‘Nocturne,’ has the violin singing in its low, dark register as if drawing long breaths. It is an opening like a soliloquy, the very opposite of a dazzling concerto’s start.
  • In the second-movement scherzo, the composer’s name motif (DSCH) appears in hiding alongside a melody like a Jewish folk dance. Follow the sharply bouncing rhythms of the violin.
  • The third movement, a passacaglia, has the cellos and double basses repeat the same bass line while the violins build variations above it. It is the tragic movement on which the whole work's weight rests.
  • The long cadenza (a passage the soloist plays alone) at the end of the third movement is a notorious hurdle among violinists. The story goes that when Oistrakh asked for a moment to catch his breath, the composer handed the finale's opening melody over to the orchestra.
Listen on YouTube ↗
♪24 Preludes and Fugues, Op. 871950–1951 (age 44–45)Performance: Keigo Mukawa (piano) · 2021 Queen Elisabeth Competition

He wrote this cycle after returning from Leipzig, where he had marked the 200th anniversary of Bach's death. In a time of terror, he stepped inside Bach's forms and quietly kept hold of his own voice.

  • The Prelude No. 1 in C major recalls No. 1 of Book 1 of Bach's The Well-Tempered Clavier, also in C major. Hear the two side by side and it becomes clear that this work is a greeting to Bach.
  • The pieces move in order through pairs of a major key and its relative minor: C major, A minor, G major, E minor, and so on. It is the same order as Chopin's 24 Preludes.
  • In each fugue, a single melody is taken up in turn by several parts (voices), as in a round. Listen for the moments when the same melody reappears in the right hand or the left.
  • The final fugue, No. 24 in D minor, is a monumental close that stacks two subjects one atop the other. The recording by Tatiana Nikolayeva, who gave the premiere, is still regarded as the benchmark.
Listen on YouTube ↗

VI. In the shadow of the thaw · 1954–1966 (age 48–60)

(Loss) In December 1954 Nina died suddenly of cancer, and the following year his mother died as well. He remarried in 1956, but the marriage ended within a few years. In 1955 the Violin Concerto No. 1 at last saw the light of day, with David Oistrakh as soloist, and in 1957 he wrote the bright, playful Piano Concerto No. 2 for the birthday of his son Maxim, then a conservatory student. In 1959 he wrote the Cello Concerto No. 1 for Mstislav Rostropovich. (The Party) Around 1958 an illness began to sap the strength of his right hand. In 1960 he finally gave in and joined the Communist Party, which he had long avoided, and friends recalled how deeply he suffered at the time. That July, near Dresden, he wrote the String Quartet No. 8 in three days; it was officially dedicated to 'the victims of fascism and war,' but in a letter to his friend Isaak Glikman he called it a memorial piece for himself. (Babi Yar) In 1962 he married the literary editor Irina Supinskaya, a marriage that lasted until his final day. That December saw the premiere of the Symphony No. 13, Babi Yar, setting poems by Yevgeny Yevtushenko about the massacre of Jews outside Kyiv. Mravinsky declined to conduct, so Kirill Kondrashin took it on, and the performance went ahead despite pressure from the authorities. The following year Katerina Izmailova, a revision of Lady Macbeth, returned to the stage. In 1966 he suffered his first heart attack.

♪String Quartet No. 8 in C minor, Op. 1101960 (age 54)Performance: Borodin Quartet · 2002

He wrote it in three days near Dresden, just after joining the Communist Party. The official dedication was to the victims of war, but to a friend he confided that it was a memorial piece for himself.

  • At the opening of the first movement, the cello slowly plays the composer's name figure, D-E♭-C-B (DSCH), and the other instruments take it up one by one. The entire work grows out of these four notes.
  • Quotations from his own earlier works are scattered throughout. Listen for the Symphonies Nos. 1 and 5, the Jewish melody from the Piano Trio No. 2, the Cello Concerto No. 1, and a melody from Lady Macbeth.
  • The second movement is a fast movement in which the four instruments race along as if possessed, and the Jewish dance melody from the Piano Trio No. 2 bursts out like a scream.
  • Some hear the loud chords that strike three times over in the fourth movement as a knock on the door in the night. This movement also contains the melody of the old Russian revolutionary song “Tormented by Grievous Bondage.”
Listen on YouTube ↗

VII. Facing death · 1966–1975 (age 60–69)

(Illness) His illness worsened. He broke his leg twice, suffered a second heart attack in 1971, and found it hard even to write with his right hand. He went so far as to seek out the surgeon Ilizarov for treatment at his hospital in distant Kurgan. His 1962 orchestration of Mussorgsky's Songs and Dances of Death led on to the Symphony No. 14 in 1969. He dedicated this work, which sings of nothing but death in eleven poems by Lorca, Apollinaire, Rilke and others, to Benjamin Britten, who conducted it the following year in Aldeburgh, England. (Quotations) His last symphony, No. 15, from 1971, quotes Rossini's William Tell Overture and the 'fate motif' from Wagner's Der Ring des Nibelungen. He never explained what they meant. The following January, Maxim, now a conductor, gave the premiere. In 1974 he wrote, one after another, the String Quartet No. 15 and a song cycle on poems by Michelangelo. The Fifteenth Quartet, six slow movements in succession, is counted among the stillest and darkest of all his music. (The end) In July 1975, from his sickbed, he completed the Viola Sonata. He called the last movement an 'Adagio in memory of Beethoven,' and the figure from the first movement of the Moonlight Sonata seeps through it. On August 9 of that year he died of lung cancer in Moscow and was buried in Novodevichy Cemetery. Fifteen symphonies and fifteen string quartets remain as a record of the era he lived through.

♪Viola Sonata, Op. 1471975 (age 69)Performance: Yuri Bashmet (viola) · Mikhail Muntyan

His last work, completed on his sickbed a few weeks before his death. He brought it to a close like a farewell addressed to Beethoven.

  • At the opening of the first movement, the viola plucks its strings with the fingers instead of the bow (pizzicato), sounding a bare, empty fifth. This unadorned beginning sets the quiet mood of the whole work.
  • The second movement draws on material from The Gamblers, an opera after Gogol that he began in the 1940s and abandoned. Its staggering, comic rhythms stand in contrast to the silence of the movements around it.
  • The triplet figure the piano plays in the third movement comes from the first movement of Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata. Above it, the viola sings a long, low melody.
  • At the end, the viola and piano gradually fade, closing as though the sound itself were vanishing. Hold your breath and listen until the very moment the last note dies away.
Listen on YouTube ↗

Lesser-known stories

In 1927 the conductor Nikolai Malko bet Shostakovich that he could not orchestrate the American song “Tea for Two” within an hour. Working from memory, he finished the arrangement in forty-five minutes, and the result was “Tahiti Trot” (Op. 16). Overshadowed by the story of his political ordeals, it is rarely mentioned, yet it shows just how quick and lighthearted a hand the young composer had. He did not merely enjoy football. He went through referee training and earned his certificate, and as a supporter of the Leningrad team Zenit he kept meticulous notebooks of match results and goal scorers. The composer remembered only in images of fear and silence was, in the stadium, a spectator who cheered louder than anyone. When his friend and fellow composer Mieczysław Weinberg was arrested in early 1953, Shostakovich risked his own safety to write to the secret police chief Beria pleading for his release. According to the testimony of Weinberg's wife, he had even prepared a power of attorney so that he could take in their young daughter if she, too, were arrested. Weinberg was freed after Stalin died. The episode became known only belatedly, through the recollections of those involved. In 2004, in the archive of the Glinka Museum in Moscow, a researcher found the piano sketches for Orango, a satirical opera he had begun and abandoned in 1932. The work, with its bizarre subject of a cross between human and ape, had lain buried in a pile of unsorted manuscripts for more than half a century. It was later completed in orchestral form and premiered in Los Angeles in 2011, and his catalogue of works is still growing, little by little, out of the archives.

Notes on terms 📚🔎

Symphony

(The word) The Korean word gyohyanggok (交響曲) means a piece in which many sounds join together (交) and resound (響). The Western name, symphony, likewise comes from the Greek symphonia, 'sounding together.' (In music) A large-scale work written for orchestra, usually made up of three or four movements of contrasting character. A fast, tense movement, a slow, singing movement, a light, playful movement and a vigorous closing movement might follow one after another. It is much like a coursed meal, where soup, main course and dessert differ in flavor and mood yet add up to a single dinner. Shostakovich left fifteen such symphonies.

String quartet

(In music) Music played together by four people, on two violins, a viola and a cello, or the ensemble that plays it. With no conductor, the four players stay together by watching each other's breathing and glances, so it sounds far more like a private, heartfelt conversation than an orchestra does. It resembles a group project in which four people each handle their own part while trading ideas to complete a single presentation. Shostakovich poured into his quartets many of the personal stories he could not tell in his symphonies.

Fugue

(The word) Fuga is Latin for 'flight.' The name comes from the way one melody runs off ahead while another gives chase. (In music) A method of composition in which a single short subject is taken up in turn by several parts (voices) and layered one upon another. It is like a round, where the next singer follows the same tune a beat behind, except that in a fugue the following voice shifts to a different pitch, and everything is intricately woven so the parts blend rather than clash. Bach was the master of this form, and Shostakovich wrote twenty-four fugues in his honor.

Passacaglia

(The word) It is thought to come from the Spanish pasacalle, meaning 'to pass (pasar) through the street (calle).' The name originally came from a dance tune played while walking through the streets. (In music) A form in which the same melody is repeated over and over in the bass while other instruments build a different variation above it each time. Picture a game of jump rope: the rhythm of the turning rope stays the same throughout, but the children who jump in show different moves each time. Because the same bass line repeats so relentlessly, the form is often used to create a heavy, solemn, tragic feeling. Shostakovich used it in the Violin Concerto No. 1, Lady Macbeth and elsewhere.

Motif

(The word) It derives from the Latin movere (to move); in Hanja it is 動機 (donggi), meaning a thread that sets something in motion. (In music) The smallest musical unit of a piece, a short figure of just a few notes. Composers stretch, invert and stack these small fragments to build large works. Like the short sound effect that plays whenever a certain character appears in a game, a motif tells the listener who or what has just entered. Shostakovich turned the initials of his own name into the notes D-E♭-C-B (DSCH) and engraved this motif, like a signature, into many of his works. (Elsewhere) In art and literature it refers to the central material or theme of a work, and in everyday speech to the reason that prompted someone to do something.

Scherzo

(The word) Scherzo is Italian for 'joke' or 'jest.' (In music) A fast, lively movement found within a symphony or quartet, with a comic or giddy character. It serves to change the mood between heavy, lengthy movements. It is like joking and laughing with friends during the break between long, difficult classes. Shostakovich's scherzos, however, often hide sharp sarcasm or terror behind the laughter, so that they frequently sound like someone smiling while seething with anger.

Cadenza

(Etymology) The Italian cadenza comes from the Latin cadere ('to fall'). It first named the passage where a piece arrives at its close, and its present meaning grew from the display of skill a soloist would offer just before that close. (In music) The passage in a concerto where the orchestra falls silent and the soloist alone gives free rein to technique and expression. It is like the moment at a school talent show when everyone is dancing together and one person steps out to center stage to show what they can do alone. The cadenza of Shostakovich's Violin Concerto No. 1 is long and difficult, and notorious among performers.

Orchestration

(In music) The work of rewriting music composed for few instruments, such as a piano piece or a song, so that it is shared out among the many instruments of the orchestra. Giving one melody to the violins and a certain chord to the brass, the arranger decides the colors of the sound. It is much like taking a pencil sketch and deciding which paint goes where. Shostakovich learned a great deal from Mussorgsky's music by orchestrating his Boris Godunov and Songs and Dances of Death. (Elsewhere) In computing, the English word orchestration also refers to automatically coordinating many servers and programs so that they run together.